Finding affordable car insurance that fits your budget doesn’t have to be difficult. With IIA, we can help you shop around with our 20+ carriers and locate a policy that aligns with your coverage requirements. Whether you’re looking for minimum liability, full coverage, or something in between, our friendly, experienced team can help guide you through your insurance journey.
Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc. (infinityauto.com) has 566 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 2.3 out of 5.
Also known as
Infinity Insurance Agency, infinityauto.com
Website
infinityauto.com
Category
Insurance
Location
Mcallen, Texas
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 89% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
After I posted a review and posted on their social media the adjuster ( Melanie Thornburg ) finally responded. I will be sure to update this review if anything changes. For now, I will give this company a chance to make this right. I have never had any issues and hopefully, that will remain the same.
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Jan 11, 2021
Good afternoon, Terrance. Thank you for your five-star review. We were delighted to learn you revised your review and left an excellent rating. We very much appreciate your concern. We hope to continue serving your insurance needs in the future. Have a wonderful day.
-Orlando, CS Consultant
CB
CELL B.
LOGIN IN DIFFICULTY, SYSTEM NOT WORKING
I have been having difficulties to conduct my payment both On the Webpage & the App itself. Everytime I attempt to log in the system claims that the "Password" or "Username" are not found and it prompted me to create a new password..I have done that step MULTIPLE TIMES and it still DOES NOT WORK..It is ridiculous I Didn'thave that Issue at all back in November... My policy will be ending soon yet how am I suppose to receive my new packet information along with my new Insurance card if I cannot even log into my damn Account... I went paperless for a reason. In addition the the Customer Service email that they tell you to reach out to IS USELESS!!!! they do not help at all!!! I need to know what are the next steps to take? Because It is obvious that this is a system error itself... This Company needs to get I.T to work As soon as possible... As of now I have no Idea what to do..Who do I reach out to???
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Jan 6, 2021
Good morning, CELL BLOCK. We are terribly sorry to discover that you are experiencing issues with our app and our website. Your frustration is understandable. Now, we would be delighted to assist. In order to give some assistance, we kindly ask that you send your name, policy number, and any screenshots of the issue you are encountering to [email protected] to solve your situation. Thank you for the time and effort you spent letting us know about this. Have a magnificent day.
—Orlando, CS Consultant
MP
MP
The worst cheapest company the coverage…
The worst cheapest company the coverage sucks they lie then they say that is not covered just canceled my policy with them today and signed up with Farmers. Stay away from infinity
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Jan 6, 2021
Good morning, MP. We're sorry you are dissatisfied with the Company. We'd definitely be willing to give some assistance. Moreover, if you have any questions or concerns, we kindly encourage you to send your name, policy number or claim number, along with your contact information to [email protected] to review your situation. Thank you your writing. Good day, MP.
—Orlando, CS Consultant
MQ
Mary Q.
WHERE IS THE ZERO STARS OPTION??
WHERE IS THE ZERO STARS OPTION??? i have an issue on my policy that i've been trying to get more information about and it seems there is NO ONE working for their customer service and their email customer.service ipacc.com IS USELESSS.. literally horrible.
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Jan 5, 2021
Good afternoon, Ms. Quintero. We are sincerely sorry to hear that you are not satisfied. Next, we would be happy to research your state of affairs. Moreover, we encourage you to send your policy number (or your claim number) to [email protected] to clear up your situation. Thank you for your calling our attention to this matter. We hope to be of service soon. Have an excellent day.
—Orlando, CS Consultant
YA
yeimy A.
I had a car accident on November 13
I had a car accident on November 13, 2020. Finally, after a month waiting for an answer Infinity insurance assigned an adjuster: Salomon Krenshaw, I have been calling him for 2 weeks, I have been leaving voice mails, but he never calls me back. Nobody in the claims department can’t help me, only the adjuster that never returns my calls. I know that my car is total loss, I need to find a solution. I need help, PLEASE.
