We believe in do-it-yourself investing. We think controlling your own money can be more rewarding than relying on money managers or robo-advisors who put your portfolio on autopilot.That’s why tastytrade gives you every edge possible with the technology, rates, and support that help you succeed more easily on your own. We’re as serious about your money as you are, and we work for you who are brave enough to take your finances into your own hands.
tastytrade (tastytrade.com) has 599 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.1 out of 5.
Also known as
tastytrade.com
Website
tastytrade.com
Category
Investments & Wealth
Location
Chicago, Illinois
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 97% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
LAMENTABLE!! Tuve la pesima idea de hacer un pequeño fondo en Cripto. Por banco es engorroso desde mi pais. Te retienen los fondos por 30 (TREINTA) dias. Tardan eternidades en contestar cuando lo hacen. Y si lo hacen es con un cierto halo de ironia. Le echan la culpa a la plataforma (sus socios) que terceriza Cryptos y viceversa. Unos desvergonzados. Te contesta un tal MOMO. Se rie en tu cara practicamente. Lo peor que he conocido en Brokers. Sin bancos es imposible irse de ellos...
Response from tastytradeDec 26, 2024
Thanks for your review and sorry to hear about your experience! I've contacted our back office team on your behalf and just sent you an email update.
TM
Tim M.
Customer service is horrible!!
Customer service is horrible!!
Most reps are rude and disgruntle.
You get conflicting information when you call.
They delay deposits and withdrawals.
Dont bother, the cheap commission is not worth the headache with them.
Response from tastytradeOct 16, 2024
Thanks for your review and sorry to hear about your experience!
TH
TH
I am so disappointed in this platform
I am so disappointed in this platform. It is old, difficult to maneuver. It is difficult to get a hold on help. I was hung up on once just asking questions about when my money will be available
The worst is that if you deposit money into TastyTrade, they say they will not allow you to withdrawal the cash in 5 days. However, I’m on day 13 now, and my cash still can’t be withdrawn. I have called them, no answer, and now I will send them my third e-mail requesting my money!
Do not use this company. There are much better run platforms out there- Schwab, ETrade, IBK brokers, just anything else instead of this ridiculous company
Response from tastytradeOct 14, 2024
Thanks for your review and sorry to hear about your experience! If you are still having issues withdrawing, please email [email protected] from your email address on file for assistance.
EQ
Executive Q.
$2000 profit = $12000 loss
I had a profitable week. Made $200
and P/L YTD reflects that.
But account history was edited into a $200 loss.
Any profit you make is flipped into a loss.
For the month, I made $400, P/L shows it.
But cash and buying power is down $1200.
They are reversing trades in account history.
But P/L YTD reveals the scam. They can't edit P/L.
This has been going on for months.
Response from tastytradeOct 14, 2024
Thanks for your review and sorry to hear about this. I've requested more information about your account so we can investigate your issue further, but you have not replied so we can't look deeper into what you are reporting.
CU
customer
Worst customer service and will not admit to errors
The customer service agent, Momo, simply denied what happened. Then in the next paragraph they admitted to it---that a cancelled stop loss order had blocked another limit order without actually working---but said it isn't a glitch.
Apparently cancelled bracket orders just don't get cancelled, but they also don't stop losses, and I should accept that.
It was the most condescending and unconcerned response I have ever received. A horrifying and once in a lifetime experience for me. Not worth the decent UI.
Response from tastytradeSep 9, 2024
Thanks for your review and sorry to hear about your experience. If you have an OCO bracket working, and cancel only one side of it, you will need to cancel the other side before routing an additional order to close the position.
TS
Timo S.
Cant Withdraw
I am very, very disappointed. They charge high fees and then the withdrawal fails. They can't tell me what the problem is. And the next time I try they take another fee... Lost about 100$ and still do not have my money!
The customer service is a joke!
Response from tastytradeJul 31, 2024
Thanks for your review and sorry to hear this! Please email [email protected] for assistance.
DB
Dr. B.
