Finding affordable car insurance that fits your budget doesn’t have to be difficult. With IIA, we can help you shop around with our 20+ carriers and locate a policy that aligns with your coverage requirements. Whether you’re looking for minimum liability, full coverage, or something in between, our friendly, experienced team can help guide you through your insurance journey.
Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc. (infinityauto.com) has 566 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 2.3 out of 5.
Also known as
Infinity Insurance Agency, infinityauto.com
Website
infinityauto.com
Category
Insurance
Location
Mcallen, Texas
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 89% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
I just also want to say this company is extremely horrible. Please take some time to read their reviews before you purchase insurance. I filed a claim against my Comp and collision policy because I hit something in the road that was unavoidable. My repairs were almost $3000. The adjuster claims he found the parts and labor cheaper and they were only willing to cover about $490. I had my girlfriend go to several shops just to see if it is cheaper than the dealer and all estimates came out to be practically the same and many of the shops stated to keep it at the dealer because we would not do work that complicated. Please take some time to read the reviews before you buy this insurance.
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Aug 20, 2020
Good morning Candice Bonney and we thank you for your review. We sincerely apologize about your current claim status. We would be more that happy to review this for you. In order to better assist you , please send us an email to [email protected] with your claim number and best contact information. We look forward to your response. Thank you and have a great day.
-Juan, CS Consultant.
LS
Liz S.
It's a very bad company
It's a very bad company! I was paying a full coverage policy and one of my family members crush my car and they dont want to cover not even the towing just cuz the person that it was driving is not in the policy but they never told me that if someone that is not in the policy cush the car the policy was not gonna pay for my claim
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Aug 19, 2020
Good afternoon Ms Salinas, Thank you for your review. We are sorry to learn that you are dissatisfied with the outcome of your claim and welcome the opportunity to look into the matter. Please send an Email to: [email protected] and include your policy/claim number, your contact number along with a brief description of the issue for a private and secure response. Thank you for your time and have a great day.
-Miriam, CS Consultant
NM
Norman M.
unprofessional and rude
This insurance company is unprofessional. I'm working at repair facility, and helping customer to claim at insurance. I helped customer to claim his accident, the adjuster is rude and she yelling all the time. The customer was very upset about it.
We started to fix the customer's vehicle, they are really hard to contact. They always dealt with us in an unkind and unprofessional attitude. They want to check every jobs that we do. They approve the estimate and supplement, but they didn't pay or issue any payment until they are satisfied with the result of the repairs. So we bought all parts from our body shop first, and fixed it.
The customer was very satisfied and wanted to pick up the car. We explained to customer, we are feel so sorry for the delay, but the infinity insurance didn't issue any payment, so customer should to wait until infinity insurance make payment. They told us to send the photos of repair, and the appraiser come out and check it. They asked for a invoices for every part that we bought. They made all sorts of excuses and refused to pay. Customer waited long time and still cannot pick up the car. Other insurance company always think customer's care first and tried to give a good dealer part or oem part to fix the customers vehicle. But infinity insurance gave all after market parts price to replace, and even that put the payments on hold. Appraiser told us he will come back, but he never show up. So we contact insurance company again and wait. They don't care at all about the customer waiting delayed time.
Also our shop is not designated by the infinity insurance, so they charged more deductible to customer. No one explain to us and customer until we finish to fix the car, so customer really upset about that.
They don't even give customers the basic freedom to choose the store that customers want to fix the vehicle.
We've been doing body shops for over 30 years, but we've never seen such an unprofessional insurance company.
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Aug 14, 2020
Hello, Norman Maria. We are distressed to learn that you and/or your body-shop may have had an unpleasant experience while transacting with the Company. We certainly do apologize for any substandard service that may have been rendered, and are sorry if you were treated in a disparaging manner. Moreover, we regret the difficulties and would like to extend supplemental assistance should you have any unsettled issues. Besides, we will be delighted to start reviewing our scenario, the moment you deliver an email to [email protected] of which should contain a policy number or a claim number—to better serve you. Thank you for calling to our attention to this matter.
-Orlando, CS Consultant
BH
Been H.
Dishonest and useless
Infinity auto insures high-risk drivers who are too reckless to afford insurance from legitimate companies and really should not be on the road. They are able to make money only because they ignore claims when their drivers crash into other unsuspecting drivers.
It was months before the adjuster even called me back after making my claim. They paid next to nothing and honestly, it would have been more efficient for me to just pay out of pocket than to waste the dozens of frustrating hours dealing with their lies, deception, and delays for their paltry payout that did not cover the damage.
