Christie C.
My kitty HATED it, and the first shipment had a delivery problem.
Two things: My first (sample, test) shipment arrived during a heatwave, and all the samples burst, so I had to wait for my next 'full price' shipment for my Blackie, a Maine Coon, to try it. When he did, he smelled it and turned away with barely a single lick. And he adores EVERYTHING seafood, except for Smalls, which I was willing to pay extra for. I was SO eager to treat him!
Response from SmallsDec 24, 2025
I am so sorry that your experience with us was such a struggle from start to finish. It is heartbreaking to hear that after the frustration of a heatwave ruining your Sampler box, Blackie didn't even give the food a chance. I know how much you were looking forward to treating him to something special, and it’s especially disappointing when they turn up their nose at a premium option. If your first full-price shipment was charged because the Sampler arrived damaged, I want to make sure we’ve made that right for you. We never want our customers paying full price for a test run that didn't start on the right foot. If your kitty truly disliked the food and you haven't been refunded for that initial experience yet, please let us know. We want to ensure that even if the food wasn't a fit for Blackie, your experience with our service is still a positive one!


