He likes the treats and the hard ball but that is about it the other toys he didn’t care for he loves things that squeak and I would for him to have a stuff animal that squeaks that he can’t destroy
Response from BULLYMAKEJul 6, 2026
Hi Stacey! We’re glad to hear he’s loving the treats and the hard ball, even if the other toys weren’t quite the right fit this time. In response to customer feedback, we added plush toys to our collection to cater to the needs of gentle chewers in households with multiple dogs. And let’s be honest, sometimes your dog needs a win to prove he still has it. Our plush toys are crafted from lightweight materials specifically designed for dogs that prefer a softer chewing experience. Please keep in mind that this is not our toughest toy type and can be destroyed. For the toughest toys, we recommend our Nylon or Rubber toys. If you would like to amend your subscription to better fit your pups prefrence, you can do so here! https://bullymake.com/customer_authentication/login?return_to=%2Fapps%2Fsubscriptions%2Fmanage
LT
LT
Love from Layla
Layla loved her box! From ALL the treats to the toys. She has thoroughly enjoyed every item! Thank you! 🐾🐾
Response from BULLYMAKEJul 6, 2026
Hi there! We’re thrilled to hear that Layla loved her box and enjoyed both the treats and toys. It means a lot to know she’s having such a great experience with every item.
SR
Sally-Ruth R.
Bullymake is awesome!
As Tony the Tiger says... They're great!
Response from BULLYMAKEJun 25, 2026
Hi there! We’re so glad your pup is enjoying everything so far. Thanks for sharing the enthusiasm, and we can’t wait to keep delivering more “they’re great!” moments in future boxes.
TA
Tila A.
So far we have only received one box…
So far we have only received one box but the experience has been great so far! The treats have been a hit!! And the toys seem to be great too!
Response from BULLYMAKEJun 25, 2026
Hi Tila! We’re so glad your first box has been a great experience and that the treats have been a hit. It’s also great to hear the toys are working well so far. We’re excited to keep the fun coming with future boxes for your pup.
SA
Stacey A.
She tore apart two of the toys…
She tore apart two of the toys immediately but you sent replacements quickly.
Response from BULLYMAKEJun 25, 2026
Hi Stacey! We’re glad to hear the replacements arrived quickly for you.
It sounds like she’s definitely a strong chewer—some pups really put their toys to the test right away. Just as a reminder, we do offer the option to customize your box to better match your dog’s chew strength and play style. https://bullymake.com/customer_authentication/login?return_to=%2Fapps%2Fsubscriptions%2Fmanage
EJ
Eddie J.
I'm loving it so far my 13 week old…
I'm loving it so far my 13 week old German Shepherd is to
Response from BULLYMAKEJun 25, 2026
Hi Eddie! We are so glad to hear that both you and your German Shepard are loving Bullymake! We appreciate you being a part of the pack and can't wait for you both to see what is in the next box.
RS
Rena S.
I ordered two three month subscriptions…
I ordered two three month subscriptions as gifts and both of the recipients loved them!
Response from BULLYMAKEJun 25, 2026
Hi Rena! We’re so happy to hear the recipients loved their Bullymake boxes—that really means a lot to us. What a thoughtful gift to send!
EM
Elizabeth M.
Don’t even waste your time with other…
Don’t even waste your time with other subscription boxes, this is the one for all!
This subscription has been the best decision I have made for my dogs. Each month, they receive a new box in the mail that includes 3 nylon toys and 3 bags of grain-free treats. You can get different toys depending on what your dog likes: rubber, nylon, stuffies, rope tugs, and ballistic toys. The dogs go NUTS for this. Cinnamon, Nugget, and Ghost love taking their new toys out of the brightly colored orange box. When we open the box, each dog gets to pick out their new toys, and they go to town. I have not had to throw away a toy yet! Previous toys the dogs DESTROYED within 15 minutes. Also, if your dog destroys one of the toys, just contact customer service, and they will send a replacement. This is a part of their 45-day guarantee. If the toy meets its demise, you just need to let them know within 45 days of you getting the box, and they will send you a new toy, no questions asked. This is limited to once per month. Most companies wouldn’t allow you to repeatedly replace toys that your dog has ruined within a certain time frame.
Other subscription boxes either give you toys or treats, and the toys are stuffed with materials I don’t really want my dog to ingest. Bullymake has toys that, yes, they can chew, but they can't break apart. It also works with their jaws and mouths, so they don't lose strength. The toys also help clean their teeth. Each month, the dogs eat most of the dog treats, and they are great for training because they aren’t giant treats.
You get to pick the best plan for you and your dogs, tailoring it to their preferences. My dogs love having toys, so we get a new box each month, but you can schedule it to come in increments, like monthly, or every 3, 6, or yearly. Their customer service is top-notch. When you have questions, you can either call or message them on the site, and they can help you with whatever issues you are having with the website, toys, or subscription. Their themes each month are exciting and creative. January was fitness, February was Valentine's Day; they got hearts. March was the Enchanted Forest. My dog's favorite toy from March was a pink mushroom that he carries around in his mouth, and it looks like a binkie. Each month has a different theme, and that carries over from the toys to the treats. My dogs have a whole toy box full of toys, but I can’t get rid of any of them because they love them all, and I can’t stop subscribing because it brings so much joy to my dogs each month.
Along with the subscription, you can add items as a one-time purchase or as a monthly add-on, including additional toys, treats, and vitamins. One thing I really appreciate is that if your dog has special allergies, they can accommodate them; you just specify them in your form. For instance, my dogs eat pretty much everything, including sticks, but Cinnamon cannot eat Lamb; she gets really itchy, also a common problem for pitbulls, but Bullymake can cater to beef, chicken, and grain allergies. If your dog is allergic to many things, you can also choose the “toys only” option, and they won't send any treats. This has truly been a game-changer for my dogs and my family. We were spending hundreds of dollars trying to find toys that could withstand power-chewing by dogs, but I stumbled upon this company and have been in love ever since. So much that I got my best friend to get a subscription for her dogs! This is truly the go-to for power-chewing puppers. I wish I could give it 10 paws up!
Response from BULLYMAKEJun 25, 2026
Hi Elizabeth! We’re so happy to hear Bullymake has been such a great fit for you and your pups!
It’s amazing to know Cinnamon, Nugget, and Ghost are loving their boxes and staying entertained month after month. We also really appreciate you highlighting the durability, customization options, and variety. That’s exactly what we aim for, especially for power chewers.
Thank you for being part of the Bullymake pack and for recommending us so enthusiastically.