SugarwishReviews of sugarwish.com

I thought it was cool I could pick my gift. I was excited but I received the cookies today and they’re stale, dry and crumbly. The taste was ok but I’m not impressed at all. I definitely won’t be giving anyone I know a sugarwish gift. It’s definitely the most expensive cookie I’ll ever eat. My grocery store has better cookies than these though. My company should have saved money and given us Amazon gift cards half the cost of these cookies. That would have been appreciated just as much.

While the packaging is really cool the overall experience was very disappointing. Paying that much for a cookie with no flavor, poor texture and fell apart out of the packaging. For that price I would rather go out and purchase some Oreo's that will not fall apart in milk.

More packaging than cookies

I ordered the cookies three weeks ago. And I just received my cookies today 1.8.2025. I had the M&M Snickerdoodle and it was bad. Snickerdoodle should be light in color too but was very dark like over baked. Tasted it and was like eating a bowl of sugar by itself and also tasted like it had raisins in it which I can't stand raisins and stale tasting. I had to throw it out! Pretty disappointing for such an expensive cookie and not good simple ingredients. I was looking forward to get the cookies and thought was going to be really good but nope....definitely will not recommend it others Very disappointing! :' (

Really cool concept but holy crap. $88 for 12 cookies????????? Wow. I found Snackmagic and they are much accommodating to dietary needs, FAR more reasonably priced and the selection is out of this world.

Sugar wish offers a variety of tasty treats in a lovely package. Unfortunately, I found the quantities offered per gift size, somewhat misleading. For example, if you opt to purchase a "large" gift ($56) for the recipient, the site indicates it includes (8) treat options. However, this does NOT hold true if they select popcorn. They will only receive (4) popcorn snacks, each of which are packaged in a fairly small (<4 in?) container. I feel the company could improve transparency on this matter. For me, spending $56 for such a limited quantity of products didnt feel like a good value. I enjoy supporting new businesses, but I am more likely to go back to previous stores I've purchased from that offer a similar service.