Shop our selection of engagement rings, wedding rings, diamonds, gemstones, metals, watches and more. Kay Jewelers carries a wide selection of looks, from classic to modern.
Kay Jewelers (kay.com) has 428 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 1.8 out of 5.
Also known as
kay.com
Website
kay.com
Category
Jewelry & Watches
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company has not replied to any reviews yet.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
If I could give them no stars I would. I ordered a ring in September at their Grove City, Ohio location and they messed up on the pricing so I canceled it then decided to give them another try on November 30, 2020 at their Tuttle Crossing Mall in Dublin, Ohio and they did it again and messed up the pricing and I asked if they would correct the price and the associate Lance was not helpful at all and said that he could not change the price. Really frustrated and upset because I let them fool me 2 times. Not only did I have to take a whole 30min drive to the mall but was very dissatisfied and I will cancel the order and no longer deal with Kay EVER.
HC
Hyman C.
FILING A COMPLAINT ON THE KAY JEWLERS…
FILING A COMPLAINT ON THE KAY JEWLERS AT THE KING OF PRUSSIA MALL ( 160 N. GULPH RD. ) PA.
WENT THER ON 11-15-2020 AND THE STAFF THERE LITERALLY DOES NOTHING !! BARELY GREET CUSTOMERS , EMPLOYESS JUST SITTING AROUND DOING NOTHING , CUSTOMERS COMPLAINING ABOUT BEING NEXT .. THAT STORE LOST MY BUSINESS FOR NOT GREETING ME OR ATTAENDING TO ME. BAD BUSINESS !!!
MP
Maria P.
KAY JEWLERS SUCKS
KAY JEWLERS SUCKS. MY HUSBAND SPENT $500 THERE FOR OUT 25TH ANNIVERSARY. I WANTED HIM TO RETURN ONE OF THE ITEMS AND THEY WOULDNT RETURN IT BECASUE IT WAS ON THE 30TH DAY OF THE PURCHASE. HE THEN ASKED THEM TO FIX 2 CHEAP ANKLE BRACLETS AND THEY WANTED TO CHARGE HIM $70.00. ALL THEY NEED TO DO WAS HOOK TWO LOOPS TOGETHER. WE WILL NEVER WASTE OUR MONEY THERE AGAIN.....
DW
Destini W.
I will be canceling this my order
I will be canceling this my order. I order a ring for my 15 year wedding anniversary. I clearly remember selecting the$30 option for over night to Kay Jewelers store closest location since purchased online. I can escalated to a manager advise I would pay more I just needed to ring. Which I PAID IN FULL FOR AND SHIPPING!!! They told me can not ship item any fast and will go out 11/09/2020... How is it you can ship any faster. This is pooooorr customer service and again I offered to pay what ever for the expedited process. I will go to Jared’s instead. This makes no sense and when I am will to pay more if need be and you have till what a week to send it and pay $30. I will be reviewing on all social media sites. First and last time!!!! You can take the $1k+ payment but not expedite the shipping??
TH
Tessa H.
So I dropped off my ring with Kay…
So I dropped off my ring with Kay Jewelers around the first of September to have it resized and soldered and the promise date to be back was supposed to be 9/26/20, but it didn’t come back till 10/3/20. So we went to go pick it up and when we get there my rings aren’t soldered together, so now we have to send it off to get soldered together which should have been done the first time to begin with, so now my promise date was 10/11/20 and it doesn’t come back till 10/16/20, so we go and pick it up and the soldering job is very sloppy, but I just leave it be. Well I wear my ring ONE day and the biggest diamond in my ring falls out within 24 hours. So my husband goes back and checks his email cause we got curious about the ring and as he’s checking his email he realizes all the pics that came back all had different characteristics marked on my diamond. So we call customer service to be told when the diamond came back the same characteristics should have been marked again, as it only makes sense so we can make sure it’s the same diamond that was sent off. We also ask the store we drop it off at why different characteristics are marked and they say it depends on who takes the pics, they may spot different characteristics and mark those, which makes absolutely no sense considering we wouldn’t be able to tell if the diamond was mine. Well now at this point my ring is now going to take up to 6 weeks for the LARGEST retail of diamond jewelry in the WORLD, Signet Jewelers to source a freaking diamond. And to top it all off the diamond swapping team should have called us back in 7-10 business days, it’s been over 10 days and still no call back. This is the SECOND time customer service hasn’t returned our call. At this point I’m ready to call my lawyer to handle all of this. Gina Coleman Drosos you my dear need to get your company together, maybe Claire Drosos can relay this message to you, cause I’m over your WHOLE company. Worst company and customer service I have ever dealt with. Let me hear your nightmares about Kay’s. #sharethispost
YC
yanira C.
the worst online store
the worst online store. I order a ring to be delivered to my closest store, my bank account was charged and the ring was never delivered, it was sent back to the home store because they couldnt found the address of the store..how if it was sent from store to store the delivery company didnt found the address???
FE
FeFe
Overpriced
Overpriced. I have purchased some gold chains from them where they advertised as solid but they were hollow. Bad deal.
CR
Caitlin R.
Unprofessional and Incompetent
The necklace my mother purchased at the Sebring Kay Jewelers had a small clasp and she asked the sales associate if a larger clasp could be put on. She said yes and told her that it would be available for pickup in about two weeks. She explained that times were a little extended due to the pandemic. We of course understood that and were accepting of the two week timeline. Donna was very nice to us and I want to put an emphasis on that. This is not a complaint about her. I had purchased a ring at the same time my mother purchased her necklace. I needed it resized so they were sent off together. I went to the store to pick up my ring and her necklace after the two weeks and my mothers necklace was not there. The sales associate Amber contacted my mother via phone to inform her that there was nothing wrong with her necklace. My mother acknowledged she knew that there was nothing "wrong" but that and it was sent off to have a larger clasp put on. My mother expressed to me that Amber was not very helpful on the phone so I went to the store with her to sort this out (about 2 weeks after the phone call with Amber). When we arrived Amber greeted us dressed very inappropriately. She had on what looked like yoga pants with a tank top and a cover up. This tank top was a lace front and was cut down to about her navel. I'm not sure if that is a new sales tactic Kay Jewelers is encouraging, however, I am not impressed. Not only was she dressed unprofessionally, but her demeanor coincided with this attribute. My mother was frustrated, with good reason, but remained professional (this is now 1 month + after the purchase date). Amber did not empathize with the situation and was rude to us. She made us feel as though we were an inconvenience. Regardless of the poor customer service we left thinking the situation had been handled. It is now 2 months + after she purchased the necklace and she still has not received it. She has not been contacted about the status of her necklace and has made two payments towards the item on her credit card. I have had such a horrible experience at the Sebring store I do not plan on shopping there again in the future.
This was my original review (with 5 stars):
I had a fantastic experience at the Kay Jewelers in Sebring, Fl. My mother and I stopped in after brunch to pick up a pair of earrings I had sent off for repair. The customer service was excellent. My consultant (I think her name was Donna) was very friendly and knowledgeable. After I received my earrings back my mother and I decided to browse around a bit. The consultant was prompt in aiding us. She made the experience fun and relaxing. We both made purchases and she helped us find the perfect pieces to suit our individual style. Excellent customer service!