GoodBuy Gear is the leader in quality-checked open box and secondhand gear for families. Shop 2,600+ brands and save an average of 55% off retail, every item inspected by our experts.
GoodBuy Gear (goodbuygear.com) has 365 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.1 out of 5.
Also known as
goodbuygear.com
Website
goodbuygear.com
Category
Malls & Marketplaces
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 97% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
We ordered a stroller and received a wagon. The return is a big hassle and after two weeks still no refund.
Response from GoodBuy GearJun 24, 2026
Hey there, thank you for bringing this to our attention. Please reach out to [email protected] so we can look into that refund for you! We do want to make sure that has been taken care of!
AP
Amanda P.
Bad experience
Unfortunately, I would not recommend this site or buy from them again based on my experience. I placed an order for two products. One of the products I received was an incorrect item. When I contacted them to resolve this I was told I had to provide photos of the item to prove that it was inaccurate, and they would not ship me the correct item until I returned what they had sent me. They didn’t even have the curtesy to schedule pick up for the item or provide me with a discount code for the inconvenience. All in all I didn’t get my correct item for weeks after the expected delivery since they had to inspect the return before shipping out the correct item. This is not how you do customer service, especially when the fault is on you as the company.
Response from GoodBuy GearJun 15, 2026
We're really sorry about your experience, receiving the wrong item is frustrating, and we understand how disappointing that must have been. Your feedback is genuinely valuable and something we're taking seriously as we continue to improve. You can always reach out to us at [email protected].
TL
Tai L.
Wrong item inside correct box
I ordered a Wayb Pico car seat in “Open Box” condition and when I opened the box, it was a completely different product inside. The box/packaging was correct, but the contents inside definitely wasn’t checked or validated by Goodbuygear. This was unfortunate as I am a returning customer and this experience left me questioning Goodbuygear’s quality control and product management process.
Response from GoodBuy GearMay 28, 2026
We're so sorry to hear this, especially as a returning customer, your trust means everything to us. This isn't our standard and we want to fix it. Please reach out at [email protected] if you have not already.
JJ
Jewel J.
Package didn't arrive and shipping…
Package didn't arrive and shipping company says missing. Please help.
Response from GoodBuy GearMay 20, 2026
Oh no! We're really sorry you're dealing with this! A missing package is the last thing we want for you, and we're absolutely here to help make it right. We just need to hear from you first so we can dig in. Please shoot us an email at [email protected] or file a claim at goodbuygear.com/apps/redo/returns-portal/login and we'll get on it as quickly as we can!
MR
Mio R.
Extremely disappointed in Good Buy Gear
Extremely disappointed in Good Buy Gear.
On April 21, 2026, I purchased a Silver Cross Dune Stroller (2022, Stone Tan, SKU 10007408.1.820) from GoodBuy Gear for $399.99. When it arrived, the canopy - an integral, built-in part of the seat unit - was missing.
I filed a claim with GoodBuy Gear. My claim was denied by a representative named Victoria, who stated that "the listing noted that the canopy was missing." This is false.
I have screenshots of the full listing showing:
- No mention of a missing canopy in the title, description, or condition notes
- A "What's Included" section that lists Rain Cover (Yes), Belly Bar (Yes), and Sun Sail (Yes) - with no disclosure of the canopy being absent
The canopy is not an optional accessory. It is a structural component physically attached to and part of the seat unit. I cannot purchase it from Silver Cross's website as an "accessory" because it's not an accessory. Silver Cross's own product documentation titles the stroller "Dune Chassis & Seat" - the canopy is inseparable from the seat.
Moreover, I checked other listings of the exact same stroller in different colors, and none of them specified that the canopy was included. The listings are exactly the same word for word. Yet those listings included the canopy. One was sold for $295.16 - more than $100 LESS than what I paid, and it was a complete stroller. Another was sold for $379.99 - $20 less than what I paid, yet was also complete. Why did I pay THE MOST for a stroller that was missing an integral part?
GoodBuy Gear sold me an incomplete item without disclosure, then denied my claim based on an inaccurate characterization of the listing. I am requesting either a full refund with a prepaid return label, a replacement of the entire stroller with a canopy included, or a replacement canopy provided at GoodBuy Gear's expense.
Desired Resolution: Full refund OR replacement stroller or canopy shipped at seller's expense.
Response from GoodBuy GearMay 6, 2026
Thank you for taking the time to share this in detail, we hear you, and we understand how frustrating this experience has been. We're sorry for the disappointment this has caused.
Our team has been in touch via email and have reached out with next steps regarding a return. We want to make sure this is resolved for you and ask that you check your inbox and reply at your earliest convenience so we can get this taken care of.
DL
Daniel L.
I ordered a 20” wheel for my daughters…
I ordered a 20” wheel for my daughters woom 4 and was sent a 24” wheel.
Response from GoodBuy GearApr 15, 2026
We are sorry for the mix-up and we appreciate your patience while our team worked to resolve it! We are glad we were able to get you fully refunded and we hope to have another chance to make it up to you.
KC
Katelin C.
Missing front wheels
Received the stroller and it had no front wheels!!!
Response from GoodBuy GearApr 15, 2026
Oh no, a stroller without front wheels is definitely not going to cut it! We are so sorry that happened and we are glad our team was able to get a replacement out to you. We hope the new one is everything you were looking for and that we get the chance to restore your confidence in us!
IG
Ignacio
Spend your bucks elsewhere
AVOID! bought a couple of open-box items from them. One was inaccurate to the advertised item and the other had critical missing parts.
claimed and got a really sweet answer with no action. they argue the missing parts were not described, so lets say you buy an open box stroller but wheels might not be included. had to buy the missing parts in order to make it work....unheard of.
Response from GoodBuy GearMar 25, 2026
Hi Ignacio, we really appreciate you sharing this, even though we know it wasn't the experience you were hoping for. We had our team re-review your claim and the listing, and we're reaching back out to get those wires to you, because that's what making it right looks like. Quality and accuracy are kind of our whole thing, so we take this seriously. Thanks for your patience, and we hope we can turn this one around.