James
TL;DR Overall rating: 7 out of 10.
I wanted to share my experience with The Farmer’s Dog. I had high hopes, but a mix of logistics issues and poor communication really soured it for me. My shipments were set to arrive bi-weekly. According to their orders page, new shipments are supposed to arrive when you have about two days of food left. That didn’t happen. I ran out of food completely for my two dogs, had to go out and buy backup food, and it messed up their stomachs badly. Then, once the Farmer’s Dog shipment finally came, transitioning back to it gave them diarrhea so bad they ended up soiling their beds. When I first signed up, I answered all the questions about my dogs to set their food and calorie goals. I didn’t know how much they were eating before, but Farmer’s Dog recommended around 900 calories daily, a little less for the smaller one. These are large dogs, pit bull mixes, 70 lbs and 100 lbs. Even before starting this food, our vet had mentioned they could lose a few pounds. So I figured Farmer’s Dog knew what they were doing and went with their recommendations. I started to notice my dogs slimming down, and while I had a brief moment of concern that they might be getting a little too thin, I still trusted the system. Eventually, they had a routine vet appointment to update their shots, and the vet was shocked at how much weight they had lost. Since I’m with them all day, I didn’t notice the decline was that drastic, but apparently it was. The vet said they should be getting around 1,600 calories daily, and a bit less for the smaller dog. I was unknowingly underfeeding them for months. I reached out to customer service when our second shipment was about to be late, and I brought this up. They sent me a link to an article that basically shifted the blame onto me, saying I should have taken the dogs to the vet to monitor how they were doing on the new food. That was never made clear when signing up. Nothing in the first shipment or in my profile ever suggested that was something I needed to do. Food quality: 9 out of 10 Customer service and reliability: 0 out of 10 Overall rating: 2 out of 10. The food might be great, but the support, transparency, and logistics made this a stressful and potentially harmful experience. Update: The Farmer's Dog has since contacted me, apologized for the issues, and issued a full refund. While the initial experience was frustrating, I appreciate their quick response and effort to make things right. Updated Overall Rating and Conclusion: Food quality: 9 out of 10 Customer service & reliability: 0/10 initially, but the follow-up was 10/10 Overall rating: 7 out of 10. While the initial experience was very poor, the company has since contacted me, apologized, and issued a refund for the delayed box. The support and transparency were lacking at the time, but their follow-up was excellent.
Response from The Farmer's DogAug 4, 2025
Hi James, Thank you so much for your honest feedback here. We always aim to provide our customers with the best possible experience and I'm sorry we fell short of expectations. We calculate a pup's daily caloric intake based on current weight, target weight, body condition and activity level. That said, we know every dog is different which is why you can always update your pup's daily calories anytime through your customer account or by reaching out to us. We also strive to provide a seamless delivery experience where your next order arrives right when you need it, and would love to do whatever we can to make things right. for you going forward. Please reach out to us at [email protected] and reference this review, and one of our specialists will be happy to assist — we're here for you!



