alex L.
Selling on Fanatics Auction
Shipped an item to Fanatics Collect vault which was great. Very efficient! However, it was down hill from there. I put one of my items into the weekly auction and the buyer never paid. It took 10 days for the item to be returned to me. Once returned I put it into the "buy now" selling route, someone had then purchased it and again never paid. I am not sure why it is a feature for the item to be moved before the buyer has paid for the item. I am now waiting for it to be sent back to me. Having been into the Regents Street store in London a few times, it has always been a really good experience. However, this has been awful. I would like to mention Rodolfo at Customer Service who has been very efficient with there replies.
Response from Fanatics CollectJul 9, 2026
Hi Alex, thanks for taking the time to share your feedback. We're so sorry to hear you've had trouble with selling your cards. We are, however, happy to hear Rodolfo has been able to support. Our team is reaching out to you now over email to help, we'd like to help make this right.



