MIKE S.
great customer service, site easy to use, item received as described
customer service was helpful, site was easy to use, item recieved as described, seamless process.
Buy and sell diamond rings and diamond engagement rings with complete confidence.
I DO NOW I DON"T (idonowidont.com) has 299 customer reviews on Five Star Index, with an average rating of 3.6 out of 5.
Is this your business?
Correct your details and reply to customers in public. Both are free.
Claim this listing
Jewelry & Watches · Huntington, New York
Excellent

Jewelry & Watches · New York, New York
Excellent
Jewelry & Watches · New York, New York
Excellent

Jewelry & Watches · Brooklyn, New York
Excellent
Showing 171 reviews with 5 stars · Clear filters
MIKE S.
customer service was helpful, site was easy to use, item recieved as described, seamless process.
Whitney
Great site. Very efficient and effective, if trying to get rid of a ring quickly.
Joseph G.
The overall experience went quite smoothly. Easy to post , customer service available when needed and completion of sale in a timely manner. I would recommend this site
LaK
Had an awful experience trying to sell two engagement rings everywhere else. I reached out to I Do Now I Don't because my ex-fiancé had bought my ring from them. Josh was so helpful. He gave advice, spotlighted my ads, and even advocated for a better offer. I ended up taking their offers on both rings instead of a private seller. My cost was zero and my profit was fair and prompt. Thank you for turning a bad situation into a SMILE!
Kris R.
I had been trying to sell my ring for over year with no luck. My best offers over the year was $6000. I was able to get $10,000 through the website which I was grateful for. I was nervous sending in such an expensive ring but my call with them put me at ease and my check came the next week. I can't be more grateful that I found this site. Thank you I Do Now I Don't!
Shayes
I had a set of $55,000 4 carat diamond studs for sale, I was very hesitant to trust Mark and send my studs for evaluation. After doing research on the company I decided to move forward and accept the overnight label I was sent and ship my diamonds. Mark called me the following afternoon as soon as he received my package and then called me later that day with an offer. His offer was better than any other company I had consulted with and was deposited immediately upon me accepting it. He was fair, honest, prompt and professional. I would definitely recommend I Do Now I Don't and Mark the appraiser. 100% satisfaction, thank you Mark! UPDATE: I just looked back and noticed all the negative reviews and was shocked. I am guessing the company was sold sometime after my review? Please be careful. My experience was excellent with Mark but it appears many others since have not had a good experience. Very unfortunate and not ok!
Michael S.
I was a bit skeptical about this site to begin with but gave it a shot. I listed my ring for sale at a price that a jeweler friend of mine said I would never get. I was eventually offered something close to it and the sale went as easily as it could have gone. I sent off my ring and maybe a week and a half later I received a check for the exact amount (minus their commission). This website provides a perfect forum for the buying and selling of rings and I would recommend it in a heartbeat to any friend that is in the market to buy or sell. Easy 5-star rating. And no, they didn't pay me to write this.
Don W S.
In 2009 I purchased a beautiful diamond ring as a gift from I Do Now I Don't. It was a fantastic purchase...I saved about $1400.00 over the original purchase price. I returned 9 days ago to I Do Now I Don't becuase I wanted to ask my Fiance to marry me. I ordered another beautiful engagement and wedding band set. I estimate that again I paid at least $1400 less than those of equal quality I had been looking at in stores. The service was good and I received the rings today, only 8 days after I placed my order. My Fiance' is estatic and I am very happy and appreciative for I Do Now I don't...I will not tell my Fiance how much I paid....somethings, even in a marriage should be ketp secret..right? ;-) Thanks again, I Do Now I Don't.... Don