Dellareese Y.
Excellent service
Excellent service, delicious product. Received in a timely manner
Find the highest quality italian gourmet products at the lowest prices in our online italian supermarket. Shop for the best, authentic Italian food online at SupermarketItaly.com!
SupermarketItaly.com (supermarketitaly.com) has 257 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.3 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listing
Grocery Stores & Markets · Westville, New Jersey
Excellent

Grocery Stores & Markets · Rutherford, New Jersey
Excellent
Grocery Stores & Markets · East Rutherford, New Jersey
Excellent
Grocery Stores & Markets · Monroe, New Jersey
Excellent
257 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Dellareese Y.
Excellent service, delicious product. Received in a timely manner
Sean
I loved the timing & quality of my products! Thank You All so much!! 🙏🏿
Evgeniya E.
I love Italian oils, spices, and food, and this is the place to find almost everything!
Francis B.
Great products at a fair price. Excellent packaging and shipping. First rate all around.
Maggie J.
Always very pleased with my experience with Supermarket Italy! Even when there’s an issue they’re quick to respond and get it resolved, which I’m very grateful for. Shipping takes a few days to get out but once it does it’s here in a day or two and I live several states away. The products are packed to handle shipping! I’ve bought olive oil, sodas, vinegars, chocolates and more and they have thankfully arrived unscathed.
BARBARA R K.
This company hasn't disappointed me yet. The products are wonderful. Many items are difficult to obtain anywhere else. Great care is taken when packing. I am so grateful to be able to enjoy their website.
shanu T.
Am satisfied with the service provider
Joanne Romagnoli H.
I have been ordering for years. Fortunately never had a problem. The experience I had this past November 2025 will change my dealings. Clearly there is no company. Strictly mail order from different locations. I had $140. Worth of product that was ordered for the holidays crushed and delivered. Literally, boxes looked like a truck ran over everything. No cooperation or assistance. Even after pics were reviewed. Nothing. No follow up. Phone is only an answering service. I’m done. Buyer beware. They don’t stand behind anything.