Custom stuffed animals of your pets! Petsies makes custom pet keepsakes for any pet, including Custom Plushies, Pillows, Blankets, Figurines, Pajamas, and more!
Petsies (mypetsies.com) has 290 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.7 out of 5.
Also known as
mypetsies.com
Website
mypetsies.com
Category
Children's Entertainment
Location
Boynton Beach, Florida
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 67% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: September 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Unboxing my petsie was a beautiful experience for me seeing her again and getting to hold her was just the greatest experience ever, from what I've just experienced all I can say is that this company is doing an amazing job they have really brought joy to my heart they have captured all my babies features and I'm ever so grateful. ♥️
Response from PetsiesFeb 2, 2024
I am so happy you had a great experience with us, and that your Petsie will now help give you a way to hold a piece of your fur baby again!
GO
Gillian O.
No regrets
Since I lost my heart dog Lilly I have been searching for anything that makes me feel better. They did such a fantastic job of recreating her. The details are honestly spot on. I cannot believe how good it is. Even though it won't replace her it gives me so muc. Comfort in my time of sadness. Best purchase I have made
Response from PetsiesJan 31, 2024
Thank you so much for leaving this review. We know nothing will ever replace your sweet Lilly, but we hope having this physical keepsake to hold will help you remember your favorite moments together!
DE
Demi
Absolutely overjoyed with my purchase
My petsie arrived today and I am over the moon. The likeness is uncanny and my whole family cried when we unboxed our little replica fur baby. Petsies was very professional and informative throughout the process and kept me well informed throughout it's journey. Honestly we are overjoyed by our purchase.
KC
Karen C.
I was under the impression that this…
I was under the impression that this was made in the United States, it was actually made in China. It was a waste of money. I would not recommend. This was purchased by my son Christopher for my Christmas present. I was disappointed in the construction and outcome of the product. Not worth 300.00
Response from PetsiesJan 17, 2024
Hello Karen,
We are very sorry you feel this way, but we in no way hide where our team creates our plushies. Our designers and seamstresses are extremely talented, skilled, and highly paid. Each stuffed animal is designed right here in Delray Beach, Florida. We also handle all quality inspection, packing/shipping, gift wrapping, and any touchups or repairs in our "Plush Hospital". To keep your prices down and get access to the best materials right at the source, the cutting and sewing takes place in our overseas facilities in China. Additionally, our team was unable to locate an order under your name. :( Please provide our team with your information and we will be happy to further assist you. Thank you- The Petsies Team
Edit: Thank you for providing the name under your order; I do see it in our system now. If you think that we missed the mark when making your Petsie, please email [email protected] so our team can figure out a solution for you. :)
-The Petsies Team
KB
Krislyn B.
I’m REALLY disappointed- low quality
I’m REALLY disappointed in my petsie order… I spent almost $400 on a plush of my sweet kitty that passed, he was my best friend and the first pet loss I’ve ever suffered. The plush I received has very accurate colors and is an okay twin (which is why I give it 2 stars) but it’s stiffer than taxidermy, the eyes are put in like uneven (the actual eyeball) with the crusty stitches or glue or something adhering it to the pet, the fluff level of his fur is not accurate except on the tail, and the fur has been falling out since I took it out of the box. It’s had a few hugs from me but other than that it sits on a shelf so there’s no reason for the fur to be clumping out.
Response from PetsiesJan 12, 2024
Hello Krislyn, We are very sorry and saddened to see this review. Our team has not received a message from you through Customer Service letting us know that you were unhappy with the plush. We encourage you to reach out to our Customer Service team via email at [email protected] so that we can potentially further assist you. -The Petsies Team
NT
Nicole T.
Custom Order
I had a custom order made of my sisters dog and the face looks nothing like her, the body is adequate but the head is totally wrong. My sister still loved it, even my other dogs sort of recognize it but the face is definitely not the same.
Response from PetsiesJan 11, 2024
Hi Nicole, thanks for your review. I’m sorry the plush didn’t come out as you expected it to, but I am glad your sister and dogs are loving it! If you do think we missed a specific detail, there are some things that we can alter at our main facility. Please email [email protected] if you’d like to chat with one of our customer service reps about this. Thanks!
TL
Timothy L.
Ordered Dec 7th no notice its Jan 2…
Ordered Dec 7th no notice its Jan 2 nothing. Literally no status nothing. Too many other sites can put your pets face on stuff - do not recommend
Response from PetsiesJan 3, 2024
Hi Timothy,
We are very sorry to see this review. :( We received your email from last week and a member of our team will be reaching out to you shortly. Not to worry. Your order is within the turnaround time we have listed on our website and our team is doing their absolute best to complete and ship these to you as quickly as we can. :) Thank you for your patience and understanding during this busy time of the year! -The Petsies Team :)
CM
charmaine M.
My baby boy has finally come home
My baby boy has finally come home. I have not long just lost my baby boy akira and having already knew about petsies it was a nobrainer I had to order one. The process was actually easy and quite quick they emailed me throughout the entire process and even asked for more photos for more detailing and before that I had already sent loads, so that was a good sign for me that they were trying to be as accurate as possible. I did not pay for a sneak peak and the main points I gave them were he had bright blue eyes and a pink marking on his nose and they got these features spot on. The making process was quick and the delivery to the UK was alot faster then I expected especially with it being around the Christmas time just over a week. I honestly love my plush, and while expensive to me it was worth it and I would buy again. Thank you to the petsie team that made him as he is perfect.
Response from PetsiesJan 2, 2024
Hi Charmaine, I'm so happy that we could give you a way to hug your baby boy Akira again! I am so sorry for your loss and we hope the Petsie is helping bring you some comfort when you are missing him most.