McGivern DiamondsReviews of overnightdiamonds.com

I’ve been a McGivern customer for over 20 years; I’ve never had less than an extraordinary experience. The difference between a family owned business and other business types is never more obvious. The owner Michael sold me my wife’s engagement ring 20 years ago and the matching band this month; and there have been other diamond purchases in between.His judgement is flawless; often pointing me to a lower price stone that he felt offered greater value. Find that at Zales! William Rohrbach Denville, NJ

McGivern Diamonds has been a great experience! The prices are way below any of the big name shops. The customer service is even better than the prices. The ring I purchased arrived fast and was PERFECT! A little advice before you start, be sure to learn about the 4-Cs.

My husband surprised me with a new wedding/engagement sparkler for our 15-year anniversary. WOW! I cannot express my gratitude for the expertise and time that McGivern took to help us find the perfect ring(s). They took their time, were responsive to what we were looking for and are 100% recommended - small business for the win. Lifetime customer.

My fiancé bought my engagement ring back in the summer of 2022 from McGivern’s. He had a wonderful experience working with them then, and I have recently had a custom wedding ring created by them. After initially receiving the ring the staff and I noticed that it wasn’t the exact fit that we needed with my engagement ring. Michael, the owner, immediately apologized and set his sights on fixing the issue as quickly as possible. He was patient and created as many CAD designs as we needed until we found the exact fix to make the ring perfect. And even though the ring had to be completely remade, there has been no extra charge. I’m so grateful to have had a wonderful family store helping us and I cannot wait to receive my wedding band so I can wear it for the rest of my life!

I can't recommend McGivern's enough. Their customer service, attention to detail, and fair pricing has made me a customer for life. I've entrusted them with all of my jewelry repairs and even the design and construction of my fiancé's engagement ring. You'll only need to do business there once to understand what I mean.

Very responsive on the Chat box and via email. Earrings arrived next day, as promised, and are beautiful.

I have been buying all of my fine jewelry and diamonds from Michael for the last 20 years and would never go anywhere else, even though I no longer live in the area. I compared prices to the best local jewelers here in Columbus, and Michael provided better quality at a better price with exceptional service.

This was my second amazing experience with Mike McGivern. This one came with some challenges on my end with transferring money from one account to the other. Mike was more patient than I deserved on this aspect. Now, let's talk about the stone he chose when I told him what I was looking for. It is absolutely exquisite and beyond my wildest dreams! His work and his customer service NEVER disappoint! I will always take my business to McGivern Diamonds.