McGivern DiamondsReviews of overnightdiamonds.com

I've been shopping around for a loose diamond for over 2 years and finally did my purchase with Mike McGivern. Being that I was shopping for a diamond that is over 2 carat, I was very cautious and selective with the websites I visit, making sure that they are legit and trustworthy. I visited numerous websites and contacted a few of them. Ultimately, I went with McGivern because Mike gave me the best price. My stone & its GIA cert came within a week of my purchase and I brought it into a local GIA certified gemologist who confirmed it as stated on the GIA certificate. It is a beautiful stone and I am very happy and satisfied with the purchase I made with Mike. My purchase transaction online went smoothly and merchandise was received very quickly. I will definitely purchase from McGivern again in the future. Thank you!!

I had been dealing with Mr. McGivern for a few months off and on trying to pick out my engagement ring. He was very patient with me even though I know I was at times a difficult customer. In the end I picked out a diamond and ring that fit my budget and exceeded my expectations. Once the ring arrived it came with all paper work certified by GIA and looked AMAZING...better than the pictures. I could not be more happy with my purchase or the customer service I received from Mr. McGivern. I would not hesitate to use him again and will definitely refer all of my friends and family to use McGivern Diamonds in the future. THANKS! Best Regards, A Satisfied Customer.

My husband purchased my diamond from Mike 12 years ago. That's when buying expensive items on the internet still made you nervous. Everything was perfect. Last week I contacted Mike about upgrading my diamond to 2x the current size. He offered a very reasonable trade-in price for my diamond which helped me get a bigger stone. I sent both my engagement ring and wedding ring to make sure everything fit together and also size both rings down by .5. Once he got the rings he notified me that he would need to replace the entire prong set which meant cutting part of my ring out. I was super nervous but based on my previous experience and the reviews I trusted he would do his very best. Over the course of a week Mike kept me updated and responded quickly to all my emails. I got my rings yesterday and they are so beautiful. I didn't think they would be as gorgeous as they are. My husband is very pleased too. I wish I could attach a picture so you could see for your self. Thank you Mike!!

I called in on a Saturday looking for a little advice as I had never purchased any diamonds or rings before. Unfortunately Michael was not in at the time I called but I received a lot of good information from the person who took my call, but was also advised to email Michael direct as I had a few more specific questions. He replied to me promptly and we continued to email back and forth Saturday, Sunday, and Monday until I was sure that I had the perfect Diamond and the perfect ring. He was more than willing to give me his opinions on things I was looking at and make recommendations that ended up being moreso what I was looking for, yet cost me less money. That is a sign of someone who stands for more than just the final dollar, but more for the service and making sure that I had exactly what I was looking for. I would recommend McGivern to ANYONE looking for High quality Diamonds and Rings at a very reasonable price and service that will blow anyone out of the water.

Very prompt with responses to my inquiries. Very polite and helpful with suggestions. Makes you feel like someone special and they do all they can to make sure you are well pleased. I recommend McGivern Diamonds. The very best!

I wish there was more than just 5 stars because Mike is absolutely amazing, and the quality of the product is second to none. Needless to say I was a bit tense getting everything lined up for the big surprise, and Mike went out of his way to help where he could (options, shipping, etc.). I can’t say much more than: Thank you Mike, amazing products and outstanding service!

My wife designed and bought a ring from Michael about 3 years ago. This past summer it was either lost or stolen while on vacation. She was devastated as we did not have it insured. I decided as a Christmas present I would surprise her by replacing it. I contacted Michael and he had all the info on the lost ring. Not only was he able to replace it almost identically but he also gave me a very fair price and it was delivered in less than a week. No question I would buy another ring from him in fact wouldn't even think of looking elsewhere. His prices are so good that it appraised for almost 3 times what we paid for the original. Don't feel any hesitation in buying from this company online sight unseen.

Michael was very helpful and straightforward with his recommendations. He was a pleasure to deal with! The stone/ring I purchased is beautiful! I would definitely do business with him again!