matthew K.
cookies to dry
cookies to dry
Response from Top Shelf CookiesJul 17, 2024
Hey Matthew, we'll be in touch!
Heather Yunger didn't take a typical path into the culinary world, it came mostly out of a crazy (but effective) superstition. A superstition for her beloved Boston Bruins meant bringing her signature cookie, Black & Golds, for every home game.
Top Shelf Cookies (topshelfcookies.com) has 323 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listingShowing 6 reviews with 2 stars · Clear filters
matthew K.
cookies to dry
Response from Top Shelf CookiesJul 17, 2024
Hey Matthew, we'll be in touch!
Danny B.
The shipping time was confusing AND disappointing. Because it was not clear when the cookies would actually be delivered, the BIRTHDAY gift arrived three days AFTER the intended celebration. To make matters worse, as we tracked the package (going from Dorchester, MA to Cohasset, MA -- and 11.75 mile distance) we were flabbergasted to learn, as we tracked it on its journey, that it was travelling by way of NH and Maine! What???? Really poor communication.
Response from Top Shelf CookiesJan 30, 2024
Danny, You should be hearing from us to resolve this. It looks like a sorting error with USPS, but we'd like to make it right. Stay tuned for an email from us. Best, Heather
Tricia S.
Cookies tasted stale and not appetizing. Very disappointing.
Response from Top Shelf CookiesJan 8, 2024
Tricia, Sorry to hear this, we'll be reaching out to solve this with you. We work really hard to ensure the freshest product goes out, so we'll work to figure out why this happened and more importantly to give you a better experience!
Liz
Delivery was late so the order did not arrive for my sister’s birthday.
Msboggsy
I ordered 4 different types of cookies. All were very dry and crumbly and had an odd taste. Lard/Crisco maybe?
Response from Top Shelf CookiesOct 12, 2023
Hi- We don’t use Crisco or Lard, the ingredients are listed on the packaging. But clearly you didn’t get the best quality and something went wrong. We will be in touch to figure out how to solve this.
Nell H.
The cookies themselves were great. However most subscriptions you sign up for like this are either 3,6 or 12 months. I did not realize this was an auto renew subscription and got dinged with a second 6-month payment. I had originally purchased a 6 month subscription for my father for christmas. Now I am paying for him to get cookies for a year. Not exactly what I had planned.
Response from Top Shelf CookiesJul 20, 2022
Neil, I reached out to you to see how to best resolve this. Since your original purchase we have updated our software, however there is an acknowledgement at checkout as well as follow up emails that the default was auto renew. We listened to feedback and changed subscription providers and we believe it is easier at purchase and for maintaining subscriptions.