Heather Yunger didn't take a typical path into the culinary world, it came mostly out of a crazy (but effective) superstition. A superstition for her beloved Boston Bruins meant bringing her signature cookie, Black & Golds, for every home game.
Top Shelf Cookies (topshelfcookies.com) has 323 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listingShowing 288 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
Jayne J.
I give two subscriptions each year. The cookies are shipped once a month. Each month they send a new flavor. The recipients rave about the texture and taste of the cookies. Their management team is always available and prepared to assist with any inquiries.
Response from Top Shelf CookiesJun 1, 2022
Thank you for gifting COTM, we are so appreciative and happy to help anytime!
Erin R.
Fantastic shipping. Cookies arrived before I expected them, in prestige condition. Cookies tasted amazing as if they just were baked! Highly recommend for a pick me up for yourself or a gift for other people.
Response from Top Shelf CookiesMay 26, 2022
Thank you so much for the order and for the kind review and your longtime support!
Fran H.
Amazing cookies and even better people. Can't recommend highly enough.
Response from Top Shelf CookiesMay 25, 2022
Thanks so much Fran, we are so appreciative of your longtime support
Ry & K.
Ooooh these cookies are amazing!!! I’ve given these as a monthly gift for past 6 mo and they have been well received. They look forward to each shipment! Will give these again and again as gifts ♥️
Response from Top Shelf CookiesMay 25, 2022
Thanks so much! We really appreciate it! The COTM has been streamlined as well so next time you subscribe it will be clearer about the option to renew.
John G.
We have been subscribing to cookie of the month for over a year now (and have made a few additional orders), and every cookie we've gotten has been thoroughly enjoyable - even flavors I wouldn't normally go for. Issues with ordering, shipping, and managing subscriptions have been few and far between, and the few we've had have been quickly and painlessly resolved. Overall a great business that I am happy to continue supporting!
Response from Top Shelf CookiesMay 25, 2022
Thank you so much for the kind words and the long time support! We are excited that the new subscription software is much more friendly and we are so glad you enjoy trying the new flavors that maybe you wouldn't have picked yourself. That's what we hoped for when we put this together
Christina L.
My Dad and family in Florida has enjoyed receiving their cookies :)
Response from Top Shelf CookiesMay 25, 2022
So glad they are enjoyed. Thank you for your support.
Happy D.
I bought a subscription to Top Shelf Cookies for my father as a gift. He looked forward to receiving his special package every month and always called me to let me know what kind of cookies he received. Great quality and service. Highly recommend.
Response from Top Shelf CookiesMay 25, 2022
We hear this a lot. Life gets so busy and we love to hear that our cookies give people a reason to connect regularly, thank you so much for sharing!
Michael R.
The cookies were fantastic. My son and daughter-in-law enjoyed them during the recovery time after their second son was born. The service was also great and the nice touch of handwrinting the note was greatly appreciated. I would happily recommend them for any occasion that calls for cookies, (are there really any occasions that don't). My only regret is that they ate them all before I could get there :)). I'll have to order more next time. Thank you.
Response from Top Shelf CookiesMay 17, 2022
Thanks for your order and your kind review. We ship all over, so next time treat yourself!
