GoodBuy Gear is the leader in quality-checked open box and secondhand gear for families. Shop 2,600+ brands and save an average of 55% off retail, every item inspected by our experts.
GoodBuy Gear (goodbuygear.com) has 365 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.1 out of 5.
Also known as
goodbuygear.com
Website
goodbuygear.com
Category
Malls & Marketplaces
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 97% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
I love buying stuff from the good by gear. If you have any doubts like I did before you can rest assure their open box items are like new.
Response from GoodBuy GearOct 23, 2026
Thank you so much for your kind words and for being a part of the GoodBuy Gear community! We’re so happy to hear that you’ve had a great experience shopping with us.
VZ
Vivien Z.
Great experience shopping here
Great selection of products. Accurate listing. Good quality and fast delivery.
Response from GoodBuy GearOct 16, 2026
Open box, great finds, and everything in perfect shape? Now that’s a win! We love helping you get the gear you need without paying full price. Thanks for coming to GoodBuy Gear and making those savings count!
VC
VC
I was sent the wrong items
I was sent the wrong items. They made it easy to make a claim and return. I was very disappointed in the mistake but they made it up with their great customer service. I will continue to buy from them.
Response from GoodBuy GearOct 16, 2026
Wrong gear, right way to make things right! 🙌 We’re sorry for the mix up, but glad our team could turn things around. Thanks for giving us another shot and sticking with GoodBuy Gear. Your next order will be on track!
CH
Christa
Order went missing
FedEx failed to scan the package and it’s gone missing. GoodBuy Gear has offered to refund the order, but it’s still a disappointing outcome after waiting for 2 weeks.
Response from GoodBuy GearOct 16, 2026
Thank you so much for sharing your feedback. We are sorry to hear the delivery was not as expected. Feel free to reach out to our Customer Care team, [email protected], if you need any help. We can't wait to see you again soon!
LE
Leela
Please with the products I ordered
Please with the products I ordered. I ordered open box and all products were in great condition. Only one of the products I got was missing the charger and although it said only open box there was sign of usage. It was the mom cozy portable water and milk warmer. I paid for the returns so I returned this item. But all other items were perfect and I saved !
Response from GoodBuy GearOct 16, 2026
Great gear at great prices? Sounds like a GoodBuy to us! We’re glad everything arrived just as expected. Thanks for shopping with GoodBuy Gear and happy saving!
BT
Bri T.
1 star — Their “Gear-antee” expires faster than the milk in your fridge
GoodBuy Gear loves to brag about its “strict safety & quality-check inspection.” Here’s what that inspection is worth: a high chair shipped to me missing the parts needed to put it together.
My Skip Hop EON 4-in-1 High Chair was a gift bought from GoodBuy Gear while I was pregnant. Like any expecting parent, I didn’t assemble a high chair for a baby who wasn’t born yet. When the day finally came to use it, I opened the box and found it incomplete. It’s not damaged or worn. It’s just missing pieces that should have been caught by the “baby gear experts” they say inspect every item.
I contacted them three times. I didn’t ask for a refund. I asked for the missing parts, store credit, or even just a supervisor to look at my case. What I got back was the same canned response every time: past 14 days, not our problem. Not one of my requests was acknowledged. When I pointed out that their own inspection failed, they replied that they “absolutely stand behind” their inspections. Clearly not.
The worst part is that their whole pitch is sustainability and keeping baby gear out of landfills. Their own manufacturer won’t sell replacement parts, so this high chair is now headed for exactly that, all because GoodBuy Gear would rather hide behind fine print than fix its own mistake.
Their 14-day window is a convenient trap for a business that sells baby gear, because so much of it is bought ahead of time and not opened for months. They know that. They profit from it. And when their quality control fails, the parent is the one stuck with the bill.
Save yourself the frustration and buy somewhere that stands behind what it sells. If you do order from GoodBuy Gear, tear everything open the second it arrives, because once those 14 days pass, their promises mean nothing.
Response from GoodBuy GearOct 16, 2026
We’re sorry to hear that your experience didn’t meet expectations. We always want families to feel confident shopping with GoodBuy Gear, and we appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback. Thank you for giving us the chance to listen and improve!
MO
momofccc365
Great prices and my order was just as…
Great prices and my order was just as described
Response from GoodBuy GearOct 16, 2026
Great gear at great prices? Sounds like a GoodBuy to us! We’re glad everything arrived just as expected. Thanks for shopping with GoodBuy Gear and happy saving!
LU
Luiza
Had a great experience
Had a great experience. Item came as expected, even better! Shipping was also very quick. Will definitely buy again.
Response from GoodBuy GearOct 16, 2026
Better than expected AND speedy shipping? Now that’s a win win! We’re so thrilled your order hit the mark! Thanks for shopping with Goodbuy Gear — we’ll be ready when you’re back for your next great find!