The Goth Society Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of thegothsociety.com

The Goth SocietyReviews of thegothsociety.com

3.420 reviews
Jewelry & Watches

The Goth Society

About The Goth Society

Jewelry for those who were never meant to blend in.The Goth Society is an independent, growing gothic jewelry brand built around individuality, symbolism and darker aesthetics.We curate pieces we believe deserve a place in your collection — from subtle everyday darkness to jewelry that refuses to go unnoticed.We're still growing, learning and refining our collection along the way. And when something doesn't live up to the standards we want for The Goth Society, we want to hear about it. Your feedback helps us decide what stays, what changes, and what we can do better.Welcome to The Goth Society. 🖤

The Goth Society (thegothsociety.com) has 20 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.4 out of 5.

Also known as: thegothsociety.com
Website: thegothsociety.com
Category: Jewelry & Watches
Listed on Five Star Index: 2026

About these reviews

Replies: The company replied to 95% of reviews.
Latest: Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits: Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score: This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.

How we calculate scores

Is this your business?

Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.

Claim this listing

More in Jewelry & Watches

takuyawatches.com
Jewelry & Watches
Excellent
317 reviews
317
Investment Watches
Jewelry & Watches · Austin, Texas
Excellent
262 reviews
262
Plum Diamonds
Jewelry & Watches · Chicago, Illinois
Excellent
376 reviews
376
European Watch Company
Jewelry & Watches · Boston, Massachusetts
Excellent
210 reviews
210

The Goth Society reviews

20 approved reviews, newest moderated first

Sarah T.
Oct 23, 2026
Fantastic brand!
Fantastic brand! Great quality she really unique alt stuff
Report
Basia I.
Oct 23, 2026
I’m obsessed 🖤
The jewelry is 100% me and totally matches my personality. Couldn’t be happier with it! 🖤
Response from The Goth SocietyOct 23, 2026
Hi Basia, That's exactly what we love to hear! 🖤 Jewelry should be an extension of who you are, and we're thrilled our pieces feel so you. Keep rocking your unique style. We're happy to have you in The Society! 🖤 Morgan The Goth Society
Report
Adam Ginnett I.
Oct 20, 2026
Its a SCAM!!
Its a SCAM!! This site is obviously a scam and trying to get your money, the deal seems good but its all dropshipped garbage do not buy!
Response from The Goth SocietyOct 20, 2026
Hi Adam, We're sorry to see you have such a negative impression of The Goth Society. Unfortunately, we haven't been able to identify an order or previous conversation connected to your review. We'd genuinely like to understand what happened. We've requested some additional information through Trustpilot so we can look into your concerns properly. Morgan The Goth Society
Report
Zoey G.
Oct 20, 2026
Amazing they rock and the quality is…
Amazing they rock and the quality is great!! Trusted site 🖤🖤
Response from The Goth SocietyOct 20, 2026
Thank you, Zoey! 🖤 We're so happy you love the quality of your pieces. Your support means a lot to us. Glad to have you in The Society! Morgan The Goth Society
Report
John Kristopher M.
Oct 11, 2026
The Goth Society listens!!!
EDIT: The Goth Society has reached out to me. They listened and gave me options that really helped me. Again, I know this was my mistake but they went above and beyond to help find a solution that I could live with. Thanks to The Goth Society ❤️ I made a mistake on my order and somehow got my ring sizes wrong. I emailed to ask about an exchange or return for a refund. They told me they can't do that and offered a ONE TIME courtesy of 50% off of one piece to make it right. The website does not state no returns on sale items (I got the bundle of 7 for $85) Get this, they also told me I am allowed to keep the pieces I have. DUH! If I am not exchanging them or getting a refund, why on God's green earth would I send them BACK?? Thanks for permission to keep the items I paid for. Disappointing customer service. The rings where nice quality but what good does it do me if I can't wear them. Again not the company's fault I measured wrong but the inability to help me fix it is crazy! What offensive options they gave.
Response from The Goth SocietyOct 12, 2026
Hi John, Thank you for sharing your experience. We're sorry about how your request was handled. We understand that the ring sizes were ordered incorrectly, but that doesn't mean we couldn't have tried harder to find a reasonable solution. We can also see why our previous response came across as unhelpful. We'd like to take another look at your order personally and see what we can do to make this right. We'll reach out to you directly. Morgan The Goth Society 🖤
Report
America B.
Oct 10, 2026
The quality of the jewelry is amazing
The quality of the jewelry is amazing, it feels nice and its super long lasting. I love how it doesn't turn my skin green after wearing it for a few hours.
Response from The Goth SocietyOct 12, 2026
Thank you, America! 🖤 We're so glad you're happy with the quality of your pieces. We really appreciate you sharing your experience! Morgan The Goth Society
Report
Lara U.
Oct 1, 2026
The shop has a really wide selection of…
The shop has a really wide selection of products, all of excellent quality. The metal is very sturdy, and the jewelry is made to last over time. I wear them every day and, so far, I can only give them a positive review! Highly recommended.
Response from The Goth SocietyOct 1, 2026
Thank you, Lara! 🖤 We're really glad to hear you're happy with the quality of your pieces and that they've become part of your everyday wear. We really appreciate you sharing your experience with The Goth Society. Morgan The Goth Society
Report
Misa P.
Sep 24, 2026
Great communication and fast shipping!
Great communication and fast shipping!
Response from The Goth SocietySep 29, 2026
Hi Misa, Thank you so much for the lovely review! 🖤 Morgan The Goth Society
Report