Jens S.
RepairSmith Not recommended on any level.
Repair Smith NOT RECOMMENDED ON ANY LEVEL! Repair Smith has a simple but good website that allows one to pick the specific problem one needs to have fixed. The convenience and sales point here - they come to you! Price will also be shown right away for the specific services, which is great. It stops right there. PRICING: I needed a diagnostic for my vehicle due to engine light issues. Repair Smith’s Price for Check engine light Diagnosis is $170.00 for Diagnosis + $19.99 Mobile Service fee. It is quite expensive considering local repair shops charge on average anywhere from $119 - $125 for check engine light diagnostics. I couldn’t leave the vehicle at the local repair shop so I took a chance with Repair Smith despite the high price. Before finalizing the order and appointment day, Repair Smith offered replacement parts that could be added to the order before finalizing. In my case the option of a gas cap replacement and replacement Rear Oxygen Sensor (my vehicle has 2!) was offered. Whether it was necessary or not it still was offered as those parts can be a problem when a check engine light problem occurs. Gas cap replacement - $67.55! The part itself was listed at $33.55 Labor was listed at $34.00! Most people who read this know that a gas cap is a cheap part - usually anywhere from $6-$12 on average. It takes a maximum of 2 Minutes to take the old gas cap off and put the new one on! How is the labor cost of $34.00 justified? How is the price for the gas cap justified? Of course there are gas caps that cost more than $33 but not in my case. Second offer the oxygen Sensor replacement - an extra $245.29 if I’d choose this option. They list the Oxygen Sensor at $160.29 and labor Cost at $85! For my vehicle an oxygen sensor from Bosch (Premium OE fitment) is $25.50 (I have 2 so it makes sense to replace both). The Oxygen sensors are screwed into the exhaust pipe, one in front and one behind the Catalytic converter. They are 2 parts that are easy to get to, once the car is high enough to get underneath comfortably. Unplug the electric connectors unscrew the sensors, screw the new ones back in, plug the electric connectors back in - done. An experienced Mechanic should not need more than 6-8 minutes to replace both. How is a price of $245.29 justified, knowing the actual prices and labor times? Appointment: Up front - If you are not at home at the scheduled time Repair Smith charges you $50 for missing the appointment! They failed to show up 3 times in a row (Original Appointment was Tuesday, rescheduled for Friday, rescheduled for Saturday). I had not received any messages, emails or phone calls to tell me that the mechanic would not show up or run late. Each time I contacted customer service and they were apologetic telling me the mechanic was behind schedule and rescheduled. After Saturday I wanted everything canceled but they offered to waive the charges and come back on Sunday. I accepted and finally on Sunday, 3 hours past the scheduled time frame the mechanic showed up. I had the car ready for diagnostics - the mechanic hooked up his diagnostics tool and said I had an EVAP leak and a misfire problem (I knew that but had not been able to find the cause of these error messages. He ended up finding a small vacuum hose (PCV hose) that was brittle, told me to replace that erased the error codes from the car computer and called it diagnosed. I was charged despite having been told the diagnostics would be free of charge. Contacting customer service yet again - they told me that it had been a misunderstanding on my end but they did give me a discount and the final amount came down to $103. NOTHING WAS FIXED: I ended up ordering the PCV hose ($7) replaced it and drove the car about 100 miles before the same errors came back. In reality the diagnostic did not find the problem and therefore was incomplete. A real car shop would keep testing and searching until it would find the actual problem. Further - after the diagnostics my test results were ready (via email) . The report claimed that the vehicle had been checked for basic health - like tire pressure, wind-shield wipers, windows etc. I essentially don’t care about all that - but don’t claim you've added an “extra” service when you didn’t. The car was NOT test driven for a suspension test - as I said NOTHING that was claimed they had serviced had been actually checked. Again I essentially don't care about that as long as the actual problem is fixed. FINAL THOUGHTS: I wasted $103 and an entire week for a service that was not only managed extremely poorly but was not able to find the actual problem. I wonder how a company with such poor business practices can stay afloat - massively over-priced, not dependable and the worst, in my case, no results.


