Box Genie helps brands create unforgettable unboxing experiences with high-quality, custom corrugated packaging. From custom mailer boxes and shipping boxes to product inserts and more, we make packaging that protects, impresses, and delivers.
Box Genie (boxgenie.com) has 146 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.4 out of 5.
Also known as
boxgenie.com
Website
boxgenie.com
Category
Shipping & Logistics
Location
Kansas City, Missouri
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 92% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Hi, Stef! Thank you for leaving a review of Box Genie, and the 5 stars!
Our team enjoyed working on your custom packaging project and can't wait for your next one. We're here for you for all your packaging needs!
Thanks,
The Box Genie Team
MS
Melanie S.
Awesome company!
The staff at box genie go above and beyond to make sure you are comfortable and understand the process. They answer questions quickly and in a way you understand. I'm not going anywhere else for boxes after my experience with them, they're the best.
Response from Box GenieMay 15, 2025
Hi, Melanie! Thank you for trusting Box Genie! It's been a pleasure working with you, and we love how your mailer box project turned out.
Our team already can't wait for your next custom box project!
Thanks,
The Box Genie Team
CU
customer
I came to your company specifically…
I came to your company specifically because you could accommodate a box insert. Halfway through, and many exchanges, I was told the price quote did not include an insert, and that I should have told them that is what I wanted. After asking for progress on sample, several times, no response. Thankfully I found a company more responsive, easier to work with and half the price.
Response from Box GenieApr 30, 2025
Hi Holly,
Thank you for your feedback, and we're truly sorry to hear that your experience didn’t meet expectations. At Box Genie, we do our best to fulfill all client requests promptly while ensuring the quality of our boxes remains high.
After checking in with our team, it looks like we didn’t receive the product needed to complete your custom insert. Since this step is essential to our process, we're sorry if that requirement wasn’t clearly communicated upfront.
We’d love the opportunity to clarify any remaining questions and make things right however we can. Please don’t hesitate to reach out — we're here to help.
Thanks,
The Box Genie Team
CL
Christine L.
The representative
The representative
Response from Box GenieMar 20, 2025
Thank you for your review! We're glad to hear you had a 5-star experience with your account manager.
Thanks,
The Box Genie Team
RA
Randy
Horrible Service & Delayed Timelines
Our first time ordering for our business has been a complete nightmare. Our current vendor no longer could do our sizes so we decided to give them a try. First we were told it would take them 1-2 days to match a proof, it ended up taking 5 business days. We were then told production would be 12-14 business days. On day 15, we were told the boxes are still in production because they were "busy". No communication of any of this was given and we had to reach out multiple times to even get a simple update. It has now been 25+ days and we do not have boxes to ship orders out in. We had to go to another source and pay rush fees because of the delays. We still have NOT received a timeline for when we will get our boxes. I highly recommend looking elsewhere.
Response from Box GenieFeb 4, 2025
Hi, Randy - we tried following up with you for information to help resolve this. Unfortunately, you left this review without an email or order number to reference. We look forward to your reply.
Thanks,
The Box Genie Team
AC
Ashley C.
Perfection from product to customer service.
I love the boxes I ordered from Box Genie soooo much! At first, I went through the process myself of trying to work with their default box sizes but ended up doing my own custom size for a specific product I sell. I ended up needing to ask support for something and was connected to Lynn. She literally guided me through every question I had and went as far as previewing my box image. The image I uploaded at first would have come out a bit blurry and she let me know that. I didn't have the time right then to edit my design, so came back a couple days later. She was still there to help me continue! Honestly, it's just nice to be connected with the same person that you initially started with. She already knew the look I was going for. After I uploaded my second design, she said it was perfect. She couldn't have been closer to the truth if she tried! I had some shipping issues where the default settings wanted me to pay some really high fee. I asked her about that and she agreed something wasn't right. When I was finally able to order, she adjusted the shipping price to make sure I wasn't being overcharged. Then there was the waiting game. Of course, these boxes are custom made, don't expect to receive them the next day. I thinkkkk it took about 3 weeks, give or take. Absolutely acceptable. When my boxes came in, I tore that box open and was in love. It's so cool to see my logo and design on the outside and inside of these boxes. I'm really proud to send these to my customers. Makes my shipping products a lot more professional.
Thank you, Lynn, for all of your help at each step and going out of your way to make sure what I was getting was perfect. Your customer service is what made me continue the buying process with Box Genie.
If you're on the fence, don't be. Order now. Can you maybe get a cheaper price somewhere else, maybe? But you won't get top notch customer support anywhere else.
Response from Box GenieJan 21, 2025
Hi Ashley,
Thank you for sharing your amazing experience! We’re thrilled to hear how much you love your boxes and that Lynn provided such exceptional support throughout the process. She truly goes above and beyond, and we’ll be sure to pass along your kind words.
It’s wonderful to know your boxes turned out perfectly and that you’re proud to send them to your customers. Your feedback means the world to us, and we’re so glad you chose Box Genie!
We can’t wait to work with you again.
Thanks,
The Box Genie Team
CM
C. M.
Tech could be improved
When providing the file, I was informed that they needed a pdf file format and could not except any raster based format. I then provided a flattened raster based file saved as a PDF with zero print advantage, but nearly 3 times the file size and was told that was perfect. Tech could use some basic education on how file format types actually work.
Response from Box GenieNov 25, 2024
Hi, Chris. Thank you for your feedback! We’re sorry for any confusion during the file submission process and appreciate you bringing this to our attention. Your input helps us improve, and we’ll work to ensure clearer guidance moving forward.
If you have any other concerns, we’re here to help.
Thanks,
The Box Genie Team
MN
MNagel
My rep was fantastic and helpful!
My rep was fantastic! She walked me through the whole process, making it super simple for me. She was really helpful moving my design over and reassuring it would look nice. Your company was easy to work with and the boxes arrived on time! Nice quality boxes, easy to assemble, sturdy, with nice printing! The color was true. I will definitely use you again!
Response from Box GenieNov 25, 2024
Hi, Mickie! Thank you for your thoughtful review! We’re so glad your rep made the process simple and ensured your design turned out great. It’s wonderful to hear you’re happy with the quality, colors, and timely delivery of your boxes.
We look forward to working with you again soon—thanks for choosing Box Genie!
Thanks,
The Box Genie Team