Signed up for the VIP both forex and Gold Telegram copy trading. After a little hiccup after I paid for the month, which was maybe my fault as my email kicked back their email. Anyway once I got that all straightened out and got into the VIP and gold Telegram groups, I watched Pat's video on installation and as usual it was the standard EA installation on MT4 and it was a breeze. Today is Friday so I'm not expecting any trades to come through but looking forward to next week and adding to this review. If next week runs smoothly then I will move this review to five stars for sure.
NH
Namo H.
I love that Pat’s team doesn't promise…
I love that Pat’s team doesn't promise overnight riches but instead provides practical, actionable strategies. My profits have been more consistent, and I’ve started to see growth that I didn’t think was possible.
TM
Taziano M.
This group has taken my trading to the…
This group has taken my trading to the next level. What I like most is that it’s not just about making trades; it's about understanding the why behind every move. It's helped me grow as a trader.
TJ
Tommy J.
2 years and NEVER consistent return... only loss
I've been Trade with Pat (aka Forex Robot Nation) since 2023 and have NEVER seen consistent returns. I started with $10k this time last year and since then has resulted in a -16% overall. Dipped to -24% at one point, recovered to +10% but didn't last long. He shows off his mansion so apparently does something right but doesn't share. I would think a $500+ VIP lifetime the signal service would be set-and-forget but apparently he's doing something on the side that he's not sharing through the VIP service. Their (typically) snarky customer service is so unhelpful, once asked about that and they replied "because we know what we're doing". That's fine but you need to communicate that to us. Getting any answer from them is pulling teeth and several times after about 15 exchanges I just gave up. Moving on.
AR
Amanullah R.
Do not buy any signals from this guy
Do not buy any signals from this guy! I just last my FTMO Challenge because of his signals. very bad trade.
Response from Forex Robot NationMar 19, 2025
We have a proven 100% win rate on our gold trades this month. I've received multiple DM's of traders passing their challenges.
If you're doing something wrong with how you are using the signals, email support, no reason for a 1 star review.
FS
flo S.
very bad signals what he shows on YT…
very bad signals what he shows on YT this trades u can not see on this VIP Room, they work together with Brokers
Response from Forex Robot NationMar 6, 2025
This is again, not a client (likely competitor).
Proof:
https://imgur.com/a/VNFuZNJ
Our signals have been incredibly positive for over 4 years running the service. I do show some of the VIP trades on YT. It really depends on the video, and what that video is about. Not every video is the same.
OT
OBI T.
Prepare Yourself For SL
It has been unprofitable for 2 weeks in a row, and I lost my money and money for the subscription. Bad signals and money management. How does it keep hitting SL on the forex signals? Gold is good, but Forex signals are rubbish and not worth it. It's the Gold win rate that makes his overall win rate look high. His forex win rate is probably 40%. The profit-to-loss ratio for TP1 is 1:2, so you need 2 wins to break even if you have a loss. Also, avoid TP2 on his signals or move TP2 to breakeven after TP1 is hit. He barely gets TP2, and if it reaches your stop loss, you lose your money from TP1 and even more money. AVOID AVOID AVOID. I had to trade myself to make my money back. I wanted to use this as a hedge/passive income, but what I got was a passive loss.
EDIT:
Of course, I used a different email to avoid retaliation. I've been a client since January. You just started managing trades better and adjusting the SL level after I made this review. I wish I could upload an image, but I'll give today's trade example below. It's the worst risk-to-reward for a trader that only gets TP1 often. Don't be lazy when people are paying for a service. You don't normally move SL after TP1. You didn't even keep to the number of trades per day this week on the agreement. I Waisted a week on my money.
XAU/USD Potential Upward Movement
Buy Market Order at 2900.91
Target Profit 1 at 2905.61
Target Profit 2 at 2918.86
Stop Loss at 2891.40
Trade safely!
Response from Forex Robot NationMar 6, 2025
The service has been running successfully for over 4 years.
Providing profit for our clients.
I'm sorry that you didn't like the service in your 2 weeks (even though I can't find you as an actual client), but the numbers you are providing are all false.
LD
Lodewijk de B.
What a dogshit calls
What a dogshit calls. They put a 12 pip SL for a 6 pip TP. Also they lost a few trades in a row and delete the trade so it never happened. Yesterday the XAUUSD trade hit SL and still no message, like it never happened. My suggestion, go learn how to trade yourself, I ve been member for 2 months and im not even breakeven with these guys, their calls arent even the worst but their trade management is, they tell you to manually stop trade while they go 3R and they tell you to keep trade while they hit your SL. Again, dogshit trades, you wont make money. The stats online are fake, the stats in telegram are fake also.
Reply to your reply.. You are a liar. The XAUUSD call never got reported, also de USDJPY call didnt get reported. This week was NOT profit like you send in your end of the week report, you made it seem like it was profit. When you win 7 pips in a trade whihc is 0.5 R and you lose 3 times 1 R its not profit. I hope you know that. This is one of the many bullshit signal telegram groups. You guys should NOT buy this, and also dont buy an other. Go learn a strategy, you'll be way more profitable then when you are lucky with these scam signals to get 1r in the week profit. Dont fall for it, there is no get rich fast way. Have a good one.
Response from Forex Robot NationFeb 26, 2025
We have never deleted a trade. This is simply untrue, and cannot be proven, because it never happened.
We report all trades.
If a trade isn't reported the moment it closes, it will still be in the end of week or end of month report.
We've been doing this over 4 years, and will continue to provide quality signals for our members.