First off, DO NOT ALLOW TRUSTPILOT TO DICTATE TRUSTWORTHINESS, AS THEY ALLOW FAKE REVIEWS FROM BUYERS COMMITTING FRAUD.We have been Authorized Dealers in the limited edition collectibles world since 2003, with one of the best reputations you can find online!
secretcompassonline.com (secretcompassonline.com) has 81 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.
Website
secretcompassonline.com
Category
Hobbies
Location
Fort Collins, Colorado
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 43% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
I'm honestly not sure about the bad reviews about the company. Most of the time, I receive my items on time. Delays are usually expected but even then, the company doesn't even charge the full amount until they are ready to ship which is reasonable in my opinion.
Shane is always very helpful and responsive. I ordered 20 figures/statues from them which also include JND products which I already received. Looking forward for doing more business with Secretcompass! Cheers!
TD
Tony D.
Secret Compass
Used Secret Compass for many years Shane and his team have gone out of there way to ensure products reach me safely in the UK, also resolved any issues, communication has always been excellent and are a top collectibles distributor would not use anyone else.
PG
Parminder G.
Excellent service
Secret Compass have always gone above and beyond in my long experience purchasing from them. Highly recommended.
DD
Dylan D.
Exceptional service every single time
Exceptional service every single time! I’ve placed multiple orders with Shane and the team, and they’ve consistently delivered impeccable service. Communication is always prompt, friendly, and professional. Shipping is fast, packaging is excellent, and everything arrives exactly as promised. It’s rare to find a company this reliable and attentive — I wouldn’t go anywhere else. Highly recommended!
OL
Olufolake
Great for collectibles.I have shopped…
Great for collectibles.I have shopped several times with secretcompass online .Very helpful team. Fast responses and I was kept up to date with deliveries. Great option to pay in instalments and I love the rewards with purchases. Great stock of collectibles Shane has been fabulous with customer service 👍👍😁😁
GC
Gary C.
Absolutely fantastic customer service
Absolutely fantastic customer service! I ordered Weta Theoden on Snowmane from Secret Compass and the statue was known to have hairline cracks on the leg from the factory and even though mine arrived after Weta's cut off date for replacement, Shane at Secret Compass managed to get a replacement sorted with Weta. Had some other issues that were the fault of Weta but these were also promptly resolved by Shane. Can't recommend Secret Compass enough!
BK
Brett K.
Excellent Seller
The original statue I ordered from Secret Compass was lost by UPS. I contacted Shane and he was very helpful. He refunded me instantly and I bought a different statue directly from them instead of through eBay (though eBay had nothing to do with the missing statue and were very helpful as well). This statue arrived in perfect condition and in a timely manner. I would recommend them to anyone that asked me and I will definitely do business with them again. Thanks Shane !
EB
Enver B.
Fraud experience
Please listen. Never trust this store. 100% fraud. They say something and do something else. They have taken money from me and refusing to refund me without delivering Orders. The name of the guy is Shane. Other buyers be aware of him. I am never gonna buy from him again.
Response from secretcompassonline.comOct 10, 2025
First off, DO NOT ALLOW TRUSTPILOT TO DICTATE TRUSTWORTHINESS, AS THEY ALLOW FAKE REVIEWS FROM BUYERS COMMITTING FRAUD.
This is a fraudulent review, by a buyer committing fraud. "Enver B" originally appeared on ebay and purchased an expensive figure. He then opened a fraudulent claim on ebay stating he never authorized the charge and was given his money back. He was kicked off of ebay for this scam and others, here is his user UD:
ebay User ID: (omxm3871) No longer a Registered User
He has since reappeared on our website with a variety of aliases and addresses and once again attempted to commit fraud, we were notified by Shopify that his latest order was fraud and cancelled the order. The customer threatened to "smash my face" and leave bad reviews, in retaliation for cancelling the order, and somehow--- Trustpilot allows fake reviews from fraudulent buyers while committing fraud. Below are a list of aliases and addresses this POS buyer has used
Mads Hansen
[email protected]
Anirban Banerjee
21, Sambhunath das Lane
Sinthi, Kolkata
700050 Baranagar WB
India
[email protected][email protected]
AN Banerjee
78, Kongensgade
5000 FYN
Denmark