Order online replacement dental retainers, teeth whitening, teeth grinding guards, and sports mouthguards. All without having to go to the dentist, saving you hundreds.
SportingSmiles (sportingsmiles.com) has 151 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.9 out of 5.
Also known as
sportingsmiles.com
Website
sportingsmiles.com
Category
Dental Services
Location
Waukesha, Wisconsin
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 19% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Very hard to get an impression, refund process is also very difficult
I tried to get an impression so many times and it kept getting rejecting. It's $10 extra for every impression kit. I tried so many times, and I just ended up asking for a refund and there is a $20~30 charge to get a refund. You also have to return all the used impression kits and rejected molds to them before they start processing the refund. I don't recommend sporting smiles.
SA
Sam
Already wear retainers? Not worth it.
I have had my old retainers for over a decade, so I was looking forward to a new set.
I went through 8 combined molds to get 2 different sets of retainers, with none of them fitting properly. I am beyond disappointed and furious. The last set didn't even sit on my teeth properly, and I made sure to follow all of the instructions and videos as best as I could.
I wore the better fitting set overnight. In the morning, my teeth were still sore and my old retainer (which again, I've worn for a decade) did not fit properly. I don't know what they did, but they did not deliver. And now I'm being charged $20 for what was advertised as "100% satisfaction guaranteed" (the fee is in the fine print). This process took 4 months, wasted several days of back-and-forth, making multiple molds after wearing my retainer, and now $20. If you have had and have worn a retainer, save yourself and don't use them.
MC
Mark C.
I was wearing my old broken night guard…
I was wearing my old broken night guard way to long, because I didn’t want to get another one at the $500 my dentist charged me last time. Sporting Smiles had good reviews and like that you could actually talk to someone. Did mess up the impression, but was sent extra supplies for free. Night guard fits perfectly and saved $400. Very happy
DE
Dee
A foul smell and stomach issues gone
My Invisalign retainer wore out I put getting them off due to price but sports miles was the cheapest option with my wore out it also caused a foul odor that did not go away from washing them it may caused my gut digestion system to be upset. The new ones are fitting perfect and that odor is now gone boosting my confidence
KH
Kai H.
Did not pay after review work
Did not pay after review work. They are big cheats. I will post 1 star every day if you don't pay me.
LA
Lily A.
Good value for the price
I'm writing the review I wish I found when I was researching retainers.
I placed my order on August 6th 2024, and received my final product September 3rd 2024. It took me 3 tries with the putty to get approved impressions. I ordered some extra putty and trays with my first order, and was sent two new sets of putty for free to retry my impressions. The customer service rep Jessica was super helpful and kind throughout the entire process, both over the phone and email.
The impressions process was tedious. I found that it worked better to have a second person present to act as a timer when mixing the putty and putting it into the tray. I also recommend having a mirror nearby to look at when you place the tray in. I watched the videos available on the website, refrigerated the putty when I got it to keep it from setting so fast, and marked where my teeth would go after sizing the tray. Even with all that, it took me three attempts to get a usable impression. If this is not something you want to risk, go with a non-DIY retainer. Human error makes it difficult to do on yourself, especially if you can't see into your mouth like a dentist would.
I've been using my new retainers (top and bottom Essix plus retainers), and they were a good fit. A bit tight initially, but I think that's how they're supposed to be to hold them in place. There appears to be a bit of excess material on the front of the bottom tray, but it doesn't cause any issues so I left it alone. I have been wearing them for almost a month now and have had no issues.
Overall, they're a good company if you're looking for a reasonable cost/decent value for the price. I broke my old retainers about 4 years ago. I noticed my teeth had shifted somewhat noticeably over the past summer, but because I could not afford orthodontics at the moment, I opted to go with this company on my friend's recommendation to prevent my teeth shifting further. I wasn't as concerned about a faster turn around, since my teeth have already been without retainers for a while, so it worked for me. If you're needing retainers immediately I recommend going with a dentist or orthodontist where they can fabricate the retainers in house.
TLDR; it is more tedious and takes longer than going to an orthodontist/dentist, but it is much cheaper. If you're good with spending less money to wait longer and do the impressions yourself, its a good option. Just keep in mind that you will likely have to redo the impressions (unless you order a lot of extra putty).
HA
Hardy And S.
I have been ordering my retainers from…
I have been ordering my retainers from sportingsmiles for a while. I keep losing them and it's awesome that they keep my impression on file and I can just reorder at any time.
BR
Brandon R.
Customer service is the absolute worst
Customer service is the absolute worst. They messed up my retainer twice and are making ME pay for the replacement tray. Unreal
Update: These are some of the most dishonest people I’ve ever dealt with.
It took months to get warranty coverage applied and it was only applied after I left negative feedback regarding their treatment of my issue.
They sent the wrong size retainer (children’s) and blamed me for user error.
After months of back and forth they finally sent the new kit but when I returned them they told me it was outside the 90 day warranty.
Criminally misleading, avoid at all costs