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Dec 30, 2020
Good morning, Yeimy. We are terribly sorry to discover your review. Equally important, we have sent out a communication to the adjusters, the adjuster's supervisor, and the manager indicating to call you with a status update to resolve your scenario. We are closely monitoring your situation and want to inform you that the claims team with follow up within one to three business days. Thank you for your being forthcoming, your patience, and understanding. Lastly, if we could be of further service, please write us at [email protected]. Have a phenomenal day.
-Orlando, CS Consultant
SC
Salvador C.
I wish I could give them zero stars
I wish I could give them zero stars. I am so disapointed at this company...they failed to report my insurance policy to the DMV and have caused a delay on getting my new tags. I even doubt my policy was any good. I am contemplating suing them
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Dec 30, 2020
Good afternoon, Salvador. We are sorry to discover your unexpected complication. It was most understanding of you to write us with your concerns. Certainly we would be happy to correct the situation and could start the moment you send your name and policy number to [email protected]. Thank you for contacting the insurance Company with your concerns. We look forward to making amends. Have a great day. -Orlando, CS Consultant
AS
April S.
WORST Experience Every!
My true star rating would be less than one, if allowed.
We were rear ended by one of their insured on September 5, 2020, in our 3 month old truck. Due to Labor Day weekend, I reported the accident on September 9, 2020. Didn't get our truck back until November 23, 2020. This has been a TOTAL nightmare! Adjuster wouldn't return calls, or emails to us, or the body shop! Kemper/Infinity (not sure what their actual name is) sent us check about three weeks later that wasn't even close to the amount of the estimate (they never asked for a copy of the estimate I got on September 8th. They had just guessed an amount to pay based on a few pictures we had sent. Therefore, the body shop needed additional authorization to completely repair the vehicle & get paid for it. However, they never could get their calls or emails returned, so they could proceed in a timely manner. I have written records of every call/email I made to Emily Terry, and her supervisor Kris Inzer, and so does the body shop (that I've had them send to me). In one call the body shop made to me, asking me if I could get ahold of Emily Terry, they stated this was the worst insurance company they had ever worked with. The body shop was very quick to share their list of unanswered correspondence with me when I told them the insurance company was blaming them for the delay.
Now, Kemper/Infinity is denying part of the rental vehicle charges, in excess of $900, stating it was the body shop that caused the delay, and that I should get reimbursed by them, which is complete BS! I have used the same body shop for several years & NEVER have we had any delays.
I just called Kemper/Infinity's customer service again, only to be told they only have phone numbers for the adjuster & her supervisor, which has proven to be useless information.
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Dec 28, 2020
Good afternoon, April. It was most understanding of you to let us know about your unpleasant situation. We greatly regret your displeasure. Now, we would be happy to give some assistance. We kindly ask that you send your name, claim number and contact information to our email: [email protected] to commence researching your scenario. Thank you for your writing to the company. Have an excellent day. —Orlando, CS Consultant
KC
Keith C.
On 10/10/2020 I was in an accident with…
On 10/10/2020 I was in an accident with 100% liability resting with Infinity's (Now Kemper) insured driver/vehicle owner. #20003874442. I was rear ended while all traffic was stopped. I suffered vehicle damage (Complete total), property damages and physical injuries requiring much medical treatment. Since Florida is no fault my insurance has been good at covering my medical..
TRYING TO GET INFINITY TO PAY MY PROPERTY DAMAGE A DISGRACE TO THE INSURANCE INDUSTRY. After the accident they sent a form letter right away with contact info. I have called more than a dozen times with zero response. The Contact is Cassiopia Haywood. You get a recording saying I will return call but if you need assistance call my manager at number given. This too is useless because each manager & number giver is disconnected number, no longer employed or just will not call back either. In my opinion this company is dealing with bad faith to all parties including the insured and victim!! Maybe they should be investigated by regulatory authorities?? Now I may be forced to bring a lawsuit against the vehicle owners personally and the driver..So what good is a company like Kemper /Infinity??
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Dec 22, 2020
Good morning Mr. Keith,
Thank you so much for your review. We sincerely apologize for your unsettling experience regarding your claim. In order to better assist you, please send us an email to [email protected]; please include your claim number and best contact information to have the appropriate individuals assist with your inquiry. We look forward to your response. Thank you and have a great day.
-Juan, CS Consultant.