Sarah N.
I cannot warn people strongly enough
I cannot warn people strongly enough: Petslify is a scam in practice if not in name. I paid $327 on March 29, 2025, for two custom plush replicas of our dog for my stepdaughters. After more than five months of excuses and copy-paste apologies, Petslify finally sent one package on August 14. Inside was not two dogs as promised, but a single plush of the wrong breed altogether. Our dog is a tan and white boxer with a nub tail. What arrived was a long-haired gray dog that looked nothing like him. Since then, the company has stalled behind an “investigation” instead of issuing a refund or providing replacements. I still have nothing I paid for, and my children left heartbroken. If you value your money or your memories, do not trust Petslify. They prey on grieving pet owners and then hide behind scripted emails when they fail. It's been over a week since I provided proof of evidence with photos requested by Petslify and they refuse to refund or replace the replicas or even give a timeline for an investigation, despite their website promise that "Yes! We offer a 100% satisfaction guarantee. If you’re not happy with your custom plush, we will provide a full refund. Additionally, we stand by the quality of our products with a lifetime warranty.".


