Magic Story Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of magicstory.com

Magic Story Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of magicstory.com

Magic Story reviews

459 approved reviews, newest moderated first

Rhonda
Aug 8, 2026
Beautiful Book
It was very rocky at first but they worked very hard to make it right. Overall the quality of the book I purchased "I Love You Grandma" is Beautiful. The images look very much like the ones that I uploaded. Thank you Magic Story. Please include other names for Grandma as you grow! 😊
Response from Magic StorySep 2, 2026
Rhonda, thank you for sticking with us through the rocky start and for giving the team the chance to make it right. We're really glad the finished "I Love You Grandma" book turned out beautifully and that the illustrations look like the photos you uploaded. Your suggestion about offering more names for Grandma is a good one and we've passed it straight to the team. — The Magic Story Team
Report
MICHELE
Aug 4, 2026
More pictures of the actual baby
More pictures of the actual baby
Response from Magic StorySep 2, 2026
Thank you, Michele! More of the actual child on the page is exactly the kind of feedback we want to hear, and we've passed it along to our illustration team — they're always working on ways to make the likeness stronger. We appreciate you taking the time. — The Magic Story Team
Report
Jeffrey A.
Aug 2, 2026
Imaginative and engaging!
Imaginative and engaging!
Response from Magic StorySep 2, 2026
Thank you, Jeffrey! Imaginative and engaging is exactly what we aim for, so it's great to hear it landed that way. — The Magic Story Team
Report
Mathilde L.
Jul 28, 2026
Commande passée il y a 12 jours et…
Commande passée il y a 12 jours et aucune nouvelle sur l’envoi de celle ci en dehors d’une notification « en transit » depuis 10 jours. Cela semble être une belle arnaque.
Response from Magic StorySep 2, 2026
Mathilde, I'm sorry you were left waiting without a clear update on your order. I'd like to look into the shipment and its final outcome. Please send your order reference privately to [email protected] and mention this review so I can help. Erik, Magic Story
Report
Laura
Jul 27, 2026
Quality exceeded my expectations
Very user friendly Great experience I can't wait to see the next book The quality was beyond my expectations
Response from Magic StorySep 2, 2026
Thank you, Laura! We work hard on both ends of this as an ordering experience that stays simple and a book that feels special when it actually arrives, so hearing the quality beat your expectations means a lot. We hope the next one is every bit as good. — The Magic Story Team
Report
Sarah K.
Jul 27, 2026
I originally got my daughter the…
I originally got my daughter the subscription for her & my granddaughter, with the “I Love Mom” book! They loved it!! I then special ordered the “I Love Dad” book for her husband; another hit!!! They are so excited to receive their books each month & read them to their precious girl!!
Response from Magic StorySep 2, 2026
Sarah, three generations in one review, we love that. So glad both the "I Love Mom" and "I Love Dad" books hit the mark, and that the monthly delivery has turned into something the whole family looks forward to. Thank you for sharing your girls with us. — The Magic Story Team
Report
Amy C.
Jul 26, 2026
True like character
Very well made and illustrated
Response from Magic StorySep 2, 2026
Thank you, Amy! Getting the likeness right is the part we obsess over most, so "true like character" is a lovely thing to read. Thanks for the kind words on the illustration and build quality too. — The Magic Story Team
Report
TJ S.
Jul 26, 2026
My 7 year old loves her book
My 7 year old loves her book. She loves that her name is actually printed in the book.
Response from Magic StorySep 2, 2026
Thank you, TJ! At seven, being the actual star of the book is a very big deal. We're thrilled she's enjoying it. Thanks for taking the time to let us know. — The Magic Story Team
Report