We believe in do-it-yourself investing. We think controlling your own money can be more rewarding than relying on money managers or robo-advisors who put your portfolio on autopilot.That’s why tastytrade gives you every edge possible with the technology, rates, and support that help you succeed more easily on your own. We’re as serious about your money as you are, and we work for you who are brave enough to take your finances into your own hands.
tastytrade (tastytrade.com) has 599 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.1 out of 5.
Also known as
tastytrade.com
Website
tastytrade.com
Category
Investments & Wealth
Location
Chicago, Illinois
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 97% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
Just tried opening an account with Tasty Trade. I did my application and got denied without any reason. I don't care about getting denied. I care about the lack of a response from a brokerage company as to why. I thought it might be because their security question asked me if I had a mortgage and what's the loan cost of that mortgage. I responded I don't.. because I never owned a house.
I reached out via chat support to see if there was anyone to speak with. Chat copied and pasted a reply and immediately ended the chat - like leave us alone we don't need a reason.
Response from tastytradeJun 30, 2025
Thanks for your review and sorry to hear this! Unfortunately we are not able to share the reason if we decide not to move forward with an account application.
LI
Lina
Very very bad broker
Very bad broker. Some mentally ill people. Even chat blocked. Jeff blocked my account. Did not accept my deposits by cryptocurrency. Some kind of nightmare. I am shocked. Blocked banking email address. No humanity, degenerate. Under no circumstances do you start with them.
Response from tastytradeMay 9, 2025
Thanks for your review and sorry to hear about your experience!
JL
Jolanta L.
AVOID, scammers
I opened an account because someone recommended it to me. I didn't check reviews before because I trusted him. I deposited $600. After a few months I withdrew $200 +$45 fee because I am not US client and the transaction went smoothly without any problems. However I never started trading. I needed money and was thinking of withdrawing another $300 but I didn't receive this money in my bank but I was still charged $45 fee and $30 money return fee. When I contacted customer service she/he couldn't explain anything to me. I called my bank and they said they never received such payments. My bank asked for a UETR or PET control number but the Tastytrade representative (name Sasha) couldn't provide it. I have been communicating only with Sasha by email for almost a month. I asked a lot of questions but I didn't get a nice answer, I see that she/he is just making fun of me. Very rude person and not helpful at all. I tried second time with all the correct information, nothing was missing and the same thing happened again. Now I have $151 left in my account. She/he pushes me to fill out a form that she/he could make the transfer wire on my behalf. Of course there's a section where I have to sign so that I don't have any complaints later. But when I asked if the money will really reach my bank account?. She/he said there is no guarantee. That means you have to forget about your money. This company is so cheap that they steal people's money like this. I think that the good reviews here are fake.
Response from tastytradeApr 28, 2025
Thanks for your review and I'm so sorry to hear about the issues trying to wire back to your bank. Our banking team has been trying to assist you in this regards and I'm sorry that you still haven't been able to receive the wire. Please check your email as we are crediting you back the recent wire fee and wire return fees so that you can hopefully initiate a new wire via form and get this money back to your bank.
PP
Patrik P.
Still the worst customer service they…
Still the worst customer service they can offer. And they find no interest in changing it. I have 2 accounts with them one had a 100 bucks margin call the other had money on it. They liquidated about 1500 USD of my position. I had to buy it back losing 20 bucks. Just make it make sense with these guys. Dreading it that a platform that is good has to have the worst customer service.
Response from tastytradeApr 22, 2025
Thanks for your review and sorry to hear about your experience! If you keep your buying power positive at all times, there is very little risk of a liquidation except for expiration risk scenarios.
TE
Ștefan
Couldn't open an account
Couldn't open an account: "Our compliance department made a decision to not support your account. Unfortunately, we do not disclose the reasons associated with their decision. We very much apologize for any inconvenience here and wish you the best."
I have multiple trading accounts at over 8 institutions (interactivebrokers, trading212, etoro, xtb, fidelity, etc) given the fact I'm from UE, and I need to have multiple since most of them are insured only for first 20.000 eur.
I've wanted to open this one for their API, in order to automate some TLT trades, but couldn't, maybe is for the best I wouldn't like to have my money blocked just because a broker wants to ...
Response from tastytradeApr 21, 2025
Thanks for your review and very sorry to hear this!
MH
Mike H.
Please stay away from this broker
Please stay away from this broker , they play with you money for days and after 6 days they put you money in the account
Response from tastytradeJan 9, 2025
Thanks for your review and sorry to hear about your experience. Here is a helpful article on settlement times for ACH deposits:
https://support.tastytrade.com/support/s/solutions/articles/43000435275
JU
Justsomeguy
I was on the platform for over a year
I was on the platform for over a year, during that time the prices in the option chain would randomly freeze, sometimes in the middle of a trade, scary stuff. I reported this to tech support multiple times, waited months, got the usual "we will look into it" and then nothing. It kept happening, sometimes the ticker would freeze too. I sent an email to the CEO who kicked it down to some manager who kicked it to their tech person, the same one i filed the ticket with that didnt feel that the prices freezing was a huge priority. After bringing this rudeness back up to the manager he sent it back to tech support who let slip that their linux client i was using was based on a framework that had become unsupported by its vendor and that they couldnt fix any of the problems with it if they wanted to without rewriting it.
I lost $,$$$'s because of their incompetence causing me to panic while my P/L froze but in reality was moving behind the scenes. As other reviewers have stated and i have related, customer service is atrocious, sometimes i would get this guy on the phone it sounds like he just got out of bed and was in a rush to get to highschool. This broker is a total clownshow. No apologies for shipping a broken linux client without disclosing the fact, no promise to fix anything, just absolute disrespect for their customer and for their field. The CEO should be fired and restaffed at a local McDonalds where he belongs.
P.S. Dont get lured in by their "$10 then free option trades", nothing is free, there is a reason every other broker charges $0.65 to roundtrip a contract. You pay when your go to buy or sell and the price is wildly out of line with what you are being shown in the option chain. I dont want to say what they are doing is illegal but it really appears that what they're doing is illegal. Since then i have moved to IBKR, pay full price for options and get my orders filled at exactly the price that is shown.
Response from tastytradeJan 7, 2025
Thanks for your review and sorry to hear about your experience. We will try better.
WE
wendy
Absolutely the worst at customer…
Absolutely the worst at customer support and customer care. The bottom of the barrel.
Response from tastytradeJan 7, 2025
Thanks for your review and sorry to hear this. We will try better.