Pet Supplies Stores - Pet Products. Pets Warehouse - 40,000 Online Pet Supplies. Shop Discount Pet Supplies - Long Island Pet Products Pet Supplies Store New York
Pets Warehouse (petswarehouse.com) has 57 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 2.2 out of 5.
Also known as
petswarehouse.com
Website
petswarehouse.com
Category
Pet Stores
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 16% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: September 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
I will NEVER buy from Pets Warehouse. I tried to make an online order with my VISA card, which they list as one of their payment options, but their system said they do not support that "card type." So, I tried a different card and the same thing happened. That seemed very odd. I use them on a regular basis and have NEVER had that happen. I've used my cards several times since then with no problems. Pets Warehouse is a terrible company, and I don't trust their payment system, or trust them to keep my personal info private.
LG
Laurie G.
I ordered three large Kong balls in red…
I ordered three large Kong balls in red and blue as they were shown in a size large and I received three packages of medium balls. They should’ve told me that they did not have the large ones and not assume I wanted the medium ones because the person I ordered this for has a very large dog and would not want the medium ones so I need to send them back but I can’t get a hold of anybody. I don’t think I should have to pay for the return because they sent the wrong thing that I didn’t order.
BP
Blu P.
Ordered a fish tank cover over two…
Ordered a fish tank cover over two months ago for $109. I was told it would be here in 3 to 7 business days but so far it never came and I never even received the email informing me of a delay. This company is horrible, but nothing will be done until us consumers take legal action. We must stop companies like this from taking our money and not delivering on their promises. I am preparing to create a website to stop people like this from taking advantage of hard-working Americans. I will post another Review soon with information on how you can join this pursuit.
Response from Pets WarehouseAug 11, 2025
Thank you for sharing your feedback. At Pets Warehouse, we take all customer concerns seriously and are committed to upholding the trust we’ve earned over more than 50 years in business.
After a thorough internal review, we were unable to locate any order, customer account, or payment matching the details provided—including the alleged $109 fish tank cover. Additionally, we have found no prior inquiries from you in our support system.
That said, if you are able to provide a valid order confirmation or receipt, we would be more than happy to immediately:
Ship the item at no cost, and
Issue a full refund as a gesture of goodwill.
Please contact our customer service team directly at [email protected] so we can assist you promptly.
To our valued customers: We want to assure you that we process thousands of orders each month with care and accuracy. We provide tracking information on all shipments and communicate proactively regarding any delays. Our commitment to customer satisfaction has guided us for over five decades, and we will continue to stand behind the quality of our service.
Unverified and potentially misleading reviews do not reflect the standard of service that the vast majority of our customers experience and trust.
Thank you for your continued support.
-JP
JD
Josephine Diane A.
On the two ocassions thst I’ve had to…
On the two ocassions thst I’ve had to go to your store employees were not knowledgeable about what you carry are not interested in helping and give minimal assistance. You need to employ people that know about pets in general . I asked about a shampoo for dandruff. “ I really don’t think we carry anything for that” as I looked myself I found quite a few shampoos for skin. The reason I asked for help was because I have trouble reading the small print. I asked about a crate and they looked at me like I had two heads. Can you please hire more competent people. I mean I love that we have a pet warehouse it’s convenient but the service at this particular store is sub standard
Response from Pets WarehouseAug 11, 2025
We’re sorry to hear that your experience at Pets Warehouse didn’t meet your expectations. Did you have a chance to visit our Lindenhurst, NY store? Please feel free to reach out to us directly at [email protected]. Our knowledgeable team is always happy to assist with any questions, and if we don’t have an immediate answer, we’ll gladly research it for you to ensure you get the information you need.
RB
Rebecca B.
Purchased two squeaky soccer balls for…
Purchased two squeaky soccer balls for my puppy. The squeaky part was dead within five minutes.
Response from Pets WarehouseAug 11, 2025
We’re sorry to hear you had an issue with your dog toy. Please email us at [email protected], and we’ll be happy to assist you in arranging a replacement with the manufacturer.
TW
Theresa W.
I ordered a top for fish tank over a…
I ordered a top for fish tank over a month ago and still haven't received it. I will never use this company again.
Response from Pets WarehouseAug 11, 2025
When you placed your order, the glass tops were on pre-order. Please contact us at [email protected], and we’ll be happy to assist you. The glass tops are now in stock and ready to ship.
MW
Mark W.
Order two planters
Order two planters. A month later, they state it was delivered by some phony service but it was not. They will not give me a refund. Scam all the way around.
XY
XY
Worst customer service I've ever…
Worst customer service I've ever experienced. They took an order for a door for a reptile cage. The wrong door was sent. I got a refund, however, the replacement door was never sent. I asked for a refund and they REFUSED to give one. The said they would give me credit.
THEY ARE THIEVES! Reporting them to the BBB. Don't waste your time!
They don't even answer their phone!