Pie InsuranceReviews of pieinsurance.com

Worst ever. Very unorganized company. Audits were a nightmare. I would submit all requested paperwork, and they would loose it every time. Then they would deduct money from my checking account via ACH, even when I requested in writing not to do so. Then you file appeal. Sometimes you would get your money back, other times you wouldn't. Even after a cancelled they continued to deduct money out of my checking account.

Total scam classic bate and switch, they charge a reasonable fee up front but then “audit “ you and charge 10x . Dont fall for them customer service is out sourced amd just follow a script. worst experience i have ever had. AVOID!!!

During my premium audit, I was disputing said audit because they misclassified me (Owner) as an installer which carried a higher per dollar insurance cost. They charged me the $965 overage during the dispute which is incredibly improper. After realizing they owed me money (plus the $965 they charged me), they said they would apply it as a credit for my current policy. I don't want that, I want Pie Insurance to write me a check for the money I paid over, plus the money you stole from me during the audit dispute. They claim it's not possible. Well, they lost a customer and I would advise anyone to go with another agency. I will also be filing with the Florida Department of Financial Services Division of Consumer Services about this matter.

My husband got injured on the job in August of last year and reported his injury in a timely manner. Paper work after paper work has been submitted from everyone involved since day 1 and til this day he hasn't gotten a dime back for his lost wages. It's going to be almost a year next month and we had to get a lawyer involved. This company will take your money monthly for premium, but will NOT pay your workers when needed. AVOID AT ALL COST.

We were quoted around $2500 for insurance, and after an audit, during which they harassed my office manager many times, they determined that all of my contractors are actually employees and raised by fee to $8000. Then they immediately had a totally different set of auditors contact us to repeat the process. We had Zenith for years, and should have stuck with them, since they never gave us trouble, and the audits were always low stress and nonconfrontational.

Horrific. My employee got hurt 8 weeks ago. We are required to report the injury in a timely manner (which we did!) but we are EIGHT WEEKS post injury and my employee is waiting on a referral STILL. Our adjuster's extension is no longer valid. No one has returned my many emails and voicemails so that I can figure out who is our new adjuster. I just leave voicemails and emails every day and no one ever responds. It should be a CRIME that they can continue to collect my workers comp premium when I can't even get someone to return my calls for EIGHT WEEKS when my employee is in active pain. Criminal. Avoid this company at all costs!!

They just tried to hit my account for $34,000+. My workers comp per month is $130 and I don't have any employees. I emailed them beforehand to try and get them audit docs they needed (as I did miss my original audit deadline) but didn't hear for them for 6 months and then a bill for $34,000+. I wouldn't use them.

They cancelled my Workers' Comp insurance, then charged me for going to a new company. Saying I short termed. They cancelled me. It was also for bogus reasons that they cancelled me. They came back three years later, saying I owed them money. Do not use them