Keystone Puppies Reviews | Read Customer Reviews of keystonepuppies.com

Keystone PuppiesReviews of keystonepuppies.com

4.81,920 reviews
Pet Stores
Mount Joy, Pennsylvania

Call Directions Website

Keystone Puppies

About Keystone Puppies

Founded in 2012, Keystone Puppies is a small, family-owned company dedicated to helping families safely find healthy, well-socialized puppies from reputable dog breeders.We are a trusted online puppy advertising platform that connects responsible breeders with caring families searching for puppies for sale. Our goal is to provide a credible, transparent place where potential pet owners can confidently find their fur-ever companion without uncertainty or risk.At Keystone Puppies, we carefully partner with responsible dog breeders who raise their puppies in clean, nurturing environments and prioritize proper veterinary care, early socialization, and overall health. We believe that well-raised puppies transition more smoothly into their new homes, creating lifelong bonds between pets and families.Through our Accredited Breeder Program, we recognize breeders who go above and beyond state requirements. Accredited breeders offer extended health guarantees, follow higher care standards, and remain committed to continually improving their breeding practices. By incentivizing these higher standards, we work to elevate responsible breeding practices across the industry.As a family-owned business, relationships matter to us. We are hands-on, involved, and committed to transparency, accountability, and improving the experience of buying a puppy online. Families across the United States trust Keystone Puppies to connect them with reputable breeders and healthy puppies raised with care.Every puppy deserves a loving home. Every family deserves peace of mind. Keystone Puppies exists to make that connection possible....safely, responsibly, and confidently.

Keystone Puppies (keystonepuppies.com) has 1,920 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5.

Also known as: keystonepuppies.com
Website: keystonepuppies.com
Category: Pet Stores
Location: Mount Joy, Pennsylvania
Listed on Five Star Index: 2026

About these reviews

Replies: The company replied to 18% of reviews.
Latest: Most recent review: October 2026.
Edits: Reviews are shown as their authors wrote them. The company can reply, but cannot edit them.
Score: This company cannot pay to remove reviews or change its score.

How we calculate scores

Is this your business?

Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.

Claim this listing

More in Pet Stores, Pennsylvania

Keystone Puppies reviews

1,920 approved reviews, newest moderated first

Dr. Dorri C. S.
Jun 16, 2026
The gent that sold me the pup was…honest, helpful and professional in a courteous way. I had a ton of questions and called several times. The process from the first to the purchase - seamless.
The gent that sold me my pup was professional and kind. He returned ALL calls promptly and took time answering EVERY question each time I called. He directed me to the website and helped me with answers about the breed I selected.( Havapoo) and his daughter who greeted us when we arrived (late) from Wash DC was pleasant and kind too. In no time her dad arrived and we were on our way after paperwork in less than 30 minutes.
Response from Keystone PuppiesJun 16, 2026
Thank you for sharing your experience! We know choosing a puppy comes with lots of questions, so we're glad the breeder took the time to provide thorough answers and helped you feel confident. We appreciate your trust in Keystone Puppies and hope you and your new puppy enjoy many happy years together!
Report
Brian S.
Jun 15, 2026
Loved the site
Loved the site, love the breeder, all around great experience and our 2 new additions to the family have been amazing!
Response from Keystone PuppiesJun 16, 2026
Thank you for your kind review! We are happy to hear that you had a great experience with both our website and the breeder. Nothing makes us smile more than knowing that your two new family members have been such a wonderful addition to your home. Wishing you and your growing family many years of love, laughter, and happy memories together!
Report
customer
Jun 15, 2026
Easy to use website and trustworthy…
Easy to use website and trustworthy people to getting a pet from.
Report
Patricia S.
Jun 12, 2026
Breeder was easy to deal with
Breeder was easy to deal with. Called to check on puppy. Like the fact that you include sires photo and size info on parents.
Report
Bailey
Jun 12, 2026
Nabisco / prince
Ms. King was so kind and our puppy was very well taken care of. They had great service and hospitality. I will be recommending a few a my friends that fell in love with our new puppy to keystone puppies.
Report
customer
Jun 8, 2026
They are amazing!
They are amazing!
Report
Johanna
Jun 6, 2026
Knowing that Keystone Puppies vetted…
Knowing that Keystone Puppies vetted gave me comfort. I looked at other adoption sites and found real puppy Mill style treatment for a living creature. I was looking for honest good healthy puppy but not the show dog AKC prices. I'm disabled and couldn't afford those prices from organizes k9 club breeders. I lost my service dog and was looking for a pup to train with the same breed I had. Im on a fixed income. And not going to CA was great as the site had breeders just near me. Thank you for this, it helps the small mom and pop type breeders out, as they are like small Businesses. The notes of visits to breeder were helpful and the health of my pup was amazing. Thank you again for doing what you do for this site, it is appreciated in so many ways.
Response from Keystone PuppiesJun 8, 2026
Thank you so much for taking the time to share your experience. We are truly sorry to hear about the loss of your service dog, and we're honored that Keystone Puppies was able to help you find a new companion during such a difficult time. Your kind words about your appreciation for the small family breeders we work with mean a great deal to our team. Thank you for trusting us. We wish you and your new pup many happy years!
Report
Marissa
Jun 5, 2026
I found my frenchie Bella in PA
I purchased my frenchie puppy Bella, from Abner Fisher through Keystone puppies. They are 100% legit. I received all the proper paperwork, AKC documents, microchip, vaccine records, health guarantee etc. She is now a beautiful happy, healthy girl who’s seven months old. My breeder, Abner is located in an Amish area of PA. We drove down to his farm to pick up Bella and visit with her mom, dad, sisters and brothers. I definitely recommend Keystone Puppies if you’re looking for a reputable breeder!
Response from Keystone PuppiesJun 8, 2026
We are so happy to hear Bella is thriving and has grown into a happy, healthy girl. It's wonderful to know that you felt comfortable throughout the process and that you received all of the information you needed. Thank you for using Keystone Puppies to help connect you with your new companion!
Report