Laura M.
Broken Promises, Disappearing Features, and Questionable Integrity
Update: very bizarre to me to see a notification from TrustPilot asking me for more information as She Sells wants to verify my review. I can find no “reference number” as asked for and instead, included my original transaction number [transaction: Card Purchase 10/21/2024 She Sells Academy LLC 657-2379487 FL Card ending in 4779]. Should there be any question to the veracity of my review I have a copy of my certificate of completion as well as numerous screenshots and recordings of text messages, deleted comments, and video of Shelby herself describing the benefits of the placement portal (as well as the great deal we were getting on it) before it’s untimely sunset and unfortunate bait and switch. No hard feelings on Shelby or the women who work for her. Many get great results! Fair warning, use discernment before joining! Date of experience is listed as early January of 2025, approximately when the placement portal was switched to the graduate software and there was no mention of it during the Miami Mastermind Weekend. I attended the event as well hoping to receive some kind of accountability from the team, alas there was none. Original Review: I joined SheSells in October of ’24 with high hopes of refining my high-ticket sales skills in a women-led environment. What I found instead was a beautifully packaged program with very little real substance behind it. Coaching was inconsistent at best. Tier exams were frequently canceled, live support was limited, and when coaching did occur, the quality varied widely. The introduction of an AI system (while perhaps convenient for the company) felt like a lazy shortcut, not a legitimate tool for building mastery in a premium sales space. The biggest letdown was the quiet erasure of the Placement Portal, which had been marketed as a revolutionary resource. “You’ll never need to cold DM again,” we were told. By January, it was gone. Replaced with a glorified contact list that still required cold outreach. Anyone who questioned the change saw their posts deleted or received deflective responses. I later learned some graduates were offered refunds or backdoor access if they complained, yet others were left in the dark. That kind of selective integrity speaks volumes. It was also hard to ignore the growing reputation issues. Particularly the controversy involving another female sales community with eerily similar branding. The deeper I looked, the more performative and opportunistic the operation appeared. If you’re drawn in by the aesthetics and promises, I don’t blame you. I was too. But be warned: the polish wears off quickly, and what remains is a program that overpromises, underdelivers, and operates with a questionable compass. This isn’t a community for women who value discernment, depth, or expect professional excellence from leadership. Two stars for the community. The women are truly the magic here.