TastlessTrade: Nonfunctional Website
I'm a polite investor with 45 years of experience that never needs customer service. I tried to move over $1M into this so-called brokerage firm Tastytrade while overlooking their completely idiotic name. Are we going to seriously trust our hard earned funds to a brokerage with a name like Tasty? Really? It sounds like porn. But I digress....the problems started with their website that would simply not scroll when trying to fill in the application. How can we be confident in proper trade execution which is all automated, if their simple front end forms don't function? I was able to get through them by changing webpage sizing, but what a hassle! I filled them in completely and submitted them, receiving an automated email reply that I would receive an account approval shortly. A week went by and I received an email asking me to complete my application. Huh? I did that already. But I logged in and filled in blanks, that I had already completed previously, but whatever, and resubmitted. The next day I received an email saying that they rejected my application and didn't want me as a customer with no reason given. Huh? I'm a retired doctor with 5 other brokerage accounts and never need customer service. I've never had disputes or problems with any other brokerage. Tastytrade is a huge incompetent waste of time in my opinion. If you want a really great brokerage, go with Fidelity. Unlike every other brokerage I've dealt with, they offer some of the highest interest rates on your cash, automatically, and their trading platform functions flawlessly, with an intuitive interface. Tastytrade is a junk, broken website in my opinion that I can't trust.
Response from tastytradeJun 21, 2024
Thanks for your review and sorry to hear about your experience!
PB
P B.
negative pl with a profitable strategy
So this broker has a app that is absolutely broken.
stoplosses are not functional, stoploses disappear or are not interactable.
they are slow to place at that. You cant place bracketed orders using the desktop app if you want charts. the order modes that do have bracketing take a lot of time to place and no charts
When you have a sl out you cannot exit a trade without removing it, so if the stock tanks or your power or internet goes out you wont have a sl during this.
they only have whole cent orders and price display, where does the rounding of this go? out of your wallet on every entry and exit. With them being favored to options this is a lot of shares on which you lose rounding.
You cannot place most competitive entry or exit order so on each trade execution you have to pay the spread if you want to get a fill. this could add up to 0.9 of a cent per share per execution, that is 1.8 cents on every share traded which you will lose.
No level two, no tape, just a buggy bid and ask volume that is averaged to whole cents so you have no clue what the price action is doing, they do have the data but it is a choice not to display it.
the charting is so buggy its appalling, charts and indicators move off screen so you cant see them anymore, this leads to assured loses.
Not to mention its just ugly, physically hurts the eyes and unfunctional, settings are constantly forgotten and failing or crossing over with other windows, indicators disappear, charts have a have loading time of 10 20 seconds if they load at all, or the charts load another tickers chart than the one you typed out and have displayed in your order control.
Every time you open the app which is often as it requires reboots multiple time a day you have to make about 60 actions before your charts are readable, the sizing and scaling needs constant adjustments during trading as well increasing workload to a level that disallows you to focus on trading, you are just adjusting windows resizing and positioning the indicators and charts constantly.
often this is bugged and non functional not allowing or really hard to move and/or resize.
charts freeze al the time on any action, including the buying shares and you have a high risk the app freezes all together , and when you are using charts to trade you cant place brackets on entry trading on the desktop charts.
i am just getting told, use another mode without charts to trade on.
There are several other major and minor issues that directly effect trading ability and control.and your sanity.
they have been having these issues for a long time and are aware of them, "they are working on it", yet let me and you trade on a incredibly broken app losing money. whilst they profit.
you cannot trade consistently and the app fights you on almost every move if you want charting.
i have a negative net pl due to these errors, i had really big loses due to the app that are way above risk management because of the limitation and failures of this broker.
they are aware of this yet i wasnt compensated for any of the loses and lost profits that i have documented, let alone for those that i did not capture on screen recordings
insult to injury they are asking me questions as if i was a employee working for them asking for detailed description and information on the issues that they "are working on" instead of just looking themselves.
the apps development is working on these issues they say but they dont appear to have any trading knowledge nor do i feel that their team is very large compared to the tastylive tv stream. They rather outsource information gathering with their clients than testing things themselves, from communications it appears that the IT team is swamped.
a lot of these issues are fairly easy fixes they just dont, instead they are asking me to simply change trading style and strategies as well as asking detailed programmer questions as if i was a unpaid employee.
i spend far over 20 hours in a month doing this hoping they would fix things, yet i just keep getting the "it is in development but we dont have a end date on completion".
after a little searching i found posts saying this very thing from users going years back.
Who knows how many ppl have lost money due to simple bugs that a alpha game would be ashamed for. i for one lost 3% of my portfolio when prior trading results avg me 3%+ gains daily on trades.
Just yesterday i was having outside of trading hour issues, the setting doesnt works and resets back to tif day. i lost about 5 trades that wouldve netted me around 15% scalping them.
this al absolutely destroyed my confidence at that, not that i had any left trading on tastytrade for the duration i have been using them
i spend a couple hundred hours using their app and i cannot tell you how it has effected my trader and personal mental state, i loved trading, now just thinking about trading makes me sick.
Response from tastytradeJun 17, 2024
Thanks for your review and sorry to hear about your experience!