Traditional dating is back in style for selective singlesAt The Matchmaking Company, our decades of matchmaking experience has taught us to stop chasing dating or technology trends, and focus on what really matters - our clients.Here is what we offer our clients.It’s our mission to get to know you, understand your relationship goals, and what you feel is most important in an ideal match. Using our time-tested process, our expert team of Professional Matchmakers will curate potential matches who they think share your key life values, interests, and life goals. With our private and secure process, you can date confidently. Stop wasting time or waiting for love to happen to you. Every Client has a Background ScreeningRelationship-Minded SinglesNo Wasted Time on Fake ProfilesGet Matched on Key Life ValuesYears of Personal Matchmaking SuccessLocal Offices and Local Singles Empower. Date. Find Love. Our matchmakers are passionate about your success and it shows in all they do!Our Company ValuesAuthenticityOur teams pride themselves on not only creating authentic, lasting relationships but also building authentic connections with their clients every step of the matchmaking journey.PassionWe lead with passion and integrity. The business is fueled on the passion of the people who work here, as well as the passionate connections we love creating.ProfessionalWe are a highly qualified team who believe in investing in each other, themselves, and their clients every step of the way to ensure curated lasting introductions.
The Matchmaking Company (matchmakingcompany.com) has 457 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.8 out of 5.
Also known as
matchmakingcompany.com
Website
matchmakingcompany.com
Category
Adult Entertainment
Location
Broken Arrow, Oklahoma
Listed on Five Star Index
2026
About these reviews
Replies
The company replied to 100% of reviews.
Latest
Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits
Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score
This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.
I tried MatchmakingCompany because I liked the idea of a more traditional approach to dating. The thought of having a service focused on finding compatible people sounded more appealing than just endlessly swiping through random profiles. Sites like RCompass.in make it easier to find genuine users and focus on conversations that actually have a chance to become something meaningful. I was hoping a matchmaking service would feel more thoughtful and personalized
Response from The Matchmaking CompanyAug 4, 2026
Arthur, thank you for sharing your feedback. We appreciate you taking the time to write about your experience.
We would like to note that several details in your review make it difficult for us to verify that it reflects an experience with The Matchmaking Company. Our service is a personalized, relationship-focused matchmaking program that is fundamentally different from online dating platforms.
Our matchmakers work one-on-one with each client to understand their relationship goals, values, and preferences before making carefully selected introductions. We strive to provide a thoughtful, personalized experience for every client.
If you are a client of The Matchmaking Company, we would welcome the opportunity to verify your membership and discuss your concerns directly. We are always happy to listen to client feedback and work toward a positive resolution.
ED
Eddie
Great information nice lady.
Great information nice lady.
Response from The Matchmaking CompanyAug 4, 2026
Eddie, thank you for your kind review!
SH
Shane
SCAM! SCAM! SCAM!
MatchMaking is a total scam and a complete waste of money!
I paid thousands of dollars for a service that promised to bring me highly qualified, optimized matches, specifically and professionally picked for me, based on my specific criteria. Even with all of my concerns and reservations, I was told “we have been in business for 40 years and you just need to trust us, trust the process, and you will be very happy”.
This program costs several thousand dollars and that is just to go in to this blindly. If you want to see pictures of your matches first, that will cost you a couple thousand dollars more for that package.
I spent almost two hours with MatchMaking, answering their questions, telling them about me, who I am, what I am looking for, interests, etc. and its like they were not even listening. My matches were NOTHING like what I was looking for. I am an athletic guy with a thin build so I had clearly stated that I am interested in petite, thin, or athletic women. I had even emailed my matchmaker with pictures of my last couple girlfriends and several other pictures of women that I am or would be attracted to. My matches were not any of these in any way. Not even close. I am not at all interested in heavy, thick, big boned, or a few extra pounds. That is not what I am looking for. Am I being picky? Yes, I am. Absolutely. I am looking for a beautiful woman that I want to spend the rest of my life with. I was told “…but you scored a 95 in our system and had some common interests so it should have been a great match”.
One match was in the system for 5 days and one match was in the system for 2 days. Whether they fit my criteria or not, it was basically, “well, here is a new girl. Lets give him this one and see how it goes”.
My first three matches asked me about my career in real estate. I am not, was not, do not, nor am I wanting to get into real estate. Because I had mentioned to matchmaking during the interview process that I owned a duplex that I rehabbed and rented, real estate somehow became my full time profession. It took three matches and three phone calls to MatchMaking to finally have that removed from my profile.
I had left a lengthy voicemail for my matchmaker about my frustrations, not having my information correct (after repeated requests) and not getting the quality of matches I was told I would. They had one last chance and one more match to go.
Now explain to me how this is OK….
I am Christian man, a Conservative man, never been married, brought up in a Cristian Reformed church, went to a Christian school, go to church every week, strong in my faith and looking for someone to match that energy and join me in that part of my life. And yet, somehow, because we scored very high in the system, I was matched with a Russian, Democrat, Atheist who is twice divorced and lives 45 minutes away from me.
“But you both scored very high in our system and you shared some common interests” is what I was told. And “we only provide you with matches. We cannot guarantee you will have a relationship or fall in love. That is up to the individuals”.
Basically your information is put into a computer and given a score regardless of common sense or any personal opinion or input.
This process was NOT what I was led to believe. I paid THOUSANDS of dollars for this service and this is absolutely not the expectation I had or was given. And because they do not offer refunds, their only suggestion was to buy additional matches as they continue to “learn and define” who I am looking for.
You are out of your mind thinking I am going to give you MORE money so you can continue to “learn” about what I want. Absolutely not!
And the only four and five star reviews you see online are because of the friendly staff and nothing to do with the matches they received. Of course they are going to be friendly when they are trying to get that much money from you. Once you sign the contract, that money is GONE.
TOTAL SCAM!!!!
Response from The Matchmaking CompanyAug 4, 2026
Shane, We're sorry to hear that your experience did not meet your expectations.
We appreciate the time you took to provide detailed feedback, and we'd like to clarify a few points for anyone reading your review. Our matchmaking process is not based solely on a computer-generated score. While compatibility tools are one resource available to our Matchmakers, every introduction is individually reviewed using each client's preferences, relationship goals, feedback, and overall compatibility before being presented.
Our process is also intentionally designed to look beyond a single characteristic. While physical preferences are certainly considered, we also evaluate shared values, lifestyle, personality, relationship goals, and long-term compatibility when selecting introductions.
We recognize that not every introduction will result in chemistry, and we understand how disappointing that can be. Matchmaking is an evolving process that relies on client feedback to refine future introductions, and while we strive to make every match a strong one, we cannot guarantee that every introduction will meet every expectation.
We're sorry that our approach did not align with what you were hoping for, but we respectfully disagree with the characterization of our company and the services we provide. We appreciate the opportunity we had to work with you and sincerely wish you the very best in your search for a meaningful relationship.
MA
Mana
The company doesn't provide the service they promise!
hey didn't find even one match for me. On the day I attended their office in WC and signed up for their service, the company representative assured me that they had many highly qualified professional men in their database who would be a good match for me. They specifically stated that, given my age and circumstances, it would not be difficult to find suitable matches and that introductions would be begin promptly. Based on these representations, I agreed to purchase their service and was charged $3500 the same day. However, nearly 3 months have passed, and the company has not introduced a single potential match to me. None of the promises or representations made during the sales process have materialized. The service I was led to believe I was purchasing has not been provided. I am extremely dissatisfied and disappointed with this experience. I paid a substantial amount based on specific assurances regarding the availability of suitable matches and the company's ability to provide introductions. To date, they have failed to deliver the promised services.
Response from The Matchmaking CompanyJul 29, 2026
Mana, we're sorry to hear you're disappointed with your experience.
We want to clarify a few details. We understand you're eager to meet potential matches. Our matchmaking process starts with a few onboarding steps to ensure the best possible experience. This includes completing all required enrollment items before active matchmaking can begin.
Our goal is never to rush introductions but rather to make thoughtful, compatible matches based on each client's preferences and relationship goals. While we understand waiting can be frustrating, we believe that quality introductions are more important than simply making quick introductions.
A member of our management team will be reaching out to you directly to discuss your concerns and review where you are in the process. We value your feedback and hope we can move forward together positively and productively.
RO
Robin
My coach Nancy has been wonderful and…
My coach Nancy has been wonderful and helpful. She took time to get to know me and I feel like she gets that it's difficult to enter the dating world at age 68 after being married for 45 years. I trust her judgement and feel comfortable expressing myself with her. I know I am in a safe place to explore the next chapter of my life. She's the perfect combination of professionalism and kindness.
Response from The Matchmaking CompanyJul 28, 2026
Robin, thank you so much for your heartfelt review.
We're truly honored to be part of this new chapter in your life. After 45 years of marriage, stepping back into the dating world is no small feat, and we're so glad Nancy has provided the support, understanding, and encouragement you deserve.
Taking the time to truly know our clients and creating a safe, comfortable space where they can be themselves is at the heart of what we do.
We wish you all the best as you embrace this exciting new chapter, and we look forward to continuing to support you every step of the way.
WM
Wayne M.
The screening was an asset
The screening was an asset, however the first 2 females did not check ANY of my boxes. It seems like the first 2 were just given to me to give them someone to date, but not for me at all. The 3rd one checked all my boxes and now, one-year later we are married .
Response from The Matchmaking CompanyJul 28, 2026
Wayne, thank you so much for sharing your story!
Congratulations on your marriage! We're thrilled to hear that your third introduction turned out to be the right one.
We appreciate your honest feedback about the process. Matchmaking is a journey, and while not every introduction is the perfect fit, each one and the feedback that comes with it helps us refine the search. We're so happy that the process ultimately led you to someone who checked all the boxes and became your lifelong partner.
Thank you for trusting The Matchmaking Company and for sharing your experience. We wish you both a lifetime of love, happiness, and wonderful memories together!
LO
Leila O.
Very informative
Very informative. Responsive. All questions were answered. Friendly encounter. I wanted to utilize a local company that I can actually speak to in person.
Response from The Matchmaking CompanyJul 22, 2026
Leila, thank you for your wonderful review!
We're so glad to hear you had such a positive experience. Taking the time to answer every question, provide clear information, and make clients feel comfortable is exactly how we want every consultation to feel.
We're especially honored that you chose to work with a local company where you can connect with real people throughout your journey. Thank you for trusting us, and we look forward to supporting you every step of the way!
SS
Steve S.
Awesome experience
Awesome experience. Money well spent. The matchmakers and the dating coaches worked very hard with me to help me be successful.
For other current or potential customers, please remember that being a matchmaker is a very hard job with high burnout. They can't manufacture a perfect match. They do their utmost best to match clients.
In my case, I needed help to be a good match for others - I was doing many things wrong that sabotaged my desire to find love. So they directed me to their relationship coaching service.
From other client feedback about me, they were able to help me see how I needed to change.
Because of their help, I found true love.
For those current and future clients, this is a process. Be open minded and patient. Don't expect perfection because that's an unreasonable expectation.
You're paying a premium for their services. Trust their process. Your outcome will largely depend on you.
Response from The Matchmaking CompanyJul 20, 2026
Steve, thank you for sharing such a thoughtful and heartfelt review.
Your perspective perfectly captures what personalized matchmaking is all about. Finding a meaningful relationship is a journey, and we're grateful that you embraced the process with an open mind, trusted the feedback you received, and invested in your own growth along the way.
We're especially thrilled that your hard work, combined with the support of your matchmakers and dating coaches, led you to find true love. Stories like yours are why we do what we do.
Thank you for your kind words about our team and for encouraging others to trust the process. We wish you and your partner a lifetime of love, happiness, and wonderful adventures together!