Jewelry for those who were never meant to blend in.The Goth Society is an independent, growing gothic jewelry brand built around individuality, symbolism and darker aesthetics.We curate pieces we believe deserve a place in your collection — from subtle everyday darkness to jewelry that refuses to go unnoticed.We're still growing, learning and refining our collection along the way. And when something doesn't live up to the standards we want for The Goth Society, we want to hear about it. Your feedback helps us decide what stays, what changes, and what we can do better.Welcome to The Goth Society. 🖤
The Goth Society (thegothsociety.com) has 20 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.4 out of 5.
Also known as
thegothsociety.com
Website
thegothsociety.com
Category
Jewelry & Watches
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 95% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Shipping was very slow and there was no communication during the shipping. In fact when we first checked it gave us incorrect information saying the package was close when it hadn't been shipped yet. We were under the impression that all of the rings were stainless steel, but at least two are copper and one feels too light to be stainless steel.
Response from The Goth SocietySep 22, 2026
Hi Catherine,
We'd really like to look into the rings you received and the shipping experience you described, but unfortunately we haven't been able to identify your order from the information available with your review.
Could you please share the name and email address used for the order and, if available, your order number?
That will allow us to find your order and look into this properly.
Morgan
The Goth Society
DT
dynamite T.
Multiple items not as advertised; lied to about earring replacement.
I found this company through an ad they placed on Pinterest advertising a bundle deal. They put a timer on the bundle page screen claiming the offer ends at 12 PM/AM (for me it was before noon as I was choosing the bundle pieces, but the website claimed the deal ended at midnight, shame on me for not listening to my gut) to add pressure...Well, it's been roughly a month give or take 5 days and they're still offering the same bundle. Conclude what you will from that.
I chose the smaller 5 items for $65 option they conveniently don't mention until you're looking into the 7 items for $85 bundle and are on the page for getting the bundle together. I picked out a skeleton necklace, an angel wings necklace, an axe necklace, a crow/raven bracelet, and crow/raven earrings. I ordered on a Wednesday and saw that orders take 3-5 business days to ship, so I figured it'd be sent by Monday.
I was initially pleasantly surprised when the order was ready for shipping by that Saturday, but then grew confused: two shipping updates 2 days later and then 5 days after the first update, but no actual information in the email. Just "Your shipping status has been updated". I figured it was probably just the item being pinged as being dropped off or picked up by different mailing centers as it made its way through shipping.
I got an email 5 days after the second shipping update: "We found a similar replacement for your order". What does that mean, you ask? Oh, it means that the order I thought was already on its way to me hasn't even been shipped out yet. The crow/raven earrings I picked out are now unavailable (despite still being listed as in stock on the website after I read the email and went to check out of curiosity). A "similar" pair of earrings that has noticeably more (unwanted) detailing was suggested in its place.
I admittedly got frustrated and did not respond until I was prompted to respond with a follow-up email 4 days later. I decided to take the rep on their word of "If you'd prefer something else instead, that's absolutely fine too. You're welcome to choose any item of equal value from our website, and we'll gladly update your order at no additional cost." I sent a link to a pair of angel wing earrings since they would match the necklace I picked out. About two hours later, I got a confirmation email saying "We've now updated your order with the replacement item you selected...and everything has been forwarded for processing. We'll also ask our fulfillment team to prepare and ship your order as quickly as possible."
What I initially thought would take maybe 2 and a half weeks max to arrive is now just now shipping because of the unavailable item. I figured, "Oh well, things happen. At least I got to pick out an alternative I actually like instead of them just assuming I wanted the replacement they offered since I really didn't like how that replacement looked, right?" I was even able to find the pair of earrings I initially wanted and ordered it by itself through another website.
The earrings I initially wanted and ordered through another website several weeks after the bundle STILL managed to arrive before the bundle did, and they arrived on the same day. Once the bundle finally arrived, I was initially impressed by how the store has its own custom bubble mailer and business card before disappointment hit me like a 16 wheeler truck. MULTIPLE items (crow/raven bracelet, axe necklace, angel wings necklace) do not match the images shown on the website. The ONLY item that matched what I initially ordered off of the website (out of FOUR) was the skeleton necklace.
The angel wings earrings I'd picked out as a replacement for the crow/raven earrings I'd initially wanted? No sign of them, with the replacement I detested in its place. The email LIED when it said "If we don't receive a reply within the next 3 days, we'll automatically refund the unavailable items to your original payment method and continue processing the remaining items in your order. Any bundle discount applied to your order will remain unchanged. *If you'd still like to choose a replacement instead, simply reply to this email within the next 3 days, and we'll happily update your order before it ships.*" The email I got telling me that my order was in transit came 2 DAYS BEFORE the follow-up email I just quoted. They'd never actually intended on replacing the earrings in time, it was just a courtesy email.
So to recap: I waited roughly a month for a jewelry bundle where all but one piece don't match the advertised images on the website and a pair of earrings I didn't want as a replacement for a pair still being listed as "in stock" on their website that I ended up getting for cheaper (before bundle discount) and faster off of another website. Great (sarcasm).
Response from The Goth SocietySep 22, 2026
Hi Spencer,
Thank you for providing your details. We've now been able to find your order and review your previous conversation with us.
Looking back at everything, we can see that we let you down in more than one way — including how the replacement you selected was handled. Some of our processes simply weren't good enough, and we're sorry.
We've made a number of changes since then to improve our product quality, communication and customer service, but that doesn't change the experience you had.
We're reaching out to you personally to make things right. 🖤
Morgan
The Goth Society