The iFISH Store provides one of the widest selections of freshwater aquarium and pond fish available online today. We have been providing freshwater fish to aquarium and pond enthusiasts for over 20 years. Here's what you can expect from The iFISH Store: High Quality Fish / Low Pricing / Fast, Low Cost Shipping / Superior Customer ServiceFollowing quarantine, all shipments are sent via FedEx Overnight at a flat rate on all orders regardless of size. Interested in something you don't see in our store? Contact us at [email protected] or 516.524.6423 and just ask!
The iFISH Store (theifishstore.com) has 4,236 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.6 out of 5.
Also known as
theifishstore.com
Website
theifishstore.com
Category
Pet Stores
Location
Richmond Hill, New York
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 28% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Hello Anesha:
We have a Live Arrival Guarantee and ask that if our customers receive a perished fish that they notify us within 2 hours after receiving the order and provide photos of the perished fish. In going through our emails, we don't see any communication from you. We would have been happy to provide a refund or credit on a future order. At this point, we aren't even sure which of the fish you are referring to in your order and would certainly have liked photos of the leaked bag as well. If you would like to open communication with us on this so we can discuss it further, please email us at [email protected] and provide further detail. Thank you!
LT
Lemuel T.
My fish(Discus) came in a timely manner…
My fish(Discus) came in a timely manner and in Great condition!!!! Will definitely order from them again!!!
TY
Tyler
Terrible customer service
Best place to get fish if you only want them to live for about 24 hours. Also do not ask for a refund they refuse to give you YOUR money back and instead are very rude and refund you ten dollars when you spent over 100$ and tell you that the rest of the money can be used for your next purchase. Place is a joke and very unprofessional.
Response from The iFISH StoreFeb 15, 2021
Hi Tyler,
We’re sorry that you are so disappointed in your experience with us. We would like the opportunity to respond to a few issues that you raised in your communications with us by phone and email so you can hopefully understand our perspective and policies as a business.
Our Live Arrival Guarantee: We stand by this guarantee and have well-defined guidelines that we follow as well as instructions on what we expect from a customer that are published on our site (https://theifishstore.com/pages/how-we-pack-live-fish-for-shipment). We clearly state that should any fish perish during shipping, in order to receive a credit or refund, we require a clear picture of the perished fish within 2 hours after the first delivery attempt with the fish removed from the shipping bag and placed on a white background. Not only did we not receive the photos as requested with the fish out of the water after you received your shipment but you also did not notify us until 5 hours later that the Long Fin Black Tetra perished and you advised all others arrived alive. You then advised us the next day that the Yellow GloFish perished the night before without providing any photo, we still accommodated you with offering a refund or credit for both fish. You notified us again 7 days later that 1-Bumble Bee Catfish, 2 Gourami’s and another GloFish perished which is well past our guarantee policy. We tried to work with you to understand the reason the fish were perishing after being in your aquarium water for 7 days by trying to see what your water parameters were, which is common practice in this industry as water conditions are critical for the fish to thrive. You stated we were being “rude” and it’s “none of our business”. The only information you provided was the water temperature is 82 degrees which we would like to add is on the high side for those type of fish. We requested pictures of the other perished fish which, again, you provided pictures of them on top of your aquarium water in a net. We feel we have gone above and beyond our own guidelines in an attempt to make this a better experience for you even though you have ignored our standard requests for our guarantee policy.
We honored our refund offered to you of the Long Fin Black Tetra and GloFish and have issued that refund. For the 2 Gourami’s , 1-Bumble Bee Catfish and 1-GloFish, we felt offering a credit on a future order is fair seeing as we were going beyond our policy timeframe.
Again, we are sorry this was your experience and we strongly believe we did the best we could to accommodate you. We don't believe we we're ever "rude" to you and maintained our business composure while, based on the telephone and email conversations with you, we found you to be quite challenging to work with and we did not appreciate your offensive tone with our customer service representatives.
AD
Ana D.
Discus
good fishes.
PS
Pedro S.
Good price and fast shipping
Good price and fast shipping
JL
James L.
Fast delivery
Fast delivery, well packed, fish still robust and vigorous even after a long day on the road
SB
Scott B.
Bad batch of fish killed everything in my tank within a week
I have made two purchases from the iFish store the first time one fish arrived dead I contacted them and asked for it to be replaced as I was making a second order they said they would add it to my order and I receive it with the shipment it never came so I did not get the credit or the fish for the first order on my second order the fish all arrived alive and had good color but they did have some small spots white spots indicating that they had ick unfortunately this wasn't seen till after they were acclimated in put into the tank the pink have been running for two years plus it's 120 gallon I've had no issues but the second batch of fish that I had purchased and put into the tank had the white spots I treated it immediately for ick but to no avail it killed everything that I had bought from them in two shipments and all the fish that were in the tank Pryor I lost 40 fish in total I am very disappointed as well are my kids because it killed their fish as well this is the first that I am riding the review or saying anything about it because at this point I never received my credit and it will not be able to replace the fish that I had prior to them that I have purchased would be nice for both my orders to be reimbursed whether it be store credit or both orders exactly the same sent to me so I would take the fish or the credit but that's up to the iFish store
Response from The iFISH StoreFeb 16, 2021
Hello Scott;
First off, we'd like to apologize for missing the addition of the replacement fish in your second order. That was an operational error on our part and the instruction just did not make it into our order system.
Second, and more importantly, we are very sorry to hear that all of the fish in your aquarium perished, apparently from ich, after the ich appeared in your second order from us. Ich is quite insidious and only becomes visible after the fish are stressed. On our end, we certainly do visual inspections and treat our tanks but ich may not bloom until the fish are stressed from something such as shipping.
Be that as it may, we'd like to try and make things right here. We'd like to offer you a credit for all of the fish in both of your orders. This would be a credit for $128.83 for the first order and $59.90 for the second order (Total Credit = $188.73).
To use this credit, you simply have to enter in theNotesComments Section on your next order that you'd like "to apply the $188.73 from Order Nos. 15932 & 16199 to this new order."
Again, we apologize for the inconvenience and the loss of your other fish. We hope this credit will help rectify the situation and you will place your confidence in us again on a future order. Thank you for being so open-minded in working with us on this.
CU
Customer
The fish arrived healthy and fast
The fish arrived healthy and fast. We would absolutely order from here again.