Paul S.
Soundcloud Monetization Rules Frustration
Soundcloud for Musicians continually denies applications for Monetization due to the use of AI. Their Monetization Terms of Service (MToS) states that: "...recordings that are exclusively (100% GenAI) computer-generated through the use of artificial intelligence.." are disallowed. This is understood. However, no matter what proof you provide that you are not using AI 100%, they continually deny monetization. More annoying is that they do this inconsistently. SoundCloud last week wrote to me and stated that "We can only approve content that is 100% original." Furthermore, they go on to state "We utilize this phrase to indicate a production that has been recorded and composed entirely without the incorporation of any samples or sounds obtained from sample purchasing platforms such as Splice or any other similar sites." This is not what the MToS states. Under the MToS agreement, it is possible to have some AI generated track content as long as its not "exclusively" generated by AI. In reality, SC continues to reject track monetization due to the use of AI, even when I produce paperwork and waivers to show I have the rights and permissions to monetize. These rejections are clearly inconsistent with SoundCloud MToS and leaves creatives confused as to what the rules really are. One other source of confusion and frustration is that SC reject tracks with the word "remix" or even "mix" in the title. For EDM producers, this is a normal nomenclature to use and what is really ironic is that the remixes are remixes of producers own tracks! This is another "rule" that is inconsistently applied. And lastly (but not least) the support bot that they use has no real use other than to raise a support ticket and when responses are made to SC's support emails, they disappear into a black hole, never to elicit a response back. It would appear that difficult questions just get "forgotten" or binned. The whole support question needs a top to bottom rethink and redesign with more resources put into it to make creatives experience much smoother, with greater transparency and consistency with the rules.


