Pie InsurancePie Insurance provides workers’ compensation insurance directly to small businesses. Small business owners can now get a workers' comp quote in 3 minutes — which means getting coverage really is as easy as pie.
Pie Insurance (pieinsurance.com) has 636 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.3 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listingAdministration & Services
Excellent
Administration & Services · New York, New York
Excellent
Administration & Services · RIVERTON, Wyoming
Excellent
Administration & Services · Nashville
Excellent
636 approved reviews, newest moderated first
Chuck H.
I honestly can’t thank Bria enough! I’m so appreciative of how she is walking me through this process, I am working with my accountant to get everything she needs to resolve this audit. Working out payments in the meantime is so helpful. Thank you very much. Chuck Hurst
Response from Pie InsuranceMar 31, 2022
Hello Chuck, we're so glad you're happy with the customer care you're receiving, we'll be sure to share your kind words with Bria!
Anna J.
Nacy Sexton was very kind and understanding of a situation that I was facing at the time of my audit. Will love working with her in the future.
Response from Pie InsuranceMar 31, 2022
Hello Anna, we're thrilled that your audit process experience was so positive, we'll be sure to share your kind words with Nacy!
Leon
Hello I'm a licensed general contractor. I reached out to Pie Insurance for workers comp insurance. First the website tried to redirect me to some commercial insurance company not Pie Insurance. Then I called to get clarification and the Pie agent who said his name was Dillian or Daniel and they do not write workers comp insurance for general contractors. Much to my surprise because they advertise on the Pie website that they do write contractors workers comp insurance. Beware of this company because what they advertise and what they tell you on the phone is false advertisement. Bait and switch trying to up sale potential clients to higher insurance rates. Hope this helps out anyone who has the same encounter. Response to Pie Insurance reply. I’ve been a licensed contractor since 1995. And I have never had a injury claim on any project I’ve done or been on. Pie Insurance is still not clarifying what is the criteria for contractors to obtain worker’s comp insurance. Or what is their standard conditions. As I said in my original review it’s a bait and switch operation. Look at Pie Insurance website of how they market to contractors. Beware prospective customers
Response from Pie InsuranceMar 30, 2022
Hello Leon, we’re sorry that we were unable to offer you coverage at this time and that the experience didn’t meet your expectations. While we do cover businesses in the construction industry, we consider many factors to determine whether we can offer coverage to an individual business. In cases where we cannot serve a customer, we share recommendations for other companies who may be able to help. We thank you for your feedback on this process and will work with our third party partners to improve the experience. If you have any further questions, please don’t hesitate to give us a call.
CLW O.
This was my first audit with Pie Insurance and was much easier than other company's audits that we have dealt with in the past. Requested information was straight forward and required documents easy to provide. Data only needed to be entered once instead of repeated entries on multiple screens.
Response from Pie InsuranceMar 31, 2022
Hello CLW Office, thank you for this 5-star review! We're so happy to hear we were able to make your audit process smooth and easy.
Mehran M. R.
The most affordable WC insurance that I've had so far for a second year... Easy fixed monthly payments through my credit card. Easy audit and refund on overpayment... Nicest people to work with... and overall, easy as Pie :)
Response from Pie InsuranceMar 24, 2022
Hello Mehran, we're so glad to hear you've had such a positive experience with Pie, thank you for being a customer!
Pradip P.
The process was smooth and the staff was very responsive.
Response from Pie InsuranceMar 21, 2022
Hello Pradip, thank you for this 5-star review! We're so happy we were able to make your experience as easy as pie.
diane
Nancy Sexton was very patient and kind
Response from Pie InsuranceMar 15, 2022
Hello Diane, thank you for this five-star review! We'll be sure to share your kind words with Nacy.
Nick M.
As a longtime business owner, I have worked with a hand full of insurance companies throughout the years. Pie Insurance truly stands behind their statement "Easy as Pie". I have more time to concentrate on my business and every aspect has been pleasant. Their very kind and professional staff has been the cherry on top. Thanks Pie Insurance!!!
Response from Pie InsuranceMar 15, 2022
Hello Nick, we are honored to serve you — thank you for being a part of the Pie family!