sally O.
Everything was defrosted and then the…
Everything was defrosted and then the second time around my cat didn’t like anything. I was so disappointed.

Big Pet Food prioritizes profits over cat health and they pack cat food with preservatives and fillers. Smalls believes cats deserve better and uses natural ingredients and added vitamins and minerals in our food. Our recipes are cooked with minimal processing. After cooking, our recipes are then frozen to maximize freshness and shipped off to happy cats across the country.
Smalls (smalls.com) has 3,851 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.2 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listingShowing 475 reviews with 1 star · Clear filters
sally O.
Everything was defrosted and then the second time around my cat didn’t like anything. I was so disappointed.
Naomi B.
Terrible company. They sign you up for a monthly subscription without your knowledge and then when you asked for a refund of $150, they refuse. I played with them as a 21 year-old taking care of three animals and living on my own with no help that I needed the money for my rent and they also refused. I was hoping to continue to use this company for cheaper and healthy food for my cats but instead got scammed on my money I didn’t have
Response from SmallsDec 30, 2025
I am so sorry to hear about the position this has put you in. We never want that process to feel this way or to put a customer in financial distress. Because Smalls is a subscription-based service, the system is designed to automatically send a full-sized box two weeks after the Sampler. We try to make this clear at checkout and in our "Heads Up" emails, but we recognize that if a customer misses those notifications, the charge feels unauthorized and sudden. Our food is packed with dry ice and scheduled with specific shipping partners to ensure it stays frozen during transit. Because of this logistics chain, we have a cutoff of 8 PM EST on the Thursday before an order ships. Once that deadline passes, the order is sent to our warehouse, and we are physically unable to stop the shipment or refund the perishable contents. Again, we sincerely apologize for any disappointment. However, if further assistance is required, please do not hesitate to reach out to our team.
Laura F.
Not only does my cat not even like the food, they charged my card $116 for a large order that I DID NOT ASK FOR. I had NO intentons of buying again after the sampler order but here I am.. Out $116. I requested a refund and struggled to just cancel this order. Also saw other peoples reviews saying the same thing. Updates to come.
Response from SmallsDec 30, 2025
I hear your frustration loud and clear, and I want to sincerely apologize for the shock and the "unauthorized" feel of that charge. It is discouraging to feel like you’ve been trapped in a subscription when your cat didn’t even enjoy the trial to begin with. When you sign up for a Sampler, it starts a subscription that triggers a full-sized box exactly 2 weeks later. If that window passes without a manual cancellation or update, the system processes the order. We try to be as transparent as possible about this during checkout, but we know that life gets busy. I’m happy to report that you have already received your refund. Nonetheless, we appreciate you giving us a try, even if it wasn't the right fit for your cat 😸
Dena C.
I tried Smalls and my cats refused to eat it. I tried it several days, different flavors, warmed it up, etc and they still wouldn't eat it. I tried to cancel my upcoming order and was told it was too late to cancel, though the package hadn't shipped yet. Customer service response was slow and frankly condescending. I see they have a 100% money back guarantee. I asked about that and have yet to receive a response. I have cancelled my overall subscription and will continue to request that the last shipment be cancelled. Extremely unprofessional.
Response from SmallsDec 30, 2025
I am sincerely sorry for the experience you’ve had. It’s frustrating enough when your cats refuse a new food after you’ve put in the effort to warm it up and try different flavors, but feeling dismissed is never an experience we want for our customers. Our food is packed with dry ice and scheduled with specific shipping partners to ensure it stays frozen during transit. Because of this logistics chain, we have a cutoff of 8 PM EST on the Thursday before an order ships. Once that deadline passes, the order is sent to our warehouse, and we are physically unable to stop the shipment or refund the perishable contents. You are absolutely correct—we do have a 100% Money-Back Guarantee on our Sampler Boxes. If your cats refused the food despite your best efforts, you shouldn't have to pay for that trial. If further assistance is required, do not hesitate to reach out to our team.
Fred S.
