Petslify is a dedicated company that transforms your cherished memories into unique, high-quality custom stuffed plush creations. Specializing in recreating your beloved pets, our team combines craftsmanship and attention to detail, ensuring that each plush is a heartwarming, lifelike tribute. Whether you're looking to memorialize a furry friend or give a thoughtful, personalized gift, Petslify guarantees a product that's both emotionally resonant and meticulously handcrafted. With our family-owned approach, we offer personalized care and a lifetime warranty, bringing a piece of your pet's spirit to life with love.
Petslify (petslify.com) has 216 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.6 out of 5.
Also known as
petslify.com
Website
petslify.com
Category
Pet Stores
Location
New York
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 7% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: September 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
UPDATE: just received an email from them with a preview of my completed plush- there are some errors/ feedback I sent them and they confirmed they will send plush back to production to fix. Not happy that I have to wait longer but I appreciate the gesture if the preview and that they are trying to get it just right. Will update my rating once I receive my plush
It’s been 12 weeks and I still have not received my plush. Company is refusing to refund my money and they won’t even give me a timeline or date or anything. I’m pretty sure the person that emails me and basically just says “sorry just deal with it” is not even real- AI generated. I’m reporting them and disputing this charge. I wanted to use cuddle clones but went with this company because they are cheaper. DONT DO IT. They are a scam.
Response from PetslifyFeb 26, 2025
Hi Natassia,
We understand how important this order is to you, and we take claims like this very seriously. However, after checking our system, we do not see an order under your name or email. We encourage you to contact our official customer support at [email protected] with your order details so we can investigate this further.
HA
Hajer Al M.
The product is amazing thank you very…
The product is amazing thank you very much! The communication was easy and helpful with Sarah.
The similarity is great and totally worth the wait!
Response from PetslifyFeb 25, 2025
Thank you so much, Hajer! We’re so happy to hear that you had a great experience and that Sarah was able to assist you. We take a lot of pride in making sure every plush captures the unique details of each pet, so knowing that you found the similarity amazing truly means a lot to us.
LG
Leslie G.
Exceptionally poor work, my replica looked like “Thing” from the Addam’s Family
I lost my service dog Peter last April 2024 after 14 years of service… I still am extremely lost without him…
I looked at Petslify to do a lookalike of him being encouraged by their 100% satisfaction guarantee.. I had the preview cost added so I could see him before being shipped… Peter was a beautiful glossy border collie with distinct features, and what they showed me when finished was a joke… the eyes were lopsided, and the wrong colour.. his ears looked like they were two mops stuck on the side of the head, and the facial colouring and shape was all wrong…I had sent multiple pictures of excellent quality of him in various positions as they requested… his black and white coat was instead created in grey, dull and long, when in fact Peter’s coat was glossy, shorter, with a slight curl…and it looked like “thing” from the Addams Family.. the plush had tacky grey long cheap looking rug like hair that made him look like a triangle, and the face and nose were completely out of proportion .. after looking at the preview I was devestated and extremely disappointed…, I was asked if I would like this replica to go back to the production team for tweaking up… There was so much wrong with this product, I knew they would need to make up an entire new plush…all I wanted was a full refund…which I did not get, because they subtract a large portion, to cover costs and material…
Had the company offered to start from scratch and redo this mess of a replica, I may have considered, because their site boasts pictures of stunning replicas… I was given the poorest artist, and the plush was totally and undeniably a joke…
The loss of Peter, was overnight, and unexpected… it still is devastating.. the trouble I went through with this company, and weeks of communication to rectify it, just opened wounds that caused anxiety and anger…. Frustration and humiliation…
It truly is a gamble hiring this company to replicate a beloved pet, and lately, after reading many poor reviews of unsatisfied customers, I would think twice… losing 80$ CDN is a ton of money for me, and I put my trust in their reputation for satisfaction…
Please… be very aware…
Response from PetslifyFeb 20, 2025
Dear Leslie,
We’re sorry to hear about your disappointment. However, we want to clarify that we followed our policies and Terms of Service at every step. Your plush was fully handcrafted with over 11 hours of work and custom materials. Before shipping, we sent preview photos as part of our process. At that stage, you requested to cancel, and per our policy, a partial deduction was necessary to cover the invested labor and materials—something you agreed to upon placing your order.
We always strive to be transparent and fair in our process. If you have any further concerns, feel free to reach out—we’re happy to assist.
Best,
The Petslify Team
BJ
Brianne J.