The company is essentially a sham and state regulators do nothing despite the numerous complaints against this company. They are a detriment to the communities in which they are allowed to operate!
If you are struck by one of their drivers you are going to have to sue to get reasonable treatment, so get organized, keep excellent notes and mop the floors with this fraudulent "company."
Also file your complaint with the state auto insurance commission. They are going to have to stop ignoring the problem at some point and take action. The entire reason liability insurance is legally required is to avoid cases where someone is struck by an at fault driver and ends up paying all of their own medical bills and for their car repair. This company is collected the premiums, but not providing protection to motorists.
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Aug 11, 2020
Good morning. We are sorry you were dissatisfied with the length of the claim and with the outcome. Your annoyance is understandable. We always feel bad when a consumer is not satisfied with our services. We have carefully considered your review and would like to research your situation further. Moreover, in order to further examine your case, we ask that you provide a claim number or a policy number to our email: [email protected]. Lastly, if we can answer any other questions, please write. Thank you for your writing to the Company. Have a terrific day.
-Orlando, CS Consultant
SG
Silly G.
NO communication. RUDE not to return calls.
MY son who is insured on my policy was in an accident with an Infinity customer on 07/22/2020. Their customer was at fault and my son is injured. We have heard absolutely nothing from Infinity at all and neither has our insurance company despite numerous attempts on both my part via voice mail to the adjuster and her supervisor and my insurance carrier has left messages and sent emails. Maybe an attorney would have better luck???? They suck.
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Aug 7, 2020
Good morning. We were distressed to learn about your unpleasant experience. Please accept our sincere apologies for what's recently happened with your case. I can understand why you are angry. The least I can do is to try to correct the situation to the best of my abilities. Moreover, in order to begin examining your scenario, we kindly ask that you send out an email to [email protected] which should contain a claim number or a policy number to better serve you. Thank you for your patience and understanding.
-Orlando, CS Consultant
AC
America C.
Got in an accident on March and haven't…
Got in an accident on March and haven't received a call back since April. Haven't gotten my money and i've called several times now. I had the same issue the guy underneath me went through. They never communicate with the customers. 😑 worst insurance by far
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Aug 4, 2020
Good morning, America.
We are terrible sorry to hear about your unpleasant situation. Also, we apologize as these are not the sort of sentiments that we want any consumer to have. Moreover, we would like to have the adjusters and/or managers reach out to you with a claims status update. In order to give some assistance, we kindly ask that you delivery an email to: [email protected] which should contain a policy number or claim number to better serve you. Thank you for contacting the insurance company with your concerns. Have an excellent day.
-Orlando, CS Consultant
TR
Tiago R.
Be carefull with AUTOMATIC PAYMENTS!
At the beginning of May, i asked costumer service to set up autopay(its on my bank statement), and that payment was in fact made, but it never recurred. Is your autopay service the kind i got to callback every month to have it applied again?! No! it does not make sense does it?! So its August now, my last payment was in March (autopayed, its in my bank statement)...! Why was my automatic payment only applied once in March and never again since then?!
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Aug 3, 2020
Good morning, Tiago. Please accept our apologies for any issues you may have experienced while transacting with the Company. Certainly, we'd like to review your query. Moreover, if you want like to further research your scenario, then we ask that you delivery an email to: [email protected] which should contain a claim number or a policy number. We look forward to hear from you. Thank you and have a marvelous day.
-Orlando, CS Consultant
IR
Irina R L.
MERECEMOS UNA RESPUESTA
Estoy tratando de contactar con la ajustadora de mi caso hace mas de dos meses. Mi carro sufrio perdida total por una condicion natural, envie los documentos que me solicitaron, el GAP esta esperando por un comprobante de pago de su parte. Mientras les sigo pagando seguro, sigo pagando mi letra del carro. Entiendo la posicion de ustedes como negocio pero y la de nosotros?. Merecemos una llamada, una respuesta de nuestro seguro al que le confiabamos mes tras mes nuestros intereres...
Response from Infinity Insurance Agency, Inc.Jul 29, 2020
Buenas tardes Irina, Lamentamos que aún no haya recibido respuesta sobre su reclamación. Entendemos lo frustrante que es no tener la información necesaria. Para mejor asistirle, por favor mándenos un mensaje con una breve descripción, incluyendo su número de Reclamos/Póliza y el mejor numero de telefono de contacto a el correo electrónico: [email protected] Muchas Gracias y que tenga un buen dia.
-Miriam, CS Consultant