Wild Idea Buffalo CoReviews of wildideabuffalo.com

4.8633 reviews
Meat, Seafood & Eggs
1575 Valley Drive, Rapid City, South Dakota

Wild Idea Buffalo Co

About Wild Idea Buffalo

Wild Idea Buffalo is unlike any other meat company. We began with a vision of actually improving the eco-system of the Great Plains. Our buffalo are raised on the wide open spaces of South Dakota where they eat only the native grasses beneath their feet. They spend their whole lives roaming freely on thousands of acres, and never see a feedlot or slaughterhouse. The result is better lives for the bison, the restoration of over 100,000 acres of the prairie, and sweet, delicious red meat that is actually good for you. Not such a wild idea after all!

Wild Idea Buffalo Co (wildideabuffalo.com) has 633 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.

Also known as: Wild Idea Buffalo, wildideabuffalo.com
Website: wildideabuffalo.com
Category: Meat, Seafood & Eggs
Location: Rapid City, South Dakota
Listed on Five Star Index: 2026

About these reviews

Replies: The company replied to 3% of reviews.
Latest: Most recent review: September 2026.
Edits: Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score: This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.

How we calculate scores

Is this your business?

Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.

Claim this listing

Wild Idea Buffalo reviews

Showing 7 reviews with 1 star · Clear filters

Harry S.
Sep 30, 2015
very disappointed
meat was bad, packets were punctured and bled out. Steaks tasted sour
Jessie D.
Sep 6, 2015
Meat was not frozen
We received the meat and it was defrosted. Could not consume in a week and gave to friends. We were disappointed in the delivery. We have ordered from Blackwing and vital choice and our items have always arrived completely frozen. Will not order again.
Edmund S Twining I.
Jun 21, 2015
ordered 4 got 3 quality tough
We would never order from them again. Ordered 4 received 3 ribeyes. They were tiny and tough.
sandra & dragan S.
Apr 11, 2015
disappointed
Meat arriver half frozen. Half thawed few things were not even cold to the touch also the ad said 2lbs of free hamburger or ground meat which was nowhere to be found. The rest of the hamburger meat came frozen all together not individually wrapped like the picture showed but that is just a preference not an issue
Response from Wild Idea Buffalo CoApr 14, 2015
Hi Sandra, We appreciate your feedback on your recent purchase and apologize you were not 100% satisfied. Thawing may occur during transit but it is completely safe to refreeze the items. During checkout there is a box to enter discounts and promo codes in order for us to receive them. Our 5 pound ground comes in one solid package but we do offer 3x1 or 4x1 patties. Again, we are sorry for the inconvenience and hope we can make it right for you! Very Best- Cori
Ed L.
Feb 17, 2015
Very disappointing
I sent Wild Idea bison burgers to my brother in law (who is a chef) as a birthday gift. They were very disappointed as they were nothing more than an expensive frozen burger, dried out with no taste. Sadly I will not use your company again.
Gregory H.
Jan 14, 2015
Too Expensive and Website problems
The total (including shipping) for 2.5 lbs. of product was $69.50 (works out to $27.80 per pound). The ad said that they would include 2 lbs. of ground buffalo at no extra cost by entering a code at check out. There was never anywhere on the website to enter the code.
Response from Wild Idea Buffalo CoJan 14, 2015
Gregory- We appreciate your feedback! For future reference, promo codes must be entered during check out as that is the only way we know you have received a special offer. During the check out process on both steps 1 and 2 on the right hand side of the page under "Order Summary" you will see "Have a discount code? Click here to enter it >" Per our email correspondence I am still more than happy to include the 2 free Premium Ground Buffalo in your next order. And please know that your contributions are helping restore the Great Plains one bite at a time! Very Best- The WIB Crew
Steve Protz is the recipient. Pamela Whitaker W.
Dec 12, 2014
Did not receive
two things.....first off, you sent this questionnaire to me - I was the purchaser of the gift to Steve Protz. Second......the gift has not yet been received by him...... I have ordered in the past with no problems.....I am giving only one star today as none of this applies and I am hoping that one star will get someone's attention.
Response from Wild Idea Buffalo CoDec 24, 2014
Pamela- Per your request to ship closer to Christmas, we moved the delivery date back to December 17th as discussed. We apologize that you were asked to give us a review being that the order was not going to you! We hope that Steve was very pleased with not only your thoughtfulness in the gift but also with the product itself. Wishing you a lovely Holiday Season and prosperous New Year! -The WIB Crew

Wild Idea Buffalo CoReviews of wildideabuffalo.com

About Wild Idea Buffalo

About these reviews

More in Meat, Seafood & Eggs

Fresh Farms USA

Great Moose Woodcraft

OC Wild Seafood

Fresh Catch Fish Co.

Wild Idea Buffalo CoReviews of wildideabuffalo.com

Wild Idea Buffalo reviews

very disappointed

Meat was not frozen

ordered 4 got 3 quality tough

disappointed

Very disappointing

Too Expensive and Website problems

Did not receive

About Wild Idea Buffalo

About these reviews

More in Meat, Seafood & Eggs

Fresh Farms USA

Great Moose Woodcraft

OC Wild Seafood

Fresh Catch Fish Co.

Wild Idea Buffalo reviews

very disappointed

Meat was not frozen

ordered 4 got 3 quality tough

disappointed

Very disappointing

Too Expensive and Website problems

Did not receive