Pie InsuranceReviews of pieinsurance.com

4.3636 reviews
Administration & Services

Pie Insurance

About Pie Insurance

Pie Insurance provides workers’ compensation insurance directly to small businesses. Small business owners can now get a workers' comp quote in 3 minutes — which means getting coverage really is as easy as pie.

Pie Insurance (pieinsurance.com) has 636 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.3 out of 5.

Also known as: pieinsurance.com
Website: pieinsurance.com
Category: Administration & Services
Listed on Five Star Index: 2026

About these reviews

Replies: The company replied to 91% of reviews.
Latest: Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits: Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score: This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.

How we calculate scores

Is this your business?

Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.

Claim this listing

Pie Insurance reviews

636 approved reviews, newest moderated first

CSN
Feb 21, 2022
Exceptional rates
Exceptional rates. Excellent communication. Highly recommended.
Response from Pie InsuranceFeb 25, 2022
Hello CSN, thank you for this 5-star review! We're so glad you were able to save with Pie.
Caroline K.
Feb 21, 2022
The customer service agent was…Friendly and knowledgeable
The customer service agent was knowledgeable and very friendly. She help me solved my request fast and explained other ways to get it done
Response from Pie InsuranceFeb 25, 2022
Hello Caroline, it's our honor to offer you top-tier customer care, thank you for being a part of the Pie family!
Steve G.
Feb 18, 2022
Thank goodness for Pie!
I had been with Travelers for 4 terrible years and was so happy to find an option like Pie!! They were fast, courteous, fair and professional in a way I had not experienced at Travelers.
Response from Pie InsuranceFeb 18, 2022
Hello Steve, thank you for this wonderful five-star review, it is our honor to serve you and your business!
Amanda
Feb 16, 2022
Nacy was wonderful to work with
Nacy was wonderful to work with. Loved the quick responses and great customer service.
Response from Pie InsuranceFeb 16, 2022
Hello Amanda, thank you for this 5-star review! We are honored to serve you and will be sure to pass on your kind words to Nacy.
Lori Christiansen - T.
Feb 14, 2022
Nacy was excellent
Nacy was excellent. Patient as my audit comes up at the end of the year and then I got the dreaded virus. Such a smooth process. So glad that Pie Insurance has brought the audit process in-house. Look forward to working with Pie Insurance forever.
Response from Pie InsuranceFeb 15, 2022
Hello Lori, we are beyond thrilled to hear that your audit process was so smooth and easy, thank you for being part of the Pie family! We'll be sure to share your kind words with Nacy.
Casie S.
Feb 7, 2022
Account Manager
Crystal was professional, friendly & assisted great!
Response from Pie InsuranceFeb 10, 2022
Hello Casie, it's our pleasure to assist you, thank you for your five-star review! We'll be sure to share this with Crystal.
t Z.
Feb 2, 2022
Stay away form this one
this company is total bait and switch. After filling out their application online and receiving a quote, you later come to find out you have been declined. I have perfect credit, zero claims--EVER , been in biz for more than 30 years. Better to stick with a well known insurance carrier. This company probably wouldn't deliver, should something happen.
Response from Pie InsuranceFeb 2, 2022
Hello T.Z., we are very sorry your experience with Pie did not meet your expectations. Online quotes are based on the information provided through our online form, whereas the information disclosed in subsequent calls determines final decisions. Please feel free to give us a call to discuss your concerns further.
Roger H.
Jan 31, 2022
Miss Crystal was very nice in Helping…
Miss Crystal was very nice in Helping me with what I needed to get done thank you
Response from Pie InsuranceFeb 1, 2022
Hello Roger, we are so glad to hear we were able to make your customer care experience a great one! We will be sure to pass your kind words on to Crystal.

Pie InsuranceReviews of pieinsurance.com

About Pie Insurance

About these reviews

More in Administration & Services

Provoiceusa

EZFrontiers

Smartphonefreedomlifestyle

Loft It Up Garage Storage & More

Pie InsuranceReviews of pieinsurance.com

Pie Insurance reviews

Exceptional rates

The customer service agent was…Friendly and knowledgeable

Thank goodness for Pie!

Nacy was wonderful to work with

Nacy was excellent

Account Manager

Stay away form this one

Miss Crystal was very nice in Helping…

About Pie Insurance

About these reviews

More in Administration & Services

Provoiceusa

EZFrontiers

Smartphonefreedomlifestyle

Loft It Up Garage Storage & More

Pie Insurance reviews

Exceptional rates

The customer service agent was…Friendly and knowledgeable

Thank goodness for Pie!

Nacy was wonderful to work with

Nacy was excellent

Account Manager

Stay away form this one

Miss Crystal was very nice in Helping…