GoodBuy Gear is the leader in quality-checked open box and secondhand gear for families. Shop 2,600+ brands and save an average of 55% off retail, every item inspected by our experts.
GoodBuy Gear (goodbuygear.com) has 365 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.1 out of 5.
Also known as
goodbuygear.com
Website
goodbuygear.com
Category
Malls & Marketplaces
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 97% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
I ordered a pack and play and it came in perfect condition, even included the changing table apparatus which I wasn't expecting!
Loving this website.
Response from GoodBuy GearMay 6, 2026
That little bonus made our day to read! We love when an item comes through with all its extras intact, that's the GoodBuy Gear experience we work so hard for. Enjoy that pack and play with your little one! 🎉
MR
Mio R.
Extremely disappointed in Good Buy Gear
Extremely disappointed in Good Buy Gear.
On April 21, 2026, I purchased a Silver Cross Dune Stroller (2022, Stone Tan, SKU 10007408.1.820) from GoodBuy Gear for $399.99. When it arrived, the canopy - an integral, built-in part of the seat unit - was missing.
I filed a claim with GoodBuy Gear. My claim was denied by a representative named Victoria, who stated that "the listing noted that the canopy was missing." This is false.
I have screenshots of the full listing showing:
- No mention of a missing canopy in the title, description, or condition notes
- A "What's Included" section that lists Rain Cover (Yes), Belly Bar (Yes), and Sun Sail (Yes) - with no disclosure of the canopy being absent
The canopy is not an optional accessory. It is a structural component physically attached to and part of the seat unit. I cannot purchase it from Silver Cross's website as an "accessory" because it's not an accessory. Silver Cross's own product documentation titles the stroller "Dune Chassis & Seat" - the canopy is inseparable from the seat.
Moreover, I checked other listings of the exact same stroller in different colors, and none of them specified that the canopy was included. The listings are exactly the same word for word. Yet those listings included the canopy. One was sold for $295.16 - more than $100 LESS than what I paid, and it was a complete stroller. Another was sold for $379.99 - $20 less than what I paid, yet was also complete. Why did I pay THE MOST for a stroller that was missing an integral part?
GoodBuy Gear sold me an incomplete item without disclosure, then denied my claim based on an inaccurate characterization of the listing. I am requesting either a full refund with a prepaid return label, a replacement of the entire stroller with a canopy included, or a replacement canopy provided at GoodBuy Gear's expense.
Desired Resolution: Full refund OR replacement stroller or canopy shipped at seller's expense.
Response from GoodBuy GearMay 6, 2026
Thank you for taking the time to share this in detail, we hear you, and we understand how frustrating this experience has been. We're sorry for the disappointment this has caused.
Our team has been in touch via email and have reached out with next steps regarding a return. We want to make sure this is resolved for you and ask that you check your inbox and reply at your earliest convenience so we can get this taken care of.
KR
Kari R.
Good service, items arrived as described
I've made a couple of purchases from this site. Everything has come as described, and shipped really quickly. Overall, I've gotten what I've expected, packaged well. Very happy with the website and will purchase here again.
Response from GoodBuy GearMay 6, 2026
Thank you for coming back, that means the world to us! Knowing you've had a consistent experience across multiple orders is exactly what we're going for. See you for the next one!
ED
Emily D.
Honest, transparent company
Great gear. Transparent listings. I've been buying from goodbuy gear for a while now. On a recent order there was a small mixup that was an honest mistake and Trixia went above and beyond to help me get it resolved. I tell everyone I know about goodbuy gear. Good for your wallet AND the planet!
Response from GoodBuy GearMay 6, 2026
This made us smile, thank you so much! We're lucky to have Trixia on our team, and we'll make sure she sees this. Honest mistakes happen, and we're so glad she could make it right. The fact that you keep coming back and spread the word means everything to us. Good for your wallet and the planet, we couldn't have said it better ourselves!
CL
Claire
Not thoroughly cleaned
The product arrived and it had an odd smell, I looked closely and there was old dried food or spit up on the carrier in the mesh. I decided not to return it because it is washable, but disappointing it wasn't fully cleaned for the price.
Response from GoodBuy GearMay 6, 2026
Thank you for the feedback, this is not the standard we hold ourselves to, and we're sorry this one slipped through our inspection process. We're glad it's washable, but you deserved to receive it clean and ready to use. We'd love to make this right for you. Please reach out to us at [email protected] so we can look into this further.
KB
Katie B.
Take the risk!!
Got a stroller for $100 less than retail and it was in tip top condition just like new!!! Came fast. Will use this site again.
Response from GoodBuy GearMay 6, 2026
A stroller in tip top shape for $100 less than retail? That's exactly what we're here for! So glad it arrived quickly and exceeded expectations. We'll see you next time!
HE
Hillary E.
I think the company is good and I am…
I think the company is good and I am hopeful they will make it right but my last two purchases were not described accurately and had damage (despite being listed as new/unused condition). I just ordered a playpen and it is missing 4 screws, was very dirty, had broken pieces and the wood was cracked in a few areas. Whoever was inspecting the product clearly missed it or was not doing their due diligence. I just submitted a claim for a return for a refund.
Response from GoodBuy GearApr 29, 2026
We're so sorry to hear this, and honestly, this is hard to read because it's the opposite of what we promise every customer. Our inspection process exists for exactly this reason, and we clearly fell short here. Not once, but twice. That's not okay, and we own that. Your claim is in good hands with our team and we'll be reaching out soon. Thank you for giving us the opportunity to make it right.
LA
Layla
Great Experience with Purchase
I purchased the Nuna Travel LX stroller and car seat system. I’m not due until August so I haven’t have the opportunity to use it yet but my experience so far has been great. I ordered it as open box and everything came wrapped up brand new. I can’t wait to use it come August!
Response from GoodBuy GearApr 29, 2026
Congratulations on your little one on the way! We love hearing this. The Nuna Travel System is such a great pick, and we're so glad everything arrived in wonderful condition. We hope you and baby have the best time putting it to good use come August!