BEWARE SMALLS CAT FOOD Just got scammed by Smalls cat food. They over shipped me (subscription) and when I cancelled they charged and shipped me an unwanted carton of frozen cat food. When I complained they said it was too late to cancel. My credit card dispute went through and then I checked Ai : Some customers have reported issues with Smalls cat food, particularly regarding unexpected charges from subscription services that they did not fully understand or authorize. Complaints often mention difficulties in canceling orders and receiving refunds, leading some to feel misled by the company's policy
Response from SmallsDec 30, 2025
I am sorry for the frustration and the feeling that you were misled. This is never our intention, and I understand why seeing an unwanted charge after you thought you had canceled would be upsetting. Because Smalls is a subscription-based service, the system is designed to automatically send a full-sized box two weeks after the Sampler. We try to make this clear at checkout and in our "Heads Up" emails, but we recognize that if a customer misses those notifications, the second charge feels unauthorized and sudden. Our food is packed with dry ice and scheduled with specific shipping partners to ensure it stays frozen during transit. Because of this logistics chain, we have a cutoff of 8 PM EST on the Thursday before an order ships. Once that deadline passes, the order is sent to our warehouse, and we are physically unable to stop the shipment or refund the perishable contents. As a growing company, we take this seriously and are constantly working to improve. Since your dispute has already been through, the financial aspect may be resolved, but we want to ensure your account is handled correctly. Feel free to reach out to our Cat Concierge team for further assistance.
Marianne B.
I would Not Recommend this food for cat owners . Our cat was on this and got horribly constipated. . I have read about numerous cats on smalls having this issue ( after 2 vet appts 900.00) I heard this product was better and changes were made ! Never ever
Response from SmallsDec 24, 2025
I am so deeply sorry to hear about your cat’s experience and the stress of those vet visits. Hearing that your kitty suffered from such severe constipation is heartbreaking, and we take health concerns like this very seriously. While many cats thrive on the high-quality protein in our recipes, every cat’s digestive system is unique. In some cases, the lack of bulk fillers found in traditional kibble—or a cat’s specific hydration needs—can require a unique transition period. However, seeing your cat in distress is the last thing we ever want. We would like the opportunity to look into this further and do what we can to make things right. If you haven't already spoken with us about this specific issue, please reach out to our team.
Christie C.
Two things: My first (sample, test) shipment arrived during a heatwave, and all the samples burst, so I had to wait for my next 'full price' shipment for my Blackie, a Maine Coon, to try it. When he did, he smelled it and turned away with barely a single lick. And he adores EVERYTHING seafood, except for Smalls, which I was willing to pay extra for. I was SO eager to treat him!
Response from SmallsDec 24, 2025
I am so sorry that your experience with us was such a struggle from start to finish. It is heartbreaking to hear that after the frustration of a heatwave ruining your Sampler box, Blackie didn't even give the food a chance. I know how much you were looking forward to treating him to something special, and it’s especially disappointing when they turn up their nose at a premium option. If your first full-price shipment was charged because the Sampler arrived damaged, I want to make sure we’ve made that right for you. We never want our customers paying full price for a test run that didn't start on the right foot. If your kitty truly disliked the food and you haven't been refunded for that initial experience yet, please let us know. We want to ensure that even if the food wasn't a fit for Blackie, your experience with our service is still a positive one!
lesley L.
I wanted to see the prices and shop for the food but your website wont allow that without going through a lengthy quiz about your cats. That should be an option not the only way to view your products. Since this is the only place to buy it other than a pet store far from my house I will be switching foods.
Response from SmallsDec 16, 2025
We’re sorry for the frustration! We understand that some customers just want to see products and pricing quickly, and we appreciate your feedback on this. While our site guides new customers through a questionnaire to help recommend the right recipes for their cats, we know this isn’t ideal for everyone. You can learn more about Smalls, our products, how the subscription works, etc., on our FAQ page here: https://help.smalls.com/ We’re always looking for ways to make the experience smoother, and your input will help inform future updates. We truly wish things had been easier for you.