Petslify - dishonest company
I lost my dog in August 2024. I placed an order for a replica and received it in Nov 2024. The replica was not made to the specifications I requested, nor did it match the photographs I provided. My dog had light yellow eyes which I selected as the eye color option. I provided photos clearly showing his eyes. The replica they sent me had dark brown eyes. I contacted them and was assured a new one would be made and sent out right away. Still waiting in Feb 2025 only for them to tell me that they’re now unwilling to honor their promise of correcting their error. I paid over $300 Canadian dollars for this item over 6 months ago. I would strongly advise not ordering from this company as they do not take responsibility for their mistakes, are dishonest, and do not honor what they claim to represent. Taking advantage of people when they’re grieving is disgraceful. Extremely disappointed.
In response to your reply:
This is not correct. I inquired about a refund, which your representative denied. A replacement was the only option offered to me, which I accepted. I asked for a return label. I received neither. Upon inquiring why, another representative told me that your company is not willing to correct the error nor offer a refund and offered me a scarf instead.
I have all of the emails confirming what has transpired. At this point I’m not sure if there are major communication issues within your company, or if you are just plain dishonest because the information is readily available through our communication.
Response from PetslifyFeb 20, 2025
Dear Brianne,
We are truly sorry that you feel this way. At Petslify, we take great care to craft custom plush replicas with attention to detail based on the photos and specifications provided. While slight variations can occur due to the handmade nature of our products, we always strive for customer satisfaction.
After you reached out about the eye color issue, we promptly offered a free replacement to resolve the concern, which was in line with our customer commitment. Additionally, as per our Refund Policy, a full refund is available upon returning the plush. However, you declined both options, making it difficult for us to provide a resolution beyond what is outlined in our terms.
We remain committed to fairness and transparency. If you reconsider and would like to proceed with the return, our team is happy to assist.
Best,
The Petslify Team
AM
Amber
Trust the good reviews and be patient, it’s worth it
It was a big leap of faith trusting the good reviews and I’m so glad I did. It certainly takes a while to get your order (about 3 months), however, I’m so glad I patiently waited. The replica of my sister’s dog was shocking. Friends and family that first saw it thought I had actually stuffed their dog 🙈 that’s how accurate these stuffed puppies are! I ordered two, one for my sister and one for my niece. Both of them thought it was a real dog that looked EXACTLY like Rocky. Happy and sad tears were shed, but needless to say my niece sleeps with it every night. I cannot begin to explain how accurate and realistic these were. I’m forever grateful.
Response from PetslifyFeb 20, 2025
Thank you so much for your trust and patience, Amber! We’re thrilled to hear that your plushies brought so much joy and comfort to your family. Your kind words mean the world to us! 💕
NP
Nastia Pais D.
Absolutely worth it!
Actually I had no idea what to expect when I ordered this plush, but I’m beyond impressed! The similarity and quality is fantastic, plus they are way more affordable than cuddle clones or petsies, definitely recommended!
Response from PetslifyFeb 20, 2025
Thank you so much, Nastia! We’re thrilled to hear that you’re impressed with the quality and similarity of your plush. We truly appreciate your support and recommendation! 💖
DD
Diana D.
I lost my golden retriever
I lost my golden retriever, Max, earlier this year, and I wanted something to remember him by. I stumbled upon Petslify and decided to give it a try. I was honestly nervous about how the plush would turn out, but when it arrived, I was in tears. The details were incredible from his fluffy ears to the little white patch on his chest. It truly felt like a piece of Max was back with me , I’m rally happy guys!
Response from PetslifyFeb 20, 2025
Diana, your words mean so much to us! We’re beyond happy that Max’s plush brought you comfort and beautiful memories. Thank you for sharing!
MD
Michael D.
I ordered a Yorkie for my daughter that…
I ordered a Yorkie for my daughter that lost hers in October. I was told give up to 9 weeks to receive the fantom stuffed Yorkie. It has now been 13 weeks and all I get is Alex if that is even a real person saying thanks for my understanding and we are in the final stages for 7 weeks. These are scammers don’t be an idiot like I was . Mike
Response from PetslifyFeb 20, 2025
Dear Michael,
We sincerely apologize for the delay and any frustration this has caused. Our plushies are fully handmade, and while we always aim to deliver within the estimated timeframe, occasional delays can happen due to high demand and the meticulous work required. Our team has been keeping you updated, and we truly appreciate your patience. Please reach out to our support team directly so we can provide further assistance and ensure your order is completed as soon as possible.
Best,
The Petslify Team