Buy and sell diamond rings and diamond engagement rings with complete confidence.
I DO NOW I DON"T (idonowidont.com) has 299 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.6 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listing
Jewelry & Watches · Huntington, New York
Excellent
Jewelry & Watches · New York, New York
Excellent
Jewelry & Watches · New York, New York
Excellent
Jewelry & Watches · Brooklyn, New York
Excellent
299 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Rachel C.
This company cares so much about their customers. They treated me so well during the process and answer all my questions quickly. I am so impressed with this service that I will be recommending it to everybody.
Lana M.
I would not trust this company. I sent my $15,500 diamond necklace to them for a direct offer and they only offered me $2000! I can get 2-3 times that much at Pawn America. The claims they make about receiving 1/2 to 3/4 of the value of your item is totally false. I listed it for 3/4 of the value or less and had no interest. They really pushed me to take a direct offer. Now I know why. They would make up to $10,000 off of me. I would not use this company. This is false advertising at its best. They need to be reported to the better business bureau. Also in response to the companies post regarding my review, I would like the public to know that the omega chain that I had with the diamond was not purchased with my diamond. I purchased the diamond alone without any chain and had it set into a pendent. I sent I Do Now I Don't the ORIGINAL RECEIPT with my diamond showing the purchase price of over $15,000. They obviously try to discredit everything you say when they don't get the review they want. Their email also says they will reply with a direct offer in 24-48 hours. Right, try 7 days! I had to call them twice to find out what was going on. Better results with Pawn America and that is where I will go.
Response from I DO NOW I DON"TMay 23, 2017
We typically do not respond to reviews, but in the spirit of fairness and accuracy we feel compelled to answer this one. Our company is well established as a leader in the secondary market for diamonds and jewelry. Our reputation is built on tens of thousands of interactions and it's a fact that sellers frequently garner between 50-75% of the retail pricing by using our online marketplace. When someone lists an item at or above retail, as was the case here, we cannot help when little buy interest in shown. Additionally, when the seller submitted her item to us for a direct offer, she did not submit the large gold necklace that accompanies it. She only inquired about the diamond pendant. Regarding our direct offer, we pride ourselves on making the highest offers possible. To illustrate that point, the full retail price of an exactly comparable diamond (both the seller's and comparable diamonds are certified) on Blue Nile retails around $7,000- $7,500. The seller states that they have an offer even above what the retailer is selling it for.
Beverly
This is a wonderful site for purchasing or selling your special ring or other fine jewelry! I recently purchased a used Tiffany & Co ring and let me tell you I got a smoking great deal and the seller was awesome. Idnid is easy to work with and responds quickly to any questions you might have. I have bought and sold on their site before and have always been pleased! The best part is is that you know what your truly getting as they verify your purchase to its true specifications that the seller listed! With some other popular sites out there your really on your own with a wing and a prayer that's it's what a seller says item is! I will always be using idnid for my jewelry.
Tarak
Buying a ring for your fiance is tough. She wants big, and perfect, you want reasonably priced. I didn't want to buy from a jewelry store where I knew I was paying 100% markup and I didn't want to go meet 20 people off of Criagslist until I found the right one. IdoNowIdont is the best of both. I actually selected a diamond and paid for it but IdoNowIdont inspected the diamond and let me know that the diamond didn't match what was advertised and credited my account when asked. I then purchased the perfect diamond for about 40% of what I would have paid at a jeweler. Thank you very much. I hope I never have to buy another diamond again, but IdoNowIdont was perfect.
Natasha
This was my first time experiencing the site and it was a positive one. The customer service was great. The only drawback was not knowing that my check was going to be sent via FedEx rather than regular mail which was stated on the website. It would have been great knowing that information ahead of time as my check had been delivered two days prior to me picking it up on my porch.
Missy Eckman K.
I started the process in January to sell my jewelry. As of today 2 months later my check is finally in the mail. Sent numerous follow-up emails. Was not happy with the amount offered.
Response from I DO NOW I DON"TMar 27, 2018
Unfortunately, we have little control over the United States Postal Service. We are sorry your check was delayed.
Ronni
There was a short delay in the process. However the overall process was great! hubby and I love MY anniversary gift:-)
Denise
As a seller, I was really hesitant (and a little scared) to sell my wedding ring set online to a site where you have to send in your item Before you receive your money. But, I read the reviews, watched the various media stories, and knew that all these credited news and tv programs would not feature this site if it wasn't legit. So, I took a chance and listed my ring. Their online customer service answered my questions, kept me up to date throughout the entire process, and even suggested what I should list the set for. I made more money selling the rings on this site than when I tried to sell on eBay. I'm very happy with I Do Now I Don't. And you will be too!