Find the highest quality italian gourmet products at the lowest prices in our online italian supermarket. Shop for the best, authentic Italian food online at SupermarketItaly.com!
SupermarketItaly.com (supermarketitaly.com) has 257 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.3 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listing
Grocery Stores & Markets · Westville, New Jersey
Excellent
Grocery Stores & Markets · Rutherford, New Jersey
Excellent
Grocery Stores & Markets · East Rutherford, New Jersey
Excellent
Grocery Stores & Markets · Monroe, New Jersey
Excellent
257 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Laura D.
They always have in stock what I need and living in Florida you can’t find the Italian products down here so it’s nice to know it can come from Supermarket Italy orders have always been on time and delivered when they said they would be.
christina C.
An abundance of good products! Delivery is amazing: packaging for shipping is done perfectly with never a damaged product! Been buying through SMI for years and couldn't be more pleased. 100% trust rating!! Mangia!!
Mom of a Rescued G.
With my local supermarket no longer carrying cheese wraps I have been on a mission to find them. Finding them was a happy accident. Skeptical at first I was pleasantly surprised when my order was fulfilled promptly. I have shared my find with others.
D.Rucker
had a minor problem with shipping. they stood behind their product and made it right. very responsive also!
Mrs L.
I have been ordering from Supermarket Italy for years now and to date have never been disappointed. They are the best, great customer service, great selection, prompt shipping, very professional.
Kyle F.
Took about a week for them to process the order, but after that it shipped out and got here quickly. The snacks were really good, we all enjoyed them. The chocolates and desserts were extremely good. Highly recommend any of the chocolates or hazelnut chocolates, Mmm! The 2 year old aged parmesan was very good, but didn't have any mouth numbing effect, which was disappointing, however it was very tasty. I'm sure we'll be back to try more snacks another time. Oh and one other thing, customer service literally got back to my text in less than a minute or so. Alessia really does care and she looked into an issue I had and helped me out, thank you for that! Good to know that there's people behind the screen that do care about you.
Red E.
Everything that I order from supermarket italy has always been fresh the hard cheese is excellent 👌 no matter what I order I have never had any problems the packaging is top notch. They will always be my go to market for authentic food
Lori
I ordered 2 small chubs of mortadella and a Genoa salami. Came nicely packaged with cold packs. Both were delicious.