Finding affordable car insurance that fits your budget doesn’t have to be difficult. With IIA, we can help you shop around with our 20+ carriers and locate a policy that aligns with your coverage requirements. Whether you’re looking for minimum liability, full coverage, or something in between, our friendly, experienced team can help guide you through your insurance journey.
Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc. (infinityauto.com) has 566 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 2.3 out of 5.
Also known as
Infinity Insurance Agency, infinityauto.com
Website
infinityauto.com
Category
Insurance
Location
Mcallen, Texas
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 89% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Horrible insurance After buying a new 2020 Telluride I decided to try and save a little money and left Geico, boy was this the biggest mistake of my year. I dont feel like getting a long story but dont ever use this company they are horrible.
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.May 4, 2021
Good morning, Jesse. We're sorry and want to help you out until you are completed satisfied. Moreover, we invite you to send your name and a policy number to [email protected] to set your situation right. Thank you for your message. Sincerely, Orlando CS Consultant
AM
Amber
ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE
ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE. THE INSURANCE ADJUSTER TATIANA IS A LIAR! My husband got into an accident with one of their insurers and she lied straight to us and said there was so bodily injury on their policy and once my lawyer was involved we found out they did have bodily injury! YOU GUYS ARE TRASH.
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Apr 29, 2021
Good afternoon, Amber. Our apologies for any inconveniences you may be experiencing. Moreover, we want to make amends and give some assistance. We can start reviewing your concerns the moment you send a name, a claim number, and good contact information to [email protected]. Thank you for your message. Have a great day. -Orlando, CS Consultant
BJ
bell J.
Dont ever buy from here!!!!!
Dont ever buy from here! I had payed for a full coverage because I had bought a car from the dealer. When I damaged my vehicle because I hit a post I posted a claim. I was calling and calling for three days straight to hear about my claim because I only got called one but missed the call. I call about 20 times each day always going to voicemail and mind you I call at different times during the day. Even left voicemails, I even called the managed of claims and NOTHING! I had to go all the way to the agency who sold me the insurance and have them call me. Finally after tons of calling and voicemails I got through only for them to tell me THAT I DID NOT HAVE FULL COVERAGE ONLY LIABILITY. How is that possible I bought the car FROM A DEALER ITS SUPPOSE TO BE FULL COVERAGE! DO NOT BUY FROM HERE PLEASE!
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Apr 29, 2021
Good morning, Bell J. We didn't mean in the least to cause you any unpleasant experiences. Moreover, to start resolving your situation please send your name, a claim number, and your contact information to [email protected]. We look forward to hearing from you. Have an excellent day. -Orlando, CS Consultant
JU
jungledog
My wife’s friend has xfinity insurance…
My wife’s friend has xfinity insurance and this is by far the worst company I’ve ever heard of. Currently my wife’s car is at the body shop and the owner is holding onto it because xfinity sent a check that expired and the new check that he’s expecting is constantly promised to be mailed out tomorrow. It has been two months. No one returns my calls. I think she would’ve been better off being hit by someone who has the General Insurance.
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Apr 27, 2021
Hello, jungledog. We apologize for any inconveniences. We want to rectify your situation and can start doing so the moment you send a name, a claim number and contact information to [email protected]. Thank you for your message. We hope to make amends in the near future. -Orlando, CS Consultant
JO
Jennise O.
Mal servicio al cliente,malos…
Mal servicio al cliente,malos ajustadores,en noviembre del 20 mi mama choco el auto, 1ro mandaron un cheque por 1700,les dije que eso no cubría los gastos, luego me dijeron a los dos meses que fuera a un taller,resulta que el auto fue perdida total,y el abril del 2021 aun estoy esperando el pago, la ajustadora kayla jones una persona grosera y rasista,me dijo que no me pagaría un dolar más de los 1700,y que en este país se hablaba ingles, llame di la queja y la cambiaron, total aun estoy esperando por el pago de mi auto y 5 meses sin el,realmente muy decepcionado.
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Apr 19, 2021
Buenos días, Jennise. Fue muy comprensivo de su parte llamar nuestra atención sobre esta situación. Perdone mi demora en responder. Además, nos gustaría ayudar a aclarar su reclamo. De hecho, podemos comenzar en el momento en que envíe su nombre, un número de reclamo e información de contacto a través de [email protected] para resolver la situación de su madre. Gracias por tu mensaje. —Orlando, CS Consultant
JR
Jonathan R.
This insurance is a joke
This insurance is a joke. I wish I would of kept progressive. Trust me, 2019 white Camry with 20,000 miles, first accident. Estimates at 12,000. Mainly front passenger front fender damage and front bumper. 4 adjusters reassigned don’t know why, no answers nothing just to say well we’re estimating 12,000 but we’re declaring this a total loss because of cost of tear eown( uh tear down price? Lol to rip out old parts? Never seen that on an invoice) and because of possibility of further damages under hood. I went and looked at the car carefully inspected it when picking up my plate and personal belongings. No frame damage nothing. The lady adjuster tried telling me one of my lights alone is 1500 for a refurbished one at all. ( a complete and utter lie, I had a light changed it was $600 dealership price with labor included OEM). Car was a 40,000 car v6 XLE. How pathetic of an insurance, very disappointed and the adjuster declared my car a total loss out of just an outside surface inspection. Car was immaculate, the car was drivable, no engine damage. Radiator wasn’t even punctured nothing. The car was picked up by another shop go figure. They made sure to answer then to pick it up, because that cars getting repaired and resold. I learned my lesson hard. I would rather pay the extra 120 a month than to save the money for a 1 star worst reviewed insurance. In the end it cost me a whole lot more. They are cutting a check for the finance to the bank to start from zero? The car had 12,000 put into it with 6500 down payment and monthly payments for the year and month I had it. And I would of rather kept my car and had it fixed. And even the body shop at dealership people said wow this is fixable, and explained to me their bad experiences as well. You live you learn. Never again after this period trashing this policy. 3 people on policy for 3 cara, no never again.
* in response. Cant contact a company that never answers nor calls back after repeated messages. They sure were fast to pick up the car though. Another shop called me in a rush to pick up the car. I know the business, it’s not hard to imagine why
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Apr 12, 2021
Good morning, Mr. Rosas. I'm sorry you were dissatisfied with the outcome of the claim. You have every right to be upset. Moreover, if you want to review your situation in further detail, then we ask for you to send your name, a claim number, and your contact information to [email protected]. Thank you for contacting the insurance Company with your concerns. Have an excellent day. —Orlando, CS Consultant
CG
Chris G.
Ok so I get this letter in the mailbox…
Ok so I get this letter in the mailbox stating that somehow my name and driver's license was breached by infinity and all they tell me is to contact Equifax I want answers and I want them now I'm getting my lawyer and I'm suing for damages I can't even think of right now not to mention down the road whoever's got my information this is bs and I dont think it is right a flippin letter dated March 16 when this breach happened in December 2020 4months later they tell me heck no
LM
luz M.
Parra las personas que buscan seguro…
Parra las personas que busca seguro está aseguranza infinity definitivamente es un fraude tengan mucho cuidado solo van a tirar su dinero a la basura,yo tuve una muy mala esperiecia hace poco chocaron dos de mis carros y la persona huyó y cuando me comuniqué dijeron que me enviarían al ajustador eso nunca pasó yo le tuve que hablar y el hombre fue sumamente racista ,grosero y prepotente y que no sabía cómo estaba mi caso porque cuando le estaba explicando me callaba y con todas sus letras me dijo que ellos no me iban a pagar ,una experiencia que no le deseo a nadie y al final no me ayudaron en nada afortunadamente yo obtuve el reporte de policía y así la otra aseguranza pago los daños la aseguranza es State Farm por cierto muy buena ellos me ayudaron en todo lo que pudieron y fue rápido porque infinity nunca me ayudaron y eso que les mande el reporte nunca se comunicaron con la otra aseguranza no me ayudaron en nada ah y la otra ajustadora jamás se comunicó le llame y no nunca respondió por favor tengan cuidado especialmente mi gente hispana porque este tipo de aseguranzas nunca responden y simplemente pagas por nada investiguen antes que todo..
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Mar 25, 2021
Buenos días, Luz. Nuestras disculpas por cualquier experiencia negativa que haya experimentado. Además, fue muy comprensivo de su parte llamar nuestra atención sobre este asunto. Además, le recomendamos que envíe su nombre, un número de reclamo y su información de contacto a nuestro [email protected] para resolver su consulta si hay elementos pendientes por abordar. Gracias por su mensaje y esperamos hacer concesiones para este escenario. Qué tengas un lindo día.—Orlando, CS Consultant