Benjamin S.
Defective Products and no Refunds
Update #3: Wool & Oak, you have not sent me return information or a packing label for the bag I have, nor have you sent tracking information for a replacement. It’s odd that you are spending so much time responding to my review and not following through as you claim to. Your strange responses are however, helpful for my claim with AMEX, so thank you. I’m happy to send all your products back if you send me a packing label. Update #2: Wool & Oak has edited their two previous replies, removing one - demonstrating a lack of transparency. They have also flagged my review as defamatory even though I have emails proving all of my statements and the timeline of events. If you can see this post it is because Trustpilot determined that my review is not defamatory. Update: Wool & Oak has now replied to this review twice. Instead of giving a refund as any reputable company would, they have chosen to publicly call an unhappy customer a liar, defend their shockingly unreasonable policies, and admit to deleting my honest reviews. If this is not proof that the company is one to avoid, I’m not sure what is. If there were a way to share photos and videos on Trustpilot I would gladly share screenshots of the emails they sent me telling me they use “jacket zippers”, the video I sent them showing the defective zipper, and the “troubleshooting video they sent me”. Original Review: I purchased the Duffle Suitcase and was happy when it arrived. When I finally used the bag a couple of weeks later, the zipper broke on the first day of my trip. As soon as I got home I attempted to return the defective bag but they told me I was outside the 14-day return window. The have now refused multiple times to accept a return and process a refund. It's literally the worst customer experience imaginable. Steer Clear. Response to vendor #1: I see that wool &oak replied below and that they are being dishonest. The have yet to actually offer me a replacement. They made “apply for warranty coverage”. They did this after I shared a video and they sent me a “troubleshooting” video that they have produced, presumably because zipper failures are so common. They also explained that they use “jacket zippers” instead of luggage zippers which is a further admission of selling a subpar product. I did not see the 14 day return window and would not have purchased the bag. I didn’t even use the bag in that period as I purchased it for an upcoming trip - which is what I imagine most people might experience. Furthermore, they do not display the review I left in their site and they actively delete the video and photographic evidence I have left in Facebook comments. Additionally they say the warranty is for 30 days and we are now outside of that period so I doubt they will even honor that. I don’t want another bag that will fail while traveling. I believe a full refund is the only appropriate course of action.
Response from Wool & OakJul 17, 2025
#2: Hi Ben, We hope you are well and we are very happy to help you in any way. To clarify again: • You were offered a free replacement under our warranty. We’re still here if you’d like to accept the free replacement. We make sure all of our customers are satisfied as you can see in all of our 5 star reviews. Our team is standing by! We understand this situation has been frustrating. While we stand by our return and warranty policies — which are clearly communicated at checkout and on our site — our intention was always to resolve your issue with fairness. We look forward to assisting you further. Best, Wool & Oak Team! #1: Hi Ben, To clarify for readers: You were offered a free replacement under our warranty — promptly and in good faith — based on the video you provided. You declined this, demanding a refund instead, which we cannot provide outside our clearly stated 14-day return window (visible at checkout, on the product page, and in your confirmation email). We do not use “jacket zippers.” Our bags are equipped with premium, luggage-grade two-way zippers — built for durability and function. We do not remove honest reviews. We only moderate false or misleading claims — especially those that misrepresent our products or policies. We stand by the quality of our bags and the fairness of how this was handled. If you choose to move forward with the free replacement, our team is still here to help. —The Wool & Oak Team



