Jason M.
It’s just AI results you can do yourself
They’re just running stuff through an AI platform and not even bothering to check the results before sending out the images. I sent in a very large resolution image of a damaged photo of a relative - large enough it couldn’t even upload through their site properly. The first “version” of the photo was sent back <24 hour later, with both of his hands mangled by the generative AI results. I replied to the revision request prompt, and <24 hours later a new variant was in Google Drive - they’d simply run it through the software again. The texture on his suit and the colors in the image were completely different. Neither version was remotely close to the actual texture of the original fabric, but that’s not the biggest issue in the world. The fact that one hand still had bizarre fused digits because their automated systems couldn’t process the obvious cigar that was in his hand was not nearly as frustrating as the email asking me to circle where the issue was after submitting cropped screenshots of their version of his hand and the original with the clear cigar in it. The final revision cleaned up the hand somewhat - but it still doesn’t have the actual cigar and it is very clearly generative AI if you zoom in. Also, the finished image is a small 5MP file - because they want you to order prints through them as well. If you can’t find an actual restoration artist, just download one of these AI apps and do it yourself. You’ll save money in the long run, and have at least some control over the results. **Re: MemoryCherish response - I did see the final revision. It looks like he’s holding a long, skinny tootsie roll. It could not more obviously not have been part of the original image - or be more patently out of place with the texture of the rest of the photo. I don’t know if it was with adobe firefly or another program, but it looks very much like someone told a generative AI tool to create a cigar and you stuck it where the old one would have been. And for further clarification, there is zero evidence as far as I could tell that anybody was doing anything manually with this photo - especially given how comically bad the first version was - and the fact that the first revision didn’t just try to correct issues in the photo, it was a version of the photo that had been run through again with wildly different results in color, texture, and mistakes. If you’re suggesting that what you sent me was after somebody looked through it that makes me even more disturbed by what I was sent. In addition, the size of the file that you sent back is absolutely in line with what happened when I ran the same photo through one of those online AI restoration programs out of curiosity - which gave me the same sort of results. I’m sure there are people out there that don’t have an issue with this kind of technology being used for this purpose, I think it pumps out garbage personally, and I would never have paid you guys if that’s what I thought you were going to use. I just think you need to be a lot more honest in your advertising what you’re actually charging people for. You could have also communicated to me if there was an issue with the photo that precluded being able to restore the photo without the heavy use of Generative AI, or if it needed to be sent to a more expensive specialist. Instead, you just ran it through something quick and easy and dropped a file in a Google Drive folder.
Response from MemoryCherishMar 5, 2026
Hi Jason, Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback. I’m truly sorry that your experience felt frustrating — that’s certainly not the outcome we hope for. I did want to clarify one important point regarding the restoration. In the latest revision, the cigar is in fact visible in the image. After your message, our team attempted to reach out to explain how to locate and view the most recent version of the file in the shared folder, but unfortunately we haven’t received a reply yet. It’s possible that you may still be viewing an earlier revision rather than the most recent update. We’d be more than happy to walk you through it and review the image together to make sure you’re seeing the correct version. Our restorations do involve both advanced tools and manual adjustments by artists, and when something doesn’t look right, we absolutely want the opportunity to correct it. Please feel free to reach out to us anytime so we can help clarify this and make sure the restoration meets your expectations. We’re always here to assist. Kind regards, The MemoryCherish Team




