Finding affordable car insurance that fits your budget doesn’t have to be difficult. With IIA, we can help you shop around with our 20+ carriers and locate a policy that aligns with your coverage requirements. Whether you’re looking for minimum liability, full coverage, or something in between, our friendly, experienced team can help guide you through your insurance journey.
Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc. (infinityauto.com) has 566 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 2.3 out of 5.
Also known as
Infinity Insurance Agency, infinityauto.com
Website
infinityauto.com
Category
Insurance
Location
Mcallen, Texas
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 89% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
It’s been a month still , I have had no answer I even emailed you and no answer
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Jan 21, 2020
Good Afternoon Ms. Simone,
We apologize for any lack of communication you may have experienced. We certainly do not conduct business in this manner. I have reviewed and it does not appear we have received an email from you, Ms. Simone. Please confirm you have emailed [email protected] and we would be more than happy to assist you. Thank you.
-Sarinah, CS Consultant
EE
Evelin E.
Worst
Worst ? Worst it’s too little of a word, how is it that we set to pay monthly $170.00 and out of the blue were supposed to pay $300.00 because of a change of address. I will never use this company again. When we decide there is not way we’re going to pay that amount, they force us to pay $84.00 because we change from them to another company!!!!
Very unfair.
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Jan 21, 2020
Good Morning Evelin,
Thank you for contacting us with your concerns. We are sorry to hear about the billing concerns you have expressed and we would like to review and answer any questions you may have. At your discretion, please send us an email to [email protected] with your policy number in order to better assist you. We look forward to your response. Thank you.
-Sarinah, CS Consultant
BW
Bonnie Whittle L.
This insurance company is a bunch of…CROOKS
This insurance company is a bunch of crooks. My sisters car was parked in front of her apartment the guy that had infinity insurance ran into it and his insurance isn’t even talking to my sister who by the way is in the hospital now. No she wasn’t in the car when it was wrecked. They just will not do their job! My sister needs to go to dialysis three times a week and they have to call a cab because infinity refuses to pay for the rental of a car or any car while their other car is not being repaired because they’re not doing that either do not use this insurance company!!!
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Jan 20, 2020
Hello Bonnie,
We are awfully sorry to hear about your experience. Also, we would like to amend this situation. In order to receive assistance, we kindly ask that you send us an email to [email protected]; including a policy number or a claim number to have the appropriate individuals help you out with this. We look forward to being of assistance, Bonnie. Thank you for contacting Infinity Insurance with your concerns. Have an excellent day.
-Orlando, CS Consultant
ED
Earl D.
Don't get screwed
I got insurance thru Infinity paid in full then was told they would not insure my truck so to cancel my policy they would charge me plus a 20.00 cancellation fee. Took my money in 30 seconds off my credit card and said it would take three weeks to get my money back. I don't recommend this company to anyone. Run don't walk away and find another company.
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Jan 17, 2020
Good Afternoon Earl,
Thank you for taking the time to leave us a review. We are sorry about any inconvenience this may have caused you. Furthermore, we would like to review your concerns. At your earliest convenience, send us your policy number to [email protected] and we would be glad to investigate further. Hope to hear from you soon. Have a great day.
-Heyssel, CS Consultant
CW
Crimson W.
Absolutely abysmal service
Absolutely abysmal service, no sense of urgency, and almost no sign of responsibility.
Infinitiy claimed fault for a T-bone accident i got into several months ago. I was unable to drive the car after the accident due to structural repairs that needed to be done to the chassey. For several months, i would frequently receive little to no response at all from infinity. I had to constantly nudge them to get off their butts and reslove my case. After dozens of emails and several (unsuccessful) attempts to reach them by phone, it took them almost THREE MONTHS just to send an adjuster out, and even then, they had to send an adjuster out three different times because they kept calling an adjuster from california to go look at my car, which was sitting in an auction lot in central texas. HOW DOES THIS HAPPEN? My insurance company had an adjuster out to look at my vehicle the SAME DAY i took it in for evaluation. Complete incompetence.
After several months of being without a car, im down several thousand dollars due to vehicle rental. Which i expected to be compensated for with a loss of use program of some kind. But no, when i asked the rep i was assigned, Jaime Aguilar, he pretty much acted like he had no idea what i was talking about. He asked for an invoice for my car rental and he said hed see what he could do. After sending him an invoice, and then emailing him about it again, he stopped answering my emails and has not called me back about it. I tried calling his supervisor, Natelie Elison, as well but, of course, she never answers the phone and i cant even leave her a message because her machine is always blocked up. Since my car has been repaired, I have been emailing Jaime from infinity every day in an attempt to get a response at all from him about this.
So thanks Infinity. Thank you for sitting on you butt for MONTHS doing diddly squat while i was without a car and then footing me with the bill for your own mistakes. Real classy.
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Jan 16, 2020
Good Morning Mr. Wallace,
Thank you for taking the time to share your very valuable feedback. We apologize for your unpleasant experience and for any inconvenience we may have caused. Your adjusters have been notified of your request and they will be contacting you soon if they have not done so already. If we may assist you further, we encourage you to continue communicating via email. Thank you and have a great day.
-Sarinah, CS Consultant
JB
jason B.
Horrible company
Horrible company, I got rear ended at a red light by one of the people they insure and they Deny the claim. Didn't stay in contact with me, never returned phone calls, could care less. Please show somewhere else.
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Jan 15, 2020
Hi Jason,
We greatly regret your dissatisfaction. These are, by all means, not the type of beliefs that we want any one to have. As a result, we would be interested in further reviewing this situation. Please send us a policy number or a claim number via email to: [email protected] to further assist. We look forward to being of assistance. Have a great day.
-Orlando, CS Consultant
AN
Aimee N.
How are they in business????? THE WORST
How are they in business? Literally the WORST company ever. 1) Husband has an accident on 11/30/19, files claim the same day. 2) Infinity tells him he can only take it to two 'approved' body shops (both 25 miles away) if he wants them to pay for it. It's CLEARLY written in our policy that we can take the car to a mechanic of OUR choice!!! Infinity finally says 'fine, but we'll only pay 80%'. Ok, whatever, let's get it fixed. 3) My husbands truck sat at the auto body shop for 30 DAYS waiting to be paid by infinity. The auto body shop threatened to charge $100/day for storage. 4) So so so SO many unreturned calls from our terrible 'representative', hold times are 20 mins plus each time, etc. Seriously, DO NOT TOUCH THIS COMPANY with a 100' pole.Hope Infinity enjoys my report to the California Dept of Insurance!! Bye Felicia!
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Jan 15, 2020
Good morning Aimee,
Thank you for contacting Infinity Insurance with your concerns. We greatly regret your dissatisfaction. Consequently, we would like to further research your issue. In order to further research this topic, we kindly ask that you send us an email to [email protected]. If you decide to send us an email, then please include a policy number or a claim number, along with a phone number to have the appropriate individuals followup with you. We look forward to serving you. Have a marvelous day.
-Orlando, CS Consultant
KB
Karen B.
Worst insurance EVER
I was stopped in heavy traffic and the lady behind me was also stopped. A guy who has Infinity didn't stop and pushed her car into mine. He then fled the scene, but we had his plate number and the cops gave us his name and insurance information.
Infinity is dragging their heels about paying because they can't determine who the driver was. GIVE ME A BREAK! The guy claims he leant his car to someone who he doesn't know their name or where they live and that person brought it back to him damaged saying they had hit a pole. REALLY?!?! They loaned their 20-3-K vehicle to a complete stranger and never asked their name even when they brought it back damaged?
And now I'm stuck without a vehicle and an adjust and her supervisor who won't assist me or answer me. Her voicemail even says "If I dont' return your call email me". Seriously?! Who does that? In my work if I don't return my customers calls I get fired.
Update: the people who responded below are very polite, but useless. All they do is notify the people who won’t respond to me in the first place. So I continue to be ignored with no one returning my calls or emails.
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Jan 14, 2020
Good Day Karen,
We are terribly sorry to hear about your unpleasant experience with your claim. We are also very sorry you feel this way and can assure you this is not how we want anyone to feel. At your discretion, please send us an email to [email protected] including your claim number and phone number and we would be more than happy to review and answer any questions you may have. We look forward to hearing from you. Thank you and have a wonderful day.
-Sarinah CS Consultant