GoodBuy Gear is the leader in quality-checked open box and secondhand gear for families. Shop 2,600+ brands and save an average of 55% off retail, every item inspected by our experts.
GoodBuy Gear (goodbuygear.com) has 365 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.1 out of 5.
Also known as
goodbuygear.com
Website
goodbuygear.com
Category
Malls & Marketplaces
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 97% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
This site is fantastic. There was slight damage done by them in the packing of the shipment but they responded immediately and bought replacement parts to fix it. Could not be happier with how they handled it.
Response from GoodBuy GearAug 26, 2026
Thank you for the kind words! Packing mishaps happen from time to time, but we're glad we could jump in fast and get you sorted with replacement parts. That's the "we'll always make it right" promise in action. Thanks for hanging in there with us, and happy gearing up!
ET
Erica T.
What a disaster the process has been…
What a disaster the process has been working with goodbuy gear. I sent an unopened baby item to sell. The product quickly sold and I earned $200 in site credit. I used it to buy a "mini crib mattress", but the listing on their site was incorrect and the mattress ended up being a full size mattress once I opened the compressed packaging. Fail. I've yet to find a way to speak to a human, but Fin their AI assistant is easily the worst I've ever communicated with. Finally they refunded me the money from the mattress but now the credit has yet to be sent to me (2 weeks later) so I can attempt to get another item I need for our kiddo. So I'm again communicating with Fin, who continues to tell me to email connect @goodbuygear.com for help ... which is the exact email address FOR FIN which we are communicating on. What a complete joke. I will never, ever sell on Goodbuy Gear again. And having now purchased a handful of items here prior to this situation, they've lost me as a customer after this credit has been used. The only reason I'm giving two stars here is because I did... finally... get a refund for the mattress without having to send it back. Since there's no real way to pack up a 3x4' mattress without an existing box.
Response from GoodBuy GearAug 26, 2026
We're sorry this happened, especially the trouble getting a real person on the line. This has been escalated to our team to resolve. Thank you for the feedback on Fin, it helps us improve. Note: you can always ask Fin for a human, and it'll route you to our team directly.
CK
Chandler K.
Shipping was super fast
Shipping was super fast. Product arrived as expected. Actually came in original packaging and looked completely unused.
Response from GoodBuy GearAug 26, 2026
This is music to our ears! Fast shipping and gear that looks brand new? That's the good stuff. Thanks for trusting us with your purchase, we hope it's a great fit for your little one!
HD
Honey D.
The wagon I bought came with missing…
The wagon I bought came with missing parts. So disappointing . I emailed customer service let’s see
Response from GoodBuy GearAug 26, 2026
Sorry to hear about the missing parts, that shouldn't have happened. Our team is on it via email and will get this sorted for you.
ME
Maria Erlinda A.
Good buys!!
Good buys!!
Response from GoodBuy GearAug 26, 2026
We see what you did there, and we love it! "Goodbuys" are our specialty. Thanks for shopping with us!
RO
Rose
Well worth the price!…
Quick delivery and the quality of the baby bouncer was excellent. I would recommend this company for quality baby products at very reasonable prices.
Response from GoodBuy GearAug 26, 2026
Yay, happy baby, happy parent! Quick delivery and quality gear at a price that doesn't hurt is basically our whole mission in a nutshell. Thanks for the recommendation, and happy bouncing!
MM
Makayla M.
Great quality items
Great quality items, barely used if anything! So glad I was able to get these for my son!
Response from GoodBuy GearAug 19, 2026
This is so wonderful to hear! We're so glad you found great quality pieces for your son, and that they were barely used to boot. Thanks for shopping secondhand with us!
AP
Ana-Paula I.
DON'T DO IT!
Do not purchase from these people. I have honestly had the worst experience.
I purchased opened box items. The items were purchased and within 3 hours of purchase II got a sale notification on the items I'd just bought. So I reached out and asked if they would honor the discount. I was told they wouldn't as the item I selected was from a third party seller. Super suspicious considering everything they say they test and mark as meeting strict quality control checks. When I pushed back and said that I didn't actually select the seller, it auto selected for me based on the color I selected, I was basically given the store policy again. I even sent them the auto select which was applying to everything on their sites. But they said I had still selected the seller. If you built your website to auto select and then you added me to your auto sale notifications within a couple of hours of purchase, I'm sorry but you should honor the discount. So I eventually left it. When everything arrived, I discovered I had double of the car seat adaptors. One set came with the stroller, the other I purchased due to it not being listed on description. So I contacted them, and their AI agent said no problem submit for return. I get an email this morning from them that I ca't return the extra adaptor...what exactly would you like me to do with the extra adaptors? Then I was told I could have purchased their protection for $45 to return the adaptors for $43 dollars...make this make sense. And they claim it was the seller I again selected, had it in the description...to which I was like, the seller you auto selected for me and supposedly didn't go on sale like all the rest, but the same seller you couldn't point to during my last inquiry. Did I save money yes, but customer service is horrid and now I get to throw away $43 dollars of equipment I don't need. It's gross, especially considering the total order was well over $1,600.
Response from GoodBuy GearAug 19, 2026
Thank you for the detailed feedback, we've shared this with our team. We're glad we could refund the adapters for you. Our team did reach out regarding making that exception, and we apologize for in confusion on that! To clarify on pricing, the item you purchased was a separate listing from the one that was priced differently, which we did explain during your inquiry. To clarify again, we are a consignment based business and every listing is separate, our pricing on secondhand gear can vary quite a bit depending on inventory, condition, and availability. If you have any other questions, please reach out to us at [email protected].