Anthony C.
From Four Stars to One Star
My wife and I have always loved the ambiance at the Cheesecake Factory, which is why we continued returning despite ongoing food issues during our last four visits. The receptionists have consistently been outstanding, accommodating, and welcoming. The staff at the cheesecake and espresso counter are also friendly, professional, and informative. Unfortunately, our most recent visit was one of the worst dining experiences we have ever had. I met my wife for happy hour, and despite not having a reservation, the receptionist quickly accommodated my request for a booth in the area we preferred. Our server was also friendly and attentive. We started with two Mai Tais and stuffed mushrooms. Years ago, the Cheesecake Factory had some of the best Mai Tais on the island, and I used to recommend the restaurant to many of my photography clients. That is no longer the case. Charging $35 for two Mai Tais with no orange juice, pineapple juice, or garnish felt like a complete rip-off. They lacked flavor and were simply not enjoyable. When the stuffed mushrooms arrived, we immediately noticed they had changed. They now came with a white sauce, and the overall taste was awful compared to what they used to be. For our entrées, my wife ordered the penne pasta with zucchini, which appeared partially cooked. I ordered the classic cheeseburger medium and juicy. What arrived at the table was unacceptable. The bun, lettuce, tomato, onions, and cheese were ice cold, and the cheese looked like it had simply been thrown on top of the patty at the last second. I told the food runner this was not acceptable, and surprisingly she agreed, even saying, “I know.” I asked her how food that clearly was not right could even leave the kitchen. She took it back, but when it returned, the cheese was melted while the burger itself was now overcooked and dry. The bun and toppings were still ice cold. At $23, this “classic cheeseburger” was disappointing. Honestly, I could have gone to Wendy’s and had a much better, juicier burger for far less money. When our server checked on us, I gave honest feedback and asked where the quality control was in the kitchen. If staff members delivering the food already know something is wrong, why is it being served in the first place? The manager eventually came to the table after speaking with our server. Unfortunately, instead of addressing the kitchen quality issues professionally, his response was, “Why do you keep coming here if the food is bad every time?” I explained that we genuinely enjoy the ambiance and cheesecake, which is why we kept giving the restaurant another chance. He also stated that my burger had already been removed from the bill, which turned out not to be true when the check arrived 20 minutes later. Our server then had to track him down again to correct the issue, resulting in another unnecessary delay. Other issues during recent visits included: • Ordering hot tea and receiving cold water that would not steep the tea bag • Spaghetti and meatballs arriving dried out after sitting too long under the salamander, with crusty sauce and hardened pasta on multiple occasions Sadly, after four disappointing visits in two months, it feels like the Cheesecake Factory has serious consistency and kitchen quality-control problems. We truly enjoy the atmosphere, the front-of-house staff, and of course the cheesecake, but for now we will be taking a break and trying other restaurants instead.