Magic Story Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of magicstory.com

Magic Story Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of magicstory.com

Magic Story reviews

459 approved reviews, newest moderated first

Carly
Nov 9, 2025
Beautiful pages rough story line...
The illustrations are beautiful and i love that it includes my son on every page but the story line is a bit scary to my 2 year old who doesn't understand his emotions yet so every other page he goes from sad to happy ...
Response from Magic StoryNov 10, 2025
Hi Carly 💜 Thank you so much for sharing your feedback — we’re thrilled to hear you loved the illustrations and that you saw your son featured throughout his story! ✨ We completely understand that The Emotion Emporium can feel a bit complex for younger readers who are still learning about emotions. We’d love to send you another book that might be a better fit for your son’s age — something a little lighter and more playful! Please reach out to our team at https://help.magicstory.com/contact , and we’ll be happy to help you choose and send a replacement. 💫 Warmly, The Magic Story Team
Report
Anderson and Bodhi S.
Nov 8, 2025
It's what my son thinks that matters
What's really important is how my 5 year old son received it, and it was just id hoped for! He was very excited and even taken back a bit about himself being the main character. It's well written and beautiful illustrated and we are looking forward to our next one. Thank you🙏
Response from Magic StoryNov 9, 2025
We're so happy you and your son love your book.
Report
Ashley S.
Nov 8, 2025
Great gift However limited selection on 1st book
I don’t like the fact I couldn’t pick out of all the different book options on the initial subscription. It only gave me about 8 to pick from and I couldn’t find anywhere to look at more options. We wanted the Dino book as his first book considering it’s his favorite subject currently but we couldn’t. That was really the only thing we didn’t like
Response from Magic StoryNov 9, 2025
Thank you for your feedback! The books we present during the process of creating your subscription are just suggestions from our best sellers. You are able to browse all books and add your child to any of them after you create their character. We will definitely take your feedback into account and try to make it more apparent that you are able to browse the site and select any book during the initial subscription. We'd like to confirm that you are also able to select your next book at any time during your subscription to make sure you're receiving the one you want before each delivery. If you have any additional issues please feel free to reach out to us. We're so happy to have you in the Magic Story family!
Report
Jeshua
Nov 8, 2025
My son's personalized book
My son absolutely loves his book it is AWESOME!!
Response from Magic StoryNov 9, 2025
This is AWESOME! We're so happy your son loves his book!
Report
Kenzly
Nov 8, 2025
Perfect in everyway
Perfect in everyway
Response from Magic StoryNov 12, 2025
Thank you Kenzly! It made our day to read your review. Enjoy your Magic Story!
Report
Patricia D.
Nov 8, 2025
I don’t like to be forced into buying…
I don’t like to be forced into buying subscriptions. I did want to subscribe all I wanted was the book.
Response from Magic StoryNov 8, 2025
Patricia, I'm sorry the purchase resulted in a subscription when you intended to buy one book. The subscription was canceled the same day. I'd like to make sure that addressed your concern and help with anything left unresolved. I've sent you a personal email so we can work through this together. Erik, Magic Story
Report
Kimberly R.
Nov 8, 2025
Great books every one I’ve bought so…
Great books every one I’ve bought so far exceeds my expectations.
Response from Magic StoryNov 9, 2025
This is so great to hear Kimberly! We can't wait for you to receive you next book and hope you continue to enjoy every story.
Report
Duronda
Nov 8, 2025
The adventure of my daughters story…
The adventure of my daughters story book is so fun to read. In fact, I think it might teach me some patience as well! I am excited to see more family members in an adventure story book that they will they will learn from! I definitely recommend for Christmas and Birthday Gifts!!!
Response from Magic StoryNov 9, 2025
Thank you for your feedback! We created Magic Story for parents and kids so it's really encouraging to hear both of you are finding value in the stories. We can't wait to see your other family members in their Magic Stories